Mat Barzal has spent most of his Islanders career doing exactly what top playmakers are supposed to do: making offense look easy. The problem is that he hasn’t always gotten treated like one of the NHL’s better ones.
Since winning the Calder Trophy as a rookie in the 2017-18 season, Barzal has rarely been talked about like a true elite. Injuries have played a part in that, and the lack of playoff runs - plus no Stanley Cups - has left him off plenty of national lists. But the production has been there, and the case for more recognition is strong.
Drafted 16th overall in 2015, Barzal has spent his entire career with the New York Islanders. Outside of two injury-hit seasons, he has been a reliable 50-plus point player, and his ability to line up at wing or center gives the Islanders real flexibility. That versatility matters, especially for a team that has leaned on him for offense for years.
He also keeps stacking up numbers that are hard to ignore. In 2024-25, after an injury-plagued season, Barzal still finished with 72 points, the most on the Islanders, along with 53 assists, also a team high. If he stays healthy, he has shown he can lead the club in both points and assists.
There’s even a milestone on the horizon. By the 2026-27 season, Barzal could move into 10th place all-time in Islanders points. That’s the kind of franchise standing that usually comes with a bigger spotlight than he’s gotten.
The NHL Fantasy Preview projects him for 66 points next season, which would be eight fewer than last year. But where he lines up could matter a lot.
He played as a second-line center last season, and he could also wind up on the wing with Bo Horvat. If that happens, the playmaking chances could increase.
And yet, Barzal still gets left off national rankings that should at least have him in the conversation. After the 2025-26 season, the NHL Network released its Top 20 players at each position, and Barzal wasn’t included. That feels like a miss.
On the centers list, Barzal’s 72 points compare favorably with a number of players who did make it, including Sam Bennett, who was ranked 20th. Barzal finished ahead of Bennett in assists, points, average ice time, and goals created. He doesn’t have a Conn Smythe Trophy, and the Islanders’ playoff absence can’t be pinned on him.
Even if he were judged as a winger, the numbers still point in his favor. His point total would stack up well against several players on the NHL Network’s Top 20 list at that position.
Among his 2015 draft classmates, Barzal’s production also stands out. In a class that included Connor McDavid, Jack Eichel, and Mitch Marner ahead of him, Barzal ranks eighth in total points and sixth in assists. He sits ahead of some players drafted before him, including Timo Meier and Dylan Strome.
Playing in New York may keep him a little out of the national glare, but Barzal has done enough to be seen more clearly than he is now.
In Other News...
Islanders Linked To A Ducks Situation That Could Suddenly Pay Off
Cutter Gauthiers next contract has become one of the more interesting ripple effects in Anaheim, and the Islanders are at least a team to keep in the conversation. The restricted free agent has emerged as a top goal scorer for the Ducks, which is exactly why the market around him has gotten so tight, and why any long-term solution is bound to draw attention from clubs watching for an opening.
For the Islanders, the intrigue is twofold. They could look at Gauthier as a player worth targeting if the Ducks situation stays stalled, even if that route comes with a steep price, while Anaheim may also need to move a current piece to make the money work. Chris Kreider, in the final year of his deal, has surfaced as a possible fit for a return to New York if the Ducks decide they need cap relief and start reshaping the roster around Gauthier. [Read more 🡒]
Islanders Fans Just Made A Jersey Choice That Feels Bigger Than Hockey
The Islanders turned a jersey project into a full-on fan referendum, and the response was enormous. More than 80,000 submissions poured in as the team opened up the design process for its 2027-28 third jersey, giving supporters a direct hand in shaping what the club will wear down the line. It is a rare bit of participation for a franchise whose look has always carried extra weight with its fan base, and the result says plenty about how much the logo and the sweater still matter in this market.
Now the club and Fanatics will take the winning concept and start turning it into something that can actually hit the ice, with the lighthouse set to become the primary crest for the first time in team history. The idea of a lighthouse on an Islanders jersey carries a built-in sense of place and identity, which is why this vote landed like more than just a design choice. The final version still has to be built out, but the signal from the fans was unmistakable. [Read more 🡒]
Islanders Fans Just Helped Decide A Jersey Look That Will Spark Debate
The Islanders turned one of their next big style decisions into a full-on fan project, inviting supporters to weigh in on a 2027-28 Third Jersey Design Concept competition. Eight different looks were put through a bracket-style vote, giving the fan base a real say in the direction of a jersey that will eventually become part of the franchises on-ice identity.
The process drew more than 80,000 submissions, a sign of just how much interest there is in a sweater that can stir up as much conversation as any lineup move. It came down to a final-round matchup between two Navy-themed concepts, and the result should give Islanders followers plenty to talk about long before the jersey ever hits the ice. [Read more 🡒]