Mets Nailed With Unexpected Dilemma

With Mets closer Devin Williams sidelined, this could be the perfect opportunity for Kodai Senga to step up into the high-pressure role despite his past struggles.

Devin Williams’ move to the injured list has opened the door for a Mets experiment that sounds bold, maybe even a little reckless: Kodai Senga in the closer role.

Williams, who was placed on the injured list Monday with a right shoulder strain after reporting arm fatigue last week, is not expected to be out long. Andy Green said Monday in Atlanta that he believes Williams will pitch again this year. Still, the Mets are in a spot where they can afford to think creatively, and that’s where Senga enters the picture.

The idea is simple enough. If the Mets are going to keep sorting through a gutted bullpen, why not see whether Senga can handle the ninth inning? Green has not locked him into anything, but he made it clear the team is willing to keep testing him in relief.

“I think we’ll stop short of being declarative right now,” he told reporters. “Flexibility is one of our greatest strengths right now.

Nobody is attached to a defined role. He’s done a really nice job in a couple of his bullpen outings and I’m excited to see him continue to get tested that way.”

That matters because Senga is not exactly a clean, simple roster decision. After his breakout 2023 season, he’s been a mess of injuries and inconsistency.

He was hurt throughout 2024, then struggled badly enough in 2025 that he accepted a trip to Triple-A Syracuse. He carries an 8.29 ERA this season, is guaranteed $30 million over the next two years, and has a conditional club option in 2028, when he’ll be 35.

At this point, he’s nearly impossible to move.

But the Mets also have the luxury of playing with ideas while other teams are chasing precision. With the season where it is, the value is in seeing what actually works.

Senga’s recent relief work gives the concept some real footing. On Aug. 4, he worked the ninth inning of a 6-2 game and reached 98.8 mph with his fastball.

Two days later, he came in during the seventh to face the heart of the Guardians order and retired the side, firing a 100.4-mph fastball and throwing only one pitch that wasn’t a fastball or forkball. That kind of sharp, stripped-down approach may suit him better than the starter’s full menu.

There’s also a confidence element here. Senga has repeatedly said he feels like a different pitcher since the injuries that altered his 2024 season, specifically a shoulder capsule strain and a calf strain that affected his mechanics.

By this year, he acknowledged there could be a mental piece to the problem as well. In relief, he has looked freer, and that alone makes the trial worth something.

The stuff plays, too. Senga began his career in Japan as a reliever, and in short bursts he can lean on his two best weapons: the fastball and the ghost fork.

This season, his fastball has averaged 96.2 mph, but that number has dipped closer to 95 mph when he’s been starting regularly. In shorter outings, the Mets may be able to get more of the velocity that makes him dangerous.

There are other arms in the mix, including Daniel Duarte and Jefry Yan, with Yan bringing the eye-catching ability to reach 100 mph. Both are cheaper and easier to move between the majors and Syracuse. But if the Mets want the biggest payoff, Senga is the one worth pushing.

Green sounded open to that kind of internal competition.

“If guys latch onto roles and show dominance in a particular capacity, you want to give them some level of certainty,” he said. “Guys thrive when they know what their expectations are.

We’re not there right now. Guys also thrive when they earn something and they’re not just given something.”

So Senga has to take it. That’s the test. And if he does, the Mets may have found something useful in a season that has offered them plenty of reasons to look for it.

In Other News...

Islanders Jersey Vote Reopens A Debate Fans Never Wanted

The Islanders have opened voting for their third jersey for the 2026-27 season, and the process has already revived one of the franchises most familiar arguments. Eight final designs are in the mix, including two versions built around the old Fish Stick look, a logo that dates to 1995 and still splits the fan base between nostalgia and outright rejection.

The debate has lingered for years because the Fish Stick identity is tied to a stretch many Islanders fans would rather leave in the past, even as others have embraced it as a throwback. The conversation got an extra jolt when Boomer Esiason, a well-known Rangers supporter and media host, voiced support for the Fish Stick jersey on air, adding another layer to a vote that was already bound to stir plenty of opinion. [Read more 🡒]

Jean-Gabriel Pageau Just Got A Cool Reminder Of His Islanders Impact

Jean-Gabriel Pageau just got a reminder of how his NHL career has traced through two familiar stops, with a custom golf putter landing in his hands that blends alternate logos from the Islanders and the Senators. The piece was made by Casey Golf Company, a boutique brand in Canada, and it neatly captures the path of a player who spent part of eight seasons in Ottawa before settling in with New York.

For Islanders fans, it is a small but telling nod to how quickly Pageau has become part of the fabric since arriving on Long Island. He is heading into his eighth season with the club after signing a three-year extension, and the putter serves as one more sign that his impact has stretched beyond the ice, even if the next chapter of that story still belongs to the years ahead. [Read more 🡒]

John Tavares Is Forcing A Bigger Islanders Legacy Debate

John Tavares has already built one of the more notable careers of his era, and the Islanders remain part of that story whether they like it or not. The former No. 1 pick spent nine seasons on Long Island, then moved on to Toronto, where he is now in his ninth season, all while keeping up a remarkably steady scoring touch that has carried him through 17 NHL seasons without a dip below 19 goals in any of them.

Those numbers have helped him reach major benchmarks with two franchises, including 500 points and 250 goals, but they have also reopened a familiar debate about legacy. For Islanders fans, Tavares is still measured not only by what he produced in New York, but by what never came with it, and the missing Stanley Cup championship remains the detail that complicates how his career is judged in Hall of Fame terms. [Read more 🡒]