The New York Jets are staring down a significant offseason challenge: addressing their quarterback situation. Among the potential candidates, Kyler Murray stands out as a high-profile option.
Recently, a trade proposal was floated by ESPN’s Bill Barnwell, suggesting a deal that could bring Murray to the Big Apple:
Jets receive: QB Kyler Murray, 2026 sixth-round pick
Cardinals receive: 2026 fourth-round pick
By the midpoint of the 2025 season, it was apparent that the Cardinals were ready to move on from Murray. His persistent foot injury led to him being placed on injured reserve, leaving Jacoby Brissett to step up, who performed admirably and remains under contract for 2026. With a new coaching staff in Arizona, the decision to part ways with their franchise quarterback ultimately rests with ownership.
Arizona faces a dilemma in securing a substantial trade return for Murray. His hefty salary-over $78 million combined for 2026 and 2027-limits potential suitors. Teams like the Vikings and Browns face salary cap constraints, while others like the Falcons, Raiders, Colts, and Steelers have different priorities or system fits.
This narrows the field to the Dolphins and Jets. While Miami is undergoing a reboot after parting ways with Mike McDaniel and dealing with Tua Tagovailoa's contract, the Jets are in a position to make a stronger push for Murray. Miami's current trajectory doesn't align with adding a quarterback like Murray, as they aren't just a QB away from contention.
However, there's skepticism about the wisdom of this move for the Jets. Murray’s appeal largely stems from his college accolades and status as a former No. 1 pick.
Yet, his performance metrics tell a different story. In three of his last four seasons, his QBR has dipped below 55, with two seasons under 50.
As he approaches 30, relying heavily on speed and athleticism, combined with recovering from a foot injury, there are significant concerns.
Moreover, Murray's contract poses challenges. The acquiring team would be on the hook for around $60 million in guarantees unless renegotiated.
If Murray were released and available at a bargain, the Jets’ interest might be justifiable. But given the circumstances, parting with a valuable early fourth-round pick-especially when it’s their sole pick between 44 and 175-seems unwise.
These mid-round selections are crucial for finding quality starters and role players.
Ultimately, this proposed trade feels like an attempt to solve a problem on paper without addressing the underlying issues. The Jets need to be cautious about viewing Murray as a quick fix when the reality may be far more complex.