Matthew Schaefer put on the kind of night that can hijack a game, a box score and the headline all at once.
The 19-year-old defenseman scored his first NHL hat trick as the Islanders beat the Blue Jackets 5-1, a result that gave New York two more points and kept Columbus buried in the Eastern Conference basement. It also marked the first hat trick by an Islanders defenseman since Denis Potvin in 1982.
The Islanders came home from California and looked like a team that knew exactly what kind of win it needed. They carried a 2-0 lead into the third period, then answered Columbus getting on the board with two quick strikes to stretch the margin back out and take the life out of the game.
Schaefer’s second goal made it 3-1, but not before the Blue Jackets tried to overturn it with a goalie-interference challenge. The call stood. Casey Cizikas had made brief contact in the crease with Cam Talbot, but the goalie wasn’t hindered by that; instead, it was his own defenseman who struck his goalie stick and spun Talbot around.
Tony DeAngelo followed with the kind of finish that put the game away for good. He worked an overlap with Mat Barzal along the right-side boards, cut to the front, and beat Talbot on the backhand to make it 4-1.
Schaefer finished the hat trick into an empty net after Columbus pulled Talbot for a sixth attacker. Simon Holmstrom fed him as he came through the neutral zone, and the shot from the blueline was there for the taking.
The teenager’s scoring burst ended up stealing the spotlight from a strong overall Islanders performance and a really good night from Ilya Sorokin. Barzal chipped in two assists, including a sharp quick pass that set up Anthony Duclair’s power-play goal to open the scoring in the first period.
Schaefer’s first goal was the one that showed off his best traits. He fired from high in the zone and found a lane through traffic, the kind of shot he’s made look routine more than once already.
In Other News...
Islanders Face One Lineup Question As Injuries Test Their Momentum
The Islanders came home from a successful three-game road trip with a 2-0-1 record and now turn their attention to Columbus, but the momentum they built is being tested by a familiar early-season issue: the lineup is not quite settled. Head coach Peter DeBoer said center JG Pageau is a game-time decision after missing the past two games, while center Calum Ritchie is still moving in the right direction but will not be available.
On the blue line, Logan Stanley is expected to sit because of injury, which opens the door for Matthew Kessel to step in. For a team trying to keep its stride after a good trip away from home, the uncertainty around Pageau matters because of what he brings down the middle, and the Islanders will have to manage at least one more adjustment before puck drop. [Read more 🡒]
Islanders Forward Crunch Could Force A Tough DeBoer Decision
Mathew Barzal is back in the Islanders lineup, Cal Ritchie is expected to follow soon after practicing with the team, and Matias Maccelli has already returned from injury to chip in assists in recent games. For a club that has spent plenty of time juggling availability up front, getting that kind of depth back at once is a welcome problem, especially as the coaching staff starts sorting out how the forward group should look when everyone is available.
Peter DeBoer now has to weigh more than just who is healthy enough to play. With the roster getting closer to full strength, the question becomes how to balance skill, chemistry and opportunity without leaving useful forwards squeezed out of the mix. The next lineup call could say as much about the Islanders long-term direction as it does about the immediate game plan, and it is not the kind of decision a coach makes lightly. [Read more 🡒]
Barzals Return Gives Islanders Hope With One Big Question Ahead
Mathew Barzals return on Nov. 14 gave the Islanders a welcome jolt, and it also offered a first look at how their offense might look with one of its most dynamic players back in the mix. After recovering from the left knee injury he suffered in February 2025, Barzal stepped into the lineup against the Anaheim Ducks, logged 16:21 and picked up an assist in his debut back.
The Islanders activated Barzal and moved Kyle MacLean to non-roster waivers to make room, a reminder that the roster shuffle around his comeback is only part of the story. Team officials, including coach Pete DeBoer, have pointed to the progress Barzal made in rehab and the careful monitoring of his minutes, but the bigger question now is how quickly he can settle back into a full workload and help drive the attack the way the Islanders need. [Read more 🡒]
