Cade Klubnik has done enough this preseason to make the New York Jets feel good about their fourth-round pick. He has not, at least yet, done enough to close the door on a veteran backup.
That’s the tension hanging over the Jets as cutdown day approaches. Klubnik is the clear internal favorite for the QB2 job behind Geno Smith after two preseason games, but the question is whether the team can really afford to go into the regular season with only that level of insurance.
Through two exhibition games, Klubnik has gone 15 of 21 for 138 yards, with no touchdowns and no interceptions. He was efficient in the opener against Tampa Bay, when Smith sat out because of foot soreness, completing five of seven passes for 56 yards and helping drive the offense to points on both of his possessions.
The Steelers game was more uneven, though still clean. Klubnik didn’t make any glaring mistakes, and he also didn’t stack together many big-time throws.
Even so, there were a few moments that stood out. One came on a third down when the pocket broke down inside the Jets’ own 20-yard line, but Klubnik stayed poised and fired into a tight window to Isaiah Williams.
The ball slipped through Williams’ hands, but the throw itself showed real conviction under pressure.
He also flashed timing on a third-and-10 throw, identifying a one-on-one matchup and getting the ball out to Malik McClain as he broke into his route. And on third-and-two inside the Jets’ own 15, he escaped pressure and turned it into a 16-yard scramble for a first down.
What hasn’t shown up much yet is the deep ball. That’s notable because Klubnik’s 2024 college season was built in part on that part of his game.
He completed 35 passes of 20 yards or more, third-most in the NCAA, behind only Jaxson Dart’s 37 and Cam Ward’s 34. Dart and Ward were first-round picks in 2025, with Ward going No. 1 overall.
The circumstances around Klubnik’s two preseason outings also matter. The opener was smoother because he worked with the Jets’ starting offense.
Against Pittsburgh, he was under much more heat, getting pressured six times on 14 dropbacks, a 43% pressure rate, compared to twice on eight dropbacks, or 25%, in the first game. The backup line clearly didn’t give him much help.
Still, the Jets’ internal pecking order is not complicated. They traded up for Klubnik in the fourth round, and Bailey Zappe and Brady Cook have not given the team much reason to hesitate. Both have thrown more career interceptions than touchdowns, and Cook’s four starts at the end of the Jets’ 2025 season were among the worst quarterback play Gang Green has seen.
The bigger issue is not who leads the backup competition right now. It’s whether that should be enough for the Jets to stop looking.
There’s a case for letting Klubnik be the guy if Smith misses time. That would give the team a live evaluation of the rookie and maybe help clarify his long-term future. It would not change the fact that the Jets could still be hunting for a quarterback high in the 2027 NFL draft, but it could tell them whether Klubnik can truly become the team’s QB2.
There’s also a much more practical concern: if Smith goes down while the Jets are in the middle of a competitive season, is Klubnik ready to keep the offense afloat?
That’s where the veteran market comes in. If the Jets are 2-1 or even 1-2 in Week 3 and Smith misses two weeks with a minor injury, bringing in an experienced quarterback makes sense.
If the season has already gone sideways by around Week 13, then turning to Klubnik would be the logical move. At that point, chasing a veteran would not.
That’s why Andy Dalton is a name worth watching if he becomes available around cutdown day. He’s not guaranteed a roster spot with the Philadelphia Eagles, where he’s competing with Tanner McKee for the backup job and rookie developmental option Cole Payton is also in the mix.
Dalton, 38, has been around long enough to know the role. Since being drafted in the second round in 2011, he has made 169 career starts and owns an 84-83-2 record. He spent last season with the Carolina Panthers, where he appeared in 13 games and made seven starts, completing 64.7% of his passes for 1,643 yards, 10 touchdowns and seven interceptions.
Carolina went 1-6 in his starts, but that record was tied to a shaky supporting cast. The production itself was more than enough to look like a real QB2 option, and certainly more established than anything the Jets have on hand right now. Dalton also has a tie to New York’s coaching staff, having played under offensive coordinator Frank Reich in Carolina in 2023.
The Jets do not need to spend assets to chase a backup quarterback. But Klubnik’s preseason has not been so dominant that the team should ignore the cutdown-day market. If Dalton or a comparable veteran shakes free, the Jets should be ready to pounce.
In Other News...
Jets Have An Early Problem In The Middle Of Their Defense
David Onyemata was brought in to help steady the middle of the Jets defense, especially against the run, after that area proved vulnerable last season. Instead, the preseason has opened with a rough stretch for the veteran lineman, who has earned the lowest Pro Football Focus grade on the team so far and has not yet looked like the immediate upgrade the Jets were counting on.
The good news for New York is that the depth chart is not completely locked in behind him, and the team does have other defensive line options waiting if the early issues carry over into the regular season. T'Vondre Sweat and Jowon Briggs are among the names the Jets can turn to, which gives them some flexibility, but it also makes Onyematas next few weeks more important as he tries to settle in and justify the starting job. [Read more 🡒]
Jets Rookie Omar Cooper Jr Suddenly Has Real WR3 Momentum
The Jets are still sorting out their wide receiver depth, and the battle for the third spot has become one of the more interesting things to watch in camp. Rookie Omar Cooper Jr. entered the first preseason game as a backup, but by the next one he was taking first-team reps with the starting offense, a sign that his stock is moving in the right direction as the team continues to evaluate its options.
Isaiah Williams remains in the mix, but his fumble in the second preseason game did not help a competition that already looked tight. The Jets have not made a decision on WR3 yet, and that uncertainty keeps this race open, but Coopers growing involvement suggests he is very much a strong candidate as the roster picture starts to come into focus. [Read more 🡒]
Jets Just Changed Who Gets A Real Shot Before Cutdown Day
The final week of the preseason brought a small roster shuffle for the Jets, who signed three undrafted free agents in Anthony Dunn, Dominic Richardson and Tanner Wall while waiving Caullin Lacy, Sam Scott and Nate Voorhis, all of whom were dealing with injuries. It is the kind of late-August move that can get overlooked, but for players on the fringe, every open practice rep matters at this stage of camp.
With the preseason finale against the Giants on deck, the new arrivals now have a narrow window to make their case for a roster spot or at least a place on the practice squad. For the Jets, it is another reminder that cutdown season is as much about opportunity as it is about attrition, and the next few days will determine whether this batch of newcomers gets a real look or simply serves as one more temporary layer of depth. [Read more 🡒]