Jets Early Draft Returns Are Shaping One Big Makai Lemon Debate

The Jets' controversial draft choice is showing early signs of paying off as their rookies outshine a top wide receiver pick.

The Jets passed on the wideout many fans wanted, and early on, that choice is looking a lot better.

New York went into the 2026 NFL Draft with the No. 16 overall pick and plenty of pressure attached to it. A chunk of the fan base wanted USC receiver Makai Lemon.

Darren Mougey went a different direction, taking Oregon tight end Kenyon Sadiq at No. 16 and then adding Indiana receiver Omar Cooper Jr. at No. 30.

Lemon didn’t last much longer, going No. 20 overall to the Philadelphia Eagles after they traded up for him. That sparked the kind of immediate regret that usually follows a favorite prospect landing elsewhere. But three games into the season, the early numbers are giving the Jets reason to feel good about how they handled the board.

Lemon has played a solid share of snaps for Philadelphia, but the production hasn’t followed. He has been targeted eight times from scrimmage and has only 33 yards to show for it.

The fit hasn’t helped, and he has reportedly been getting open more than the box score suggests, but the concerns that followed him into the draft are still hanging around. His lack of top-end speed and physicality at the line of scrimmage were questioned before the draft, and those issues seem to be showing up now.

Add in the fact that he missed a chunk of the offseason program with an injury and hasn’t looked fully like himself, and the Eagles haven’t gotten the immediate burst many expected.

Cooper’s start has been limited by injury, too, but the flashes have been there. He logged only one drive in the opener before getting hurt, and he has 30 yards so far.

Even so, his 30-yard catch in a win over the Tennessee Titans showed exactly why New York wanted him: the run-after-catch juice, the toughness, the hard-driving style that made him a national champion at Indiana. He was never going to slide to the second round, and once he’s healthy, he’s expected to move right back into the starting lineup.

Sadiq, meanwhile, is starting to look like the kind of pick that can change the shape of this offense. He also dealt with an offseason injury, but he erupted in the Week 3 shootout against the Detroit Lions.

After never reaching 100 receiving yards in a college game at Oregon, he delivered seven catches for 105 yards and his first NFL touchdown. The score came on a wild grab, with Sadiq nearly parallel to the turf to haul it in.

If Cooper keeps building, Sadiq keeps ascending, and Adonai Mitchell’s fast start holds up, the Jets could wind up with four skill players they trust for the future.

Mougey has taken his lumps before, but on this decision, the early returns suggest New York got it right by staying away from Lemon at No. 16.

In Other News...

Jets Suddenly Have A Real Nahshon Wright Problem In The Secondary

Nahshon Wrights start with the Jets has gone from low-key to hard to ignore. The veteran cornerback arrived on a $3.5 million guaranteed deal, but early in the season he has barely seen the field, and in a recent game he was a healthy scratch while rookie DAngelo Ponds got his first NFL action. For a team that is always trying to sort out the back end of its defense, that kind of usage says plenty about where Wright stands right now.

The bigger question is what comes next, because the Jets did not bring him in to be an afterthought. When a veteran corner is active in name only and a rookie is already getting a look, it naturally raises concerns about depth, roster construction and whether the team has another awkward cornerback situation developing. It is the sort of subplot that can linger for a while in New York, especially with the memory of former Jet Dmitri Patterson still offering a cautionary comparison. [Read more 🡒]

Jets Win Just Took On A Much Darker Meaning For Packers Fans

The Packers Week 2 loss to the Jets carried an added cost beyond the final score, because Jayden Reed is now headed to injured reserve with a neck injury suffered on the second play of that game. For Green Bay, it turns a routine early-season setback into something more serious, as one of its most important pass catchers now faces an extended absence with no return timeline attached.

Reeds absence forces the Packers to reshuffle both their roster and their game plan at a time when they were still settling in offensively. For Jets fans, the win already had the usual satisfaction of a Sunday result, but now it comes with a harsher afterglow for Green Bay, where the injury from that game has become the bigger story. [Read more 🡒]

Jets Players Are Already Sending A Clear Message About Geno Smith

Geno Smiths early run has given the Jets at least one stable storyline in a season that still feels very much in flux. Through three weeks, he has piled up 783 passing yards, thrown four touchdowns and avoided interceptions, and that kind of start has not gone unnoticed in the locker room. Tight end Jeremy Ruckert has already spoken up about Smiths leadership and the way he has handled the offense, a meaningful endorsement for a team trying to find its footing.

The Jets are still sitting at 1-2, which keeps the bigger picture from feeling settled no matter how well Smith has played. If the season continues to tilt away from the playoff race, the conversation around the quarterback room could get louder, especially with some fans already looking ahead to rookie Cade Klubnik getting a chance if the team is out of contention. For now, though, Smiths play is making it hard to ignore the message coming from inside the building. [Read more 🡒]