Matthew Schaefer is already thinking bigger after a rookie season that put him in rare company.
The Islanders’ 19-year-old defenseman represented the team at the NHL Media Tour in Las Vegas ahead of training camp, and he arrived with the kind of confidence that usually follows a breakthrough year, not a 23-goal, 59-point debut that won him the Calder Trophy. Schaefer, who was 18 last season, didn’t just make the jump to the NHL - he blew past every previous benchmark for 18-year-old defensemen and quickly looked like one of the league’s most intriguing young players.
Now the challenge is simple to say and hard to do: top it.
Schaefer isn’t shying away from that pressure. In fact, he sounds eager for it. He said the leap from his first NHL season to his second feels “night and day,” pointing to how much he learned once the grind of the league hit him.
"Yeah, I mean, you go into your first year, you don't know what to expect," Schaefer said. "You're at training camp, you're at rookie camp, and you're a little nervous because you don't know many guys there.
You're coming in, it's different. But honestly, I've learned so much from start to finish.
I gained my confidence.
"I learned what the league was like," Schaefer continued. "Obviously, there weren't many days off, so you're playing basically every other day, and I found a lot of ways to get my rest and recovery, take care of my body, but play at 100, you know, as close to 100 percent, each and every night, and be hungry every night.
"Year 2 can be even better. And, you know, it took me the first little bit of the season to get going. I want to come out of the gates going right away and carry it through the whole season."
That kind of reflection matters for any young player, but especially one who went straight from juniors into the NHL and handled it like Schaefer did. He made clear that the Islanders’ support system was a huge part of why everything clicked so quickly.
"Obviously, I think the main thing that helped me last year was just everybody in the Islanders organization," Schaefer said. "Mainly my teammates and coaches and all the staff.
They helped me so much from top to bottom. So I would like to thank, you know, everybody.
“This is the most fun I've had playing hockey, and, it's all because of the people that are surrounding me and my support system," Schaefer continued. "Every time I come to the rink, I have a smile on my face.
I'm ready to learn. I'm ready to work.
And I'm ready to just be there with my family. It's awesome.”
For all the talk about what he accomplished as a rookie, Schaefer sounds even more focused on what comes next. He said he wants to be “bigger, stronger, faster,” and that message landed like a warning to the rest of the league.
He’s already a Calder winner. He’s already one of the Islanders’ most important players.
And he’s not talking like someone satisfied with any of it.
In Other News...
Islanders May Have Landed A Draft Class That Changes Everything
Corey Pronmans 2025 NHL re-draft offered another early look at what the Islanders may have gotten from a class that already feels worth watching closely. Matthew Schaefer stayed in the top spot, and the rest of the group also drew plenty of attention in the re-ordering, with the kind of upward movement that suggests more than just a promising night at the draft table.
The bigger picture is what makes it interesting for the Islanders. Their 2009 draft class eventually became a major part of the franchises foundation, and this group is now being discussed in similar terms as the prospect pipeline starts to take shape. If these players develop the way evaluators believe they can, the 2025 class could end up doing far more than fill out the system. It could help define the next version of the team. [Read more 🡒]
Ilya Sorokins Rise Puts One Islanders Problem Back In Focus
Ilya Sorokins season left no doubt about his standing among the NHLs elite. After finishing as the Vezina Trophy runner-up, he landed at No. 35 on NHL Networks Top 50 Players list heading into the 2026-27 season, a ranking that reflects both his value and how central he has become to the Islanders hopes. He was at his sharpest in the first half of last season, when he helped keep the team afloat and looked every bit like the kind of goaltender who can drag a roster into contention.
The problem is what followed the Olympic break, when Sorokins performance dipped and the Islanders slipped out of the playoff race. The workload on him became impossible to ignore, and it has put the rest of the roster back under the microscope. With Pete DeBoer now in charge, the Islanders are counting on a more structured defensive approach to take some of that burden off their goalie, even if the size of the turnaround still hangs on how well that system actually takes hold. [Read more 🡒]