Matthew Schaefer is already operating like a star, and now the question is how far his second NHL season can go.
The New York Islanders defenseman is only 19, but he’s coming off a rookie year that put him in rare company. In a full 82-game season, the Hamilton, Ont., native piled up 59 points, turning what had been a draft year shortened by injury into one of the best rookie campaigns by a defenseman in the salary-cap era. He also handled a huge workload, averaging 24:41 per night, and looked comfortable doing it.
That kind of season would be enough for most young blueliners. For Schaefer, it just raised the bar.
He didn’t look like a player feeling his way through the league for long. After some expected preseason learning curves, he quickly became an all-situations defender for an Islanders team trying to claw back into the playoff picture. He won the Calder Trophy with ease, and his play even put him into serious consideration for Canada’s Olympic team.
The appeal is obvious every time he steps on the ice. Schaefer skates effortlessly in every direction, and that movement fuels everything he does offensively.
He can carry the puck with speed, read the ice at a high level and keep plays alive with the kind of poise and awareness that make a power-play quarterback look natural. Put all of that together with his hands and decision-making, and you get a defenseman who already looks close to the ideal.
Now he’s back in Year 2, where the expectations get louder and the spotlight gets hotter. The Islanders have a chance to shake up a subpar Metropolitan Division and push for the playoffs, but Schaefer will have to be a driving force if that’s going to happen.
He’s a Norris Trophy contender, though he’s probably closer to 10th than first in that race right now. Even so, at 19, he already has the kind of game that can take over shifts and tilt the ice.
That’s why the sophomore conversation matters. If Schaefer is going to join the all-time great second-year defensemen, he’ll need to climb into some elite statistical territory.
The standard at the top is brutal. Sergei Zubov’s 89-point season with the New York Rangers in 1993-94 and Paul Coffey’s 89-point year with Edmonton in 1981-82 sit as the benchmark.
Only five second-year defensemen in NHL history have cleared 70 points, with Zubov the most recent. Cale Makar had a shot to blow past that pace in 2020-21, but the COVID-impacted season left him with 44 points in 44 games.
Using Hockey Reference’s era-adjusted points model, Zubov’s sophomore year would come out to about 81 points in 2026-27, while Denis Potvin would land at 70. Everyone else would fall short of that line.
Based on what Schaefer already showed as a rookie, 70 points this season feels well within reach. The era-adjusted lens matters because scoring was so much higher in the 1980s and early 90s, and among U-20 defensemen, Phil Housley’s 77-point season in 1983-84 remains the best ever.
Schaefer’s rookie production, though, stands alone for the 21st century.
The Islanders’ roster only adds to the expectation that Schaefer will be the engine of the offense. They lost Anders Lee but added Matias Maccelli and rookie Victor Eklund, and beyond that, the forward group doesn’t bring a ton of depth. Schaefer also has no real competition for the top power-play role, so the man advantage should keep feeding his point total.
There’s already a sign that the load may be even heavier early. Mathew Barzal is out to start the season, and Schaefer has been leaned on more because of it.
On Saturday, he picked up two assists in a 6-0 win over the New Jersey Devils, which works out to an 84-point pace. Small sample, sure, but the start has been strong.
The Islanders may not have the kind of scoring depth that makes life easy, but that also means Schaefer should get plenty of chances to be “the guy.”
He may also have a real shot at another historic marker: becoming the youngest defenseman in NHL history to score 30 goals in a regular season. Phil Housley was 20 when he got there in 1983-84, and Schaefer just turned 19.
Last season, he scored 23 goals, tying Brian Leetch’s rookie record, and he did it on a team that was never truly in the playoff mix. None of the players in the accompanying list reached 30, not even Coffey, who had the luxury of playing with Mark Messier, Jari Kurri, Glenn Anderson and Wayne Gretzky.
With another year of development behind him, Schaefer should keep growing the way star players usually do. A 10-point jump from last season almost sounds conservative for a player who sees the game and executes it the way he does. Add in an 84-game schedule, and there are even more chances for him to chase records.
He’s already one of the best young defensemen in hockey, and he’s become the kind of player you don’t miss when the Islanders come to town. The Norris Trophy still looks like a difficult climb, with Cale Makar, Quinn Hughes, Lane Hutson and Zach Werenski holding the edge there. But Schaefer is built for a big year, and betting against him making sophomore history feels like a mistake.
In Other News...
Islanders Already Face A Romanov Concern They Couldn't Afford
Alexander Romanovs night ended early Tuesday against the Rangers, and for an Islanders team already trying to steady its blue line, that is the kind of development it could not have welcomed. Romanov exited with an apparent injury and was not back on the ice for the final stretch of the game, leaving New York to finish without one of its more important defensemen.
Pete DeBoer said Romanov is still being evaluated, which leaves the Islanders in wait-and-see mode for now. If the injury lingers, it would add another layer of difficulty to a defensive group that can ill afford to lose a regular presence for any length of time. [Read more 🡒]
Islanders' Rangers Loss Exposed A Problem Fans Were Dreading
Semyon Varlamovs return was one of the few encouraging developments in a rough night for the Islanders, even if it came in a loss to the Rangers that underscored how much work still remains. The veteran goalie was back in the crease after knee surgeries, stepping into a charged rivalry game and facing a steady Rangers attack that kept New York under pressure from the opening shift.
Alexis Lafrenire led the way for the Rangers with a big night, while Oliver Bjorkstrand added two goals and Mika Zibanejad piled up three assists as the visitors pulled away and stretched their winning streak to four. For the Islanders, the result was less about the score line than the reminder that simply getting Varlamov back is only one piece of a much larger problem they still have to solve. [Read more 🡒]
Islanders Suddenly Have A Blue Line Concern After Rivalry Loss
The Islanders left their rivalry loss with more than just a setback in the standings, because two regulars came out banged up and the blue line suddenly looks a little thinner. Simon Holmstrom was forced out after taking a hit to the face, and while the concern is a broken nose, the early expectation is that he will keep playing and stay in his third-line role.
Alexander Romanovs exit is the more pressing issue for the back end. The defenseman left with a leg injury, and coach Pete DeBoer did not offer a postgame update, leaving the Islanders to sort through what it could mean for the defensive rotation if Romanov needs time. [Read more 🡒]