The Islanders are leaning into a straightforward answer to a tricky problem.
With Matias Maccelli and Cal Ritchie both set to miss multiple games because of lower-body injuries, the club is turning to Kyle MacLean and Mitchell Chaffee for Tuesday night’s matchup with the Ducks at UBS Arena. On paper, it’s not the kind of replacement plan that jumps off the page. In practice, it fits exactly what the team needs right now after a solid 1-0-1 Canadian road trip.
Ritchie, the second-line center, will be out four to six weeks after what looked like a left leg or knee injury early in the first period of Saturday’s 4-1 win in Toronto. Maccelli, who had been skating on Bo Horvat’s top line, is expected to miss two to four weeks. That’s a better outcome than it first appeared after he awkwardly seemed to wrench his left knee and groin.
That opens the door for a pair of depth forwards who bring the same kind of game: uncomplicated, physical, and reliable.
MacLean and Chaffee are both U.S.-born, both sit in that depth-forward lane, and neither has reached 200 NHL games yet. They are not here to fill the net or chase highlight-reel moments. They are here to do the work that keeps a lineup steady and a game on the right side of the ledger.
MacLean has been a healthy scratch through the first eight games, while Chaffee was summoned on an emergency basis from the Islanders’ AHL affiliate in Hamilton, Ontario. He made the trip back to Long Island with general manager Mathieu Darche, assistant GM Evan Gold and co-owner Jon Ledecky, all of whom were in Hamilton for the Hammers’ home game on Sunday.
Hamilton had other options, including leading scorer Liam Foudy, 2024 first-rounder Cole Eiserman and Pierre Engvall, who is in the fourth season of a seven-year, $21 million deal that keeps looking worse.
Even so, the Islanders are clearly choosing the more direct path. MacLean and Chaffee both impressed in training camp, but the opening-night lineup never quite had room for them as coach Pete DeBoer searched for the right balance across four lines. Now the injuries have changed the math.
The hope is that both players slot in cleanly and, with Casey Cizikas, help the Islanders establish a forecheck that can set the tone for the rest of the group.
Chaffee is eager for the chance.
“This is why you play the game,” Chaffee said. “You want to play the game at the highest level. I feel like I can help this team.
“I play physical, so I can bring that. I love shooting the puck and holding on to pucks and winning puck battles.”
The 28-year-old came into the league as an undrafted free agent, first signing with the Wild in 2020 and appearing in two games for Minnesota. He spent the last three seasons in the Lightning organization, where Darche, then Tampa Bay’s assistant GM, got a close look at him. Chaffee has 16 goals and 10 assists in 109 NHL games.
Cizikas was quick to point out what stood out about him in camp.
“Just the way he plays, the way he sees the ice,” Cizikas told Newsday when asked what stood out about Chaffee in training camp. “He works hard and he has the skill to go along with it. We’re excited to have him back up here and get this thing going as a line with me, him and Mac.”
That trio has already shown a glimpse of what it can do. In the preseason, MacLean, Chaffee and Cizikas played together once and combined on the Islanders’ first goal in a 4-3 win over the Rangers at Madison Square Garden on Sept. 22, with MacLean finishing a setup from Chaffee and Cizikas.
Chaffee can also work the half-wall on the power play if needed. At Monday’s practice, though, Simon Holmstrom moved onto the first power-play unit to fill Maccelli’s spot, while Ondrej Palat joined the second unit in place of Ritchie.
MacLean is a more familiar face. He has spent the past two seasons as a regular on the fourth line after getting called up in 2023-24, and the Islanders know exactly what they are getting: a skater who moves well, avoids mistakes and keeps things simple. His career line sits at 10 goals and 17 assists in 172 NHL games, and he’ll need to chip in a little more offensively if he wants to stay in the mix.
For now, he is just happy to be back on the ice.
“I’m pretty pumped,” MacLean said. “I’ve been patient.
Just trying to stay ready and work and happy to get the opportunity. I’ll be ready to go.”
He also pointed to the type of identity the Islanders can build with that kind of line.
“I think we found a little bit of that last year with Case and Gats,” said MacLean, referring to Marc Gatcomb, now with Vegas. “What it came down to is we were just simple.
When we were rolling, it helped the team having four lines able to go. I think it’s simplicity to our game, just playing hard and bringing energy.”
That’s the appeal of this move. MacLean and Chaffee do not need to overcomplicate anything.
They do not need to try to be more than they are. The Islanders just need them to bring the same hard-working, straightforward game that makes a fourth line useful when the lineup gets squeezed.
In Other News...
Stars Lose A Key Defensive Piece At The Worst Time
Scott Mayfields season has already been defined by a frustrating lack of ice time, and the latest sign points to that not changing against the Anaheim Ducks. The Islanders defenseman has appeared in only two games this season, leaving him on the outside looking in even as the club continues to manage its blue line and evaluate its options.
The situation has created an awkward backdrop for both player and team, especially with a full no-trade clause giving Mayfield control over his future for now. If the healthy scratches keep piling up, his name could become one to watch as the season moves along and the Islanders navigate a roster picture that still feels unsettled. [Read more 🡒]
Islanders May Have Found A Fourth Line Fans Can Rally Behind
The Islanders 3-2 win over the Ducks had the kind of depth-driven feel that can steady a team looking for reliable contributions beyond its top end. With three different goal scorers and nine players recording points, the night offered a little bit of everything, but one of the more noticeable developments came from the bottom half of the lineup, where fresh faces and grinding shifts helped set the tone.
Mitchell Chaffee, recalled on Monday, made his Islanders debut and left enough of an impression to earn the hardest worker helmet, while Ondej Palt was named player of the game. Afterward, head coach Pete DeBoer pointed to Chaffee and Kyle MacLean as examples of the physical edge and energy that can make a fourth line matter, the kind of detail that can quickly turn a one-off performance into something fans start watching for every night. [Read more 🡒]
Islanders Still Have A Barzal Problem With No Clear End In Sight
Mathew Barzals absence has stretched from the start of training camp into the early part of the season, and the Islanders still do not have a clear answer on when he might get back on the ice. General manager Mathieu Darche said Barzal is dealing with inflammation in his left knee and remains without a timetable to resume practicing or playing, leaving the club to keep navigating life without one of its most important forwards.
The uncertainty around Barzal has only added to the attention around the roster, but Darche also pushed back on another item making the rounds. He said there is no truth to the rumor that defenseman Scott Mayfield is considering waiving his no-trade clause, noting that Mayfields agent was in town for unrelated reasons, which at least quiets one source of speculation while the bigger Barzal question lingers. [Read more 🡒]