Matthew Schaefer Already Sounds Like The Islanders Cornerstone Fans Wanted

Matthew Schaefer shares valuable insights with Gavin McKenna on navigating the pressures and opportunities of playing in Toronto's intense hockey scene.

Matthew Schaefer’s message to Gavin McKenna was simple, and it came with the kind of perspective only another top pick can really deliver: take it in, but keep grinding.

In a recent Sportsnet interview, Schaefer said McKenna should “Just enjoy the ride and keep working.” That was the heart of it. Schaefer, coming off an impressive start with the New York Islanders, framed the whole thing as one of those moments you never forget once you’re in it.

He also dug into what it means to land in Toronto, where hockey is baked into daily life. Schaefer pointed out that if you grew up there, you already know the sport is everywhere.

The city has always been a tournament hub, and the spotlight that comes with it is part of the package. His advice was to feel that energy, enjoy it with family, and then get back to work instead of getting swallowed by the “big moment” talk.

That mindset tied into development, too. Schaefer said he started on the third pairing and earned his way up from there.

He and McKenna aren’t the same player, but the lesson lands the same way: early confidence matters, reps matter, and progress comes from believing in your game and staying at it. Schaefer also noted that McKenna will be figuring out how to fit in with new teammates and coaches, and he believes that kind of support can matter a lot.

Schaefer made it clear he was happy for McKenna, even while acknowledging the pressure that comes with that kind of landing spot. It’s a dream, sure, but it can also pull a player too far into the future if he’s not careful. Schaefer’s point was to stay present once the season begins.

There’s also a little extra juice for Schaefer personally, because he said the two are set to go head-to-head early this season. He called it a big moment, especially with it happening in Toronto right away, and said he’s hoping McKenna has a bunch of family there to help him soak it all in.

The message, in the end, was plain: enjoy Toronto, enjoy the moment with the people around you, and keep putting in the work so you’re ready when it matters.

In Other News...

Islanders Aging Core May Be Headed For A Bigger Reckoning

The Islanders are heading into the 2026-27 season with a roster that looks a lot like the one they already had, and that is the point. Aside from Anders Lee moving on and Matias Maccelli coming in, the group has barely changed, leaving New York as the sixth-oldest team in the league by average age, even before factoring in 19-year-old Victor Eklund, who is expected to push for a spot out of camp or be among the final cuts.

The bigger issue is what comes next. Ondrej Palat, Kyle Palmieri and Casey Cizikas are all set to hit unrestricted free agency next summer, Semyon Varlamov is in the same position, and the trade protection on Ryan Pulock and Scott Mayfield is about to loosen. With Kashawn Aitcheson also knocking on the door of a larger role, the Islanders may soon have to decide whether to keep leaning on the same core or start making harder choices about how long that core can stay intact. [Read more 🡒]

Islanders Already Have One Contract Problem They Need To Fix

Ondrej Palats place on the Islanders books is one of those lingering roster issues that can quietly shape a season. New York took on his contract from the Devils last season, and while his contribution was modest, the bigger challenge now is the price tag attached to it. A $6 million cap hit is tough to move when the production has not matched it, which leaves the Islanders with a familiar kind of NHL problem: a useful enough player, but a contract that makes every decision around him more complicated.

For now, the Islanders may simply hold the line and carry Palat through this season while they see whether his play can justify the commitment. There is at least an end point in sight, with Palat set to become a free agent next summer, so the team is not locked into this arrangement for the long haul. Still, until his value on the ice starts to look more in line with the cap number, the Islanders are going to have to work around a deal that does not fit especially cleanly. [Read more 🡒]