Islanders Rookie Is Suddenly Entering A Much Bigger NHL Conversation

With experts drawing parallels to the greats, young Matthew Schaefer emerges as a promising successor to Connor McDavid's NHL legacy.

Connor McDavid has spent his career building a resume that already looks untouchable. Six Art Ross Trophies, five Ted Lindsay Awards, three Hart Trophies, a Rocket Richard and a Conn Smythe tell part of the story, even if the Stanley Cup is still missing. This season, he’s somehow taken things even higher, sitting on 55 points through 24 games and on pace to become only the second player ever to hit 200 points in a season.

So if McDavid is the face of the NHL right now, who comes next?

On Sportsnet’s The FAN Hockey Show, Michael Futa pointed to Matthew Schaefer of the New York Islanders.

"I’m going to go with the NY Islanders’ own, Matthew Schaefer," Michael Futa said on Sportsnet’s The FAN Hockey Show. "My thing is, he is character personified.

You know, it’s almost like everybody understands his situation... He’s just the face of the game.

And he plays in a market that needed that."

That kind of praise goes beyond what Schaefer does with the puck. The league has always wanted its biggest stars to bring more than production, and Futa made it clear Schaefer checks those boxes too.

"Matthew Schaefer, he’s got the look and the play on the ice is incredible," Futa’s co-host Matthew Marchese said. "He’s pacing for over 100 points as a 19-year-old defenseman, which is absurd.

He’s also very marketable. He’s doing stuff with one of the companies, No Bull, which Tom Brady’s involved in...

They’re allowing him to be him, which I think is really important on the island, too.

With just 103 games under his belt, Schaefer is already being talked about in the same conversation as McDavid. That says plenty about what he’s shown so far, and about how quickly he’s become part of the league’s biggest spotlight. Even with players like Macklin Cellebrini and Nathan MacKinnon in the mix, Schaefer is already in that breath.

In Other News...

Islanders May Be Eyeing The Blue-Line Swing Fans Have Wanted

The Islanders find themselves in an awkward middle ground, close enough to the playoff chase to keep the focus on the present, but not so far out that they can comfortably pivot into draft-position mode. That makes the trade market especially interesting, and one name worth watching is Simon Edvinsson of the Red Wings, a young blue-liner who has surfaced as a possible trade candidate.

Detroit is said to be looking for the right deal, and any team serious about Edvinsson would likely need to pay up. He is a restricted free agent and not a target for offer sheets, which means a trade would have to do the heavy lifting, probably involving a first-round pick and top prospects. For the Islanders, that kind of ask would test just how aggressively they want to chase help on the back end. [Read more 🡒]

Islanders Keep Rolling As One Concern Lingers Behind Feel-Good Night

The Islanders kept their momentum going with a 3-2 win over the Red Wings, stretching their point streak to seven games on a night that had plenty to celebrate. Casey Cizikas marked his 1,000th NHL game by picking up an assist, and Ilya Sorokin backed it up with 18 saves as New York continued to bank points in a tight race.

Ryan Pulocks absence was the one notable concern, though, as the defenseman sat out with an upper-body injury. He will be evaluated once the team gets back to Long Island, leaving the Islanders with at least one lingering question after an otherwise feel-good night. [Read more 🡒]

Islanders Keep Finding A Way Even With This Banged Up Roster

Even with the lineup taking hits, the Islanders keep finding ways to stay afloat, and Sundays 3-2 win over the Red Wings was another reminder of that. Casey Cizikas reached his 1,000th NHL game in a night that had plenty of moving parts, including an early deficit the Islanders had to erase before settling into the kind of grind they have leaned on all season. Simon Holmstrom helped turn the game around, and Ondrej Palat provided the finishing touch with two goals.

The win also came with a scare when Emil Heineman briefly left with an injury before returning, another sign of how thin things can feel for New York right now. Ilya Sorokin helped make sure the night ended with two points, coming up with the key saves the Islanders needed as they protected the lead and kept their momentum going despite the banged-up roster. [Read more 🡒]