Keith Hernandez didn’t exactly hide his frustration with the Mets on Wednesday, and the target of that frustration was impossible to miss: first base.
During New York’s game against the Milwaukee Brewers, Hernandez used a 0-0 tie in the top of the second inning to fire off a blunt critique of how the position is being valued.
"Seems like today's game, they don't give first base enough credit. Certainly, the Mets don't" - Keith Hernandez pic.twitter.com/2s0varbByF
- Awful Announcing (@awfulannouncing) July 22, 2026
The comment landed like more than a passing broadcast gripe. It sounded like a shot at the Mets’ decision to let Pete Alonso go, and maybe just as much at the idea that Mark Vientos could handle the job. Hernandez doesn’t seem remotely close to getting over that call.
The numbers behind Alonso’s defense only sharpen the point. At the time of Hernandez’s remark, Alonso had a 4 OAA this year for the Baltimore Orioles, and among qualified first basemen, only Ty France had graded out better in that stat.
That kind of production helps explain why Hernandez has kept circling back to the subject. He has every credential to do it, too. With a Gold Glove-laden résumé and a reputation as maybe the best player ever to field the position, Hernandez has plenty of authority when he talks first base.
Alonso has long carried the label of a shaky defender because of his range and, more notably, his throwing. But his work scooping balls was elite, and his bat made any defensive flaw easier to live with. Hernandez appears to see it the same way, believing Alonso was good enough at the position to justify keeping him.
He has been far more complimentary when discussing Jared Young, praising the way he has handled first base more often than not. Vientos, though, has not drawn the same kind of praise. When he’s involved in a play, it becomes a tense moment.
That gap matters whether you lean on the eye test or the metrics. Vientos at -9 OAA has matched Alonso’s mark from last year and the year before, and each of those seasons was Alonso’s worst by that measure.
But Hernandez’s irritation may be aimed at something even bigger than Alonso versus Vientos. The Mets’ first-base plan has been a mess from the start.
They let Alonso walk, Vientos hasn’t been able to settle in at the spot, and Jorge Polanco was signed with the intention of learning first base before an injury limited him to two games there. He may not be back at the position for a while.
For a Mets club that has talked plenty about run prevention, the whole setup looks like a contradiction. Hernandez clearly sees it that way, and Wednesday’s comment made that plain. If that was enough to set him off, the Orioles’ visit in September could be even more interesting.
In Other News...
Islanders May Be Waiting Too Long To Trade One Veteran Center
The Islanders have spent the offseason weighing how to squeeze more flexibility out of a roster that still has a few useful veterans attached to meaningful cap hits, and the conversation around Jean-Gabriel Pageau fits right into that larger puzzle. His recent performance and the likelihood of a reduced role have made him a logical name to watch, especially for a team trying to balance present competitiveness with a cleaner path forward.
What makes the timing interesting is that the market may be friendlier now than it will be later, when a player with his profile is more clearly slotted into a smaller role. If New York decides to act while there is still demand, the payoff could be more than just financial breathing room, with the chance to add future assets and give the front office more room to maneuver as it reshapes the roster. [Read more 🡒]
Pete DeBoer Just Named The Islanders' Path Back To The Playoffs
Pete DeBoer did not spend much time sugarcoating the Islanders path back to relevance. In a TSN interview, the new head coach pointed to two areas that have to improve if the club is going to get back to the Stanley Cup Playoffs: a power play that lagged badly last season and a defensive structure that allowed too many dangerous looks against.
For DeBoer, the encouraging part is that neither problem feels permanent if the roster is right and the details sharpen up. He said quick turnarounds are possible in the NHL, and from the Islanders perspective that matters because last seasons miss was not framed as a talent shortage so much as a team that left too much on the table in the key moments that decide games. [Read more 🡒]
Islanders Interest In Patrik Laine Says Plenty About Their Offseason
Patrik Laines unsigned status has become one of the more notable offseason lingerers, and the Islanders name surfacing in the conversation says plenty about how teams are weighing his fit. A fully healthy Laine still brings obvious upside, especially on the power play, where his finishing ability can change the look of a unit in a hurry. But with the market slow to develop and only a few clubs even loosely tied to him, the question has shifted from talent to how much a team is willing to commit for that kind of specialized scoring.
For the Islanders, the fit is complicated by a forward group that already looks crowded, which makes any real pursuit harder to see. The Kings have been the other club most credibly linked, though even that remains murky, and the longer Laine stays on the market, the more this starts to feel like a test of patience as much as roster need. What remains unresolved is whether a team will eventually step up with more than a low-risk look and give him the kind of opportunity his track record suggests he can still justify. [Read more 🡒]