Simon Holmstrom Is Making One Islanders Decision Look Risky

Could the Islanders face future financial strain due to Holmstrom's escalating talent and a quickly rising salary cap?

Every time Simon Holmstrom puts the puck in the net, the New York Islanders get a little more proof that they may have let the price tag climb on themselves.

Saturday’s first career hat trick against Anaheim was the latest reminder. It also gave Mathieu Darche another reason to look back at the two-year, $7.25 million deal Holmstrom signed in July 2025 and wonder what a longer commitment might have cost before the market moved.

At the time, the contract made sense on paper. Holmstrom got a raise, and the Islanders avoided locking in major term after one breakout season. The $3.625 million annual cap hit still looks manageable.

But manageable today can turn into a bargain missed tomorrow.

Holmstrom had already shown enough to make the discussion interesting before that bridge deal was signed. He had a 20-goal, 45-point season in the books, which was enough to suggest real upside even if there were still questions about whether he could keep it going. Darche opted to wait for more certainty.

That kind of patience usually comes with a price.

The uncomfortable part for the Islanders is the timing. Holmstrom’s contract runs out after this season, and he will still be a restricted free agent. That gives New York some leverage, but it does not lock his value in place.

The cap environment is changing, too. The NHL’s salary cap sits at $104 million this season, with $113.5 million scheduled for 2027-28.

The league has also floated a preliminary $127.5 million estimate for 2028-29, though the way those increases are distributed could still change. In a rising cap world, productive players in their prime only get more expensive.

A longer deal in 2025 could have bought the Islanders more certainty before that climb really kicked in.

There is one important caveat here: nobody knows whether Holmstrom would have agreed to the term or the money that would have made sense for Darche. A GM can only negotiate the contract in front of him.

Still, the question is getting harder to brush aside.

One hat trick does not set Holmstrom’s next salary. What happens next will. If he keeps producing, the Islanders will end up paying for his growth - and for the decision to wait.

In Other News...

Islanders May Have A Shot At A Young Star For A Price

Matvei Michkovs early run with the Flyers has already become one of the more intriguing storylines in the division, and not just because of his talent. Reports have surfaced that the young winger is unhappy with the organization and has seen limited ice time under the head coach, which is enough to get rival teams paying attention. Even the on-bench argument with defenseman Nick Seeler, since resolved, added to the sense that this is a situation worth monitoring.

For the Islanders, the appeal is obvious if Philadelphia ever decides to listen on a trade. A player with Michkovs upside rarely becomes available, and any deal would likely come at a steep cost in first-round picks and prospects. Nothing official has been announced, but the speculation alone is enough to make this a name worth keeping on the radar as the season unfolds. [Read more 🡒]

Blue Jackets Suddenly Face Another Blue Line Concern With Dante Fabbro

The Blue Jackets blue line took another hit when Dante Fabbro left after taking a cross-check in the game against the Flyers, adding a fresh concern to a defense that has already had to manage injuries. Rib issues can linger, and any absence on the back end forces Columbus to shuffle pairings and lean harder on the depth it has been building around this season.

For the Islanders, it is a reminder of how quickly defensive health can become a league-wide storyline. Logan Stanleys lower-body injury against the Ducks is expected to be minor, while St. Louis is still waiting on more information after rookie Aleksanteri Kaskimaki hurt his shoulder against the Panthers. The common thread is familiar for every team in the race: one awkward collision can change the look of a blue line in a hurry. [Read more 🡒]

Matthew Schaefer's Rookie Pace Is Entering Rare Islanders Territory

The Islanders wrapped up their road trip in style with a 6-2 win over the Ducks, getting a first career hat trick from Simon Holmstrom and a solid night in goal from Semyon Varlamov. But the performance that keeps standing out belongs to Matthew Schaefer, who chipped in three points and continued to look like much more than a rookie trying to find his footing.

Schaefers latest outburst was his second three-point game of the season, pushing him to 21 points in 19 games and putting him in some rare Islanders company for a first-year player. For a team that has spent plenty of time searching for offense, the bigger question now is how far his pace can go if he keeps producing at this level. [Read more 🡒]