Semyon Varlamov’s road back to an NHL win finally ended in Nashville, and the Islanders made sure the payoff came with a little extra celebration. On Tuesday night, Varlamov backstopped a 4-3 shootout victory over the Predators, capping a comeback that had stretched 712 days and carried him through two partial knee replacements, two conditioning starts with the Bridgeport Islanders last April and a pile of rehab work along the way.
Varlamov handled 20 of 23 shots and shut the door in the shootout, including a sharp poke check on Ryan O’Reilly. Kyle Palmieri then delivered the deciding shootout goal, with Bo Horvat also scoring in the tiebreaker.
In regulation, Anthony Duclair, Brayden Schenn and Horvat all found the net as the Islanders earned their first win in Nashville since Oct. 28, 2017.
The result mattered beyond the personal comeback. The Islanders had gone 0-1-1 over their previous two games and were trying to shake off Sunday’s 6-3 loss in Dallas. They grabbed a 3-0 lead, gave it away, then found a way to survive the third-period push and get out with two points.
“It was a great response game by our group after the Dallas game,” Head Coach Pete DeBoer said. “This is a hard league to win in, and this is a hard building to win in. So it's two big points for us.”
Varlamov’s night kept getting bigger as the third period wore on. He robbed Filip Forsberg on a Predators power play while the game was tied 3-3, then made Forsberg miss wide in the shootout after the earlier stop on O’Reilly. DeBoer didn’t waste time identifying his goalie’s importance.
“After missing all that time, I think every night that we've rolled him out there, he's been a little bit better and a little bit more comfortable,” DeBoer said postgame. ”He was our best player tonight.”
The Islanders helped him out late, throwing themselves in front of shots and stacking up five blocked shots in the final 1:44 of regulation to keep the game alive. Afterward, the usual goalie congratulations turned into a full-team swarm, with the group circling Varlamov for a celebration that felt bigger than the standard postgame routine.
“I think it's a really close group in there,” DeBoer said postgame. “I'm kind of entering as a new guy, obviously, but it's impressive, and I think there are great veterans that have been around for a while with good experience and chemistry that have played together for a long time.”
The celebration kept rolling back in the room, where Varlamov picked up both the hard hat and the oar for the first time this season. There were taps on his pads, plenty of smiles and cheers with goalie coach Sergei Naumovs, and a locker room full of the kind of noise that fit the moment.
“It took me a long time, but I’m glad this organization, Mathieu Darche, the GM and coaching staff and the ownership gave me this opportunity,” Varlamov added. “I'm very thankful, and I appreciate that they believed in me and gave me this chance. So I'm just humble and very, very thankful.”
Matthew Schaefer also turned in a night the Islanders won’t forget. The 19-year-old defenseman became the first skater on record to play all five minutes of overtime since 2009-10, when real-time time-on-ice data began being tracked officially.
He even got back in time to break up a potential Predators breakaway near the end of that shift. Schaefer finished with a career-high 32:16 and added an assist on Horvat’s goal that made it 3-0 just 1:08 into the second period, extending his point streak to five games.
“He was all over the ice tonight, like he is every night,” DeBoer said. “He just wants to make a difference every shift, and that's what's so special about him.”
Schenn’s night had a milestone of its own. His first-period goal gave the Islanders a 2-0 lead and marked the 300th of his career, making him the eighth player from the 2009 Draft to reach that number and the 249th overall in NHL history.
The goal also pushed Schenn’s point streak to four games, his first run of that length since Feb. 23 - Mar.
2, 2025.
“Stats are great and all that type of stuff, but I take it as a accomplishment as to how many good teammates and coaches and opportunities that I've have along the way in order to put put me in that position,” Schenn said. “I've had a lot of great linemates over the course of my career, and like I said, I just got rewarded by my teammates. It's nice, but at the end of the day, it goes to the other guys that you play with and the opportunity you get.”
The Islanders dressed 11 forwards and seven defensemen, with Scott Mayfield re-entering the lineup for Kyle MacLean. Mayfield logged 9:06 and finished with three blocked shots in his third game of the season.
In Other News...
Islanders Recalls May Signal Something Bigger On Defense
The Islanders latest roster shuffle brought Pierre Engvall and defenseman Kashawn Aitcheson up from the AHL affiliate, with Cal Ritchie and Matias Maccelli going on injured reserve and the club getting back to a 23-man roster. On the surface, it is a practical move to cover absences, but it also comes at a time when the blue line is still searching for clarity after a recent loss and coach Peter DeBoer has left open the possibility of making more changes if the current look does not hold.
Aitchesons recall is the part worth watching most closely, because it signals the Islanders are at least considering adjustments on defense rather than simply shuffling forwards to survive a short stretch. With pairings still unsettled and roster flexibility in play, the next few games could tell the staff whether this was just a temporary patch or the first sign of a deeper rethink on the back end. [Read more 🡒]
Matthew Schaefer Just Gave Islanders Fans Another Reason To Watch Closely
Matthew Schaefer kept finding his way into the biggest moments of the Islanders overtime clash with Nashville, and the rookie defenseman ended up with a workload that stood out even in a game full of extra pressure. Peter DeBoer had plenty to like afterward, pointing to Schaefers poise and the way he handled a heavy night on the back end, where his 32:16 of ice time led all defensemen in the game.
What made the overtime stretch especially notable was how involved Schaefer stayed once the game moved past regulation. He drew the tripping penalty early in the five-minute session, then remained on the ice through the delayed-penalty power play and the rest of overtime, a rare level of trust in a young defenseman in a high-leverage spot. For Islanders fans, it was another reminder that Schaefer is already being leaned on in ways that go well beyond the usual rookie experience. [Read more 🡒]
Islanders Finally Ended A Frustrating Nashville Trend The Hard Way
The Islanders finally had reason to smile in Nashville after another tense, back-and-forth night against the Predators. Anthony Duclair got them on the board first, and from there the game turned into the kind of road battle that never seems to come easy for New York there, with lead changes and penalties keeping both sides on edge before the matchup spilled into overtime.
Nashville kept pushing and the Islanders had to survive the full drama of a shootout to leave with the result they wanted. For a team that had spent years struggling in that building, it was a welcome ending to a familiar frustration, even if it took far longer than they would have preferred to put the old pattern behind them. [Read more 🡒]