Islanders Keep Sending A Clear Message About Scott Mayfield

As questions loom over Scott Mayfield's future with the Islanders, his benching raises eyebrows amid a critical juncture in his career.

Scott Mayfield’s place with the Islanders has become impossible to ignore, and not for the right reasons.

The 34-year-old defenseman was back on the outside looking in after Monday’s practice at Northwell Health Ice Center in East Meadow, a strong sign he was headed for his 14th healthy scratch in 20 games when the Islanders host the Blue Jackets on Tuesday night at UBS Arena. For a player in his 13th NHL season, and the fourth year of a seven-year, $24.5 million contract, that’s a steep fall.

Mayfield has kept the same steady message throughout it all.

“I think they understand that I’ve been around and know the position,” Mayfield told Newsday after Monday’s practice at Northwell Health Ice Center in East Meadow, which indicated he was headed toward being a healthy scratch for the 14th time in 20 games when the Islanders face the Eastern Conference-worst Blue Jackets on Tuesday night at UBS Arena.

“I think I’ll just leave it at that. It’s a business and you can only dress 20 guys each game.”

He also said his stance on the contract hasn’t changed.

“It doesn’t change much from the last time I spoke,” Mayfield said. “You just stay ready.”

The bigger question now is whether there’s any real route back into the lineup. Mayfield has been out since Nov. 5, and when Newsday asked Pete DeBoer after Monday’s practice why he hasn’t played, the answer was blunt.

“All I can tell you is there’s no agenda here other than winning games and we’re going to put the best lineup on the ice that night in order to try and win a game,” DeBoer said. “Those are the decisions we’ve made so far, both on forwards and on defense and in net.”

The Islanders clearly value speed, and DeBoer knows this group has to keep up in a fast league. Mayfield has never been the quickest skater, but he has built his game on defending hard, killing penalties and bringing a physical presence, even if turnovers have occasionally been part of the package.

Still, the depth chart has not been kind to him. When the team had eight healthy defensemen, Mayfield was already eighth. Now, with Logan Stanley out day-to-day with a lower-body injury, he sits seventh out of seven.

Ben Hutton, who signed on Nov. 5 after joining the Islanders on a professional tryout agreement three days earlier, is set to skate on the third pair with offseason free-agent addition Matt Kessel. Stanley, meanwhile, was signed as a free agent on Sept. 27, just three days before the season opener, rather than have Mayfield in the opening-night lineup.

Mayfield’s last game came in a 5-3 loss to the Stanley Cup champion Hurricanes at UBS Arena, when he played a team-low 8:56 during the second game of Ryan Pulock’s four-game absence with a shoulder injury. Across his six appearances this season, Mayfield has no points, 12 penalty minutes and an average of 12:20 of ice time.

“I’ve seen it with different guys. I’ve seen it with young guys.

I’ve seen it with old guys. Every situation is different,” Mayfield said.

“It can be frustrating at times. You want to play.

That’s really all it is. The frustration isn’t anything other than you’re not in the lineup.

And that’s OK to be frustrated about.”

He said he still feels good when he does get on the ice.

“I feel good on the ice,” Mayfield said. “I know the game I need to play.

I like my penalty kill and I like what I’ve done defensively on the ice. That’s my main focus.

Some games are better than others. The Carolina game was my last one.

They’re a hard team and smothering and that was a more difficult game for me.”

One of his better outings came in Minnesota on Oct. 29, when he logged 15:51 in a 4-3 overtime win and Pulock got hurt on his first shift.

Pulock, who has been Mayfield’s teammate in both the AHL and NHL since being drafted 15th overall in 2013, said the veteran has handled the situation the right way.

“It’s hard but, for him, he keeps his head up and he comes to the rink every day,” Pulock told Newsday. “He puts in the work and he prepares himself to play and be ready every night.

Obviously, it’s something new in your career when it happens and it’s not easy to handle. But he’s such a professional that, every day, he shows up and works.”

Mayfield remains what he has long been: a third-pair defenseman. The issue is that the Islanders have treated him like much less than that.

In Other News...

Islanders Catch Columbus At A Moment That Could Shift Its Week

The Blue Jackets arrive on Long Island carrying more than just the weight of a disappointing start. Columbus is trying to steady itself after injuries to key players Conor Garland and Sean Monahan, and it is doing so without head coach Rick Bowness, who is away from the team because of an undisclosed health issue. Assistant coach Don Granato is running the bench for now, and the Islanders are catching a club that is still searching for a cleaner, more reliable version of itself.

This road trip could tell a lot about where Columbus is headed in the short term. The Blue Jackets are set to play the Islanders, then continue on to Chicago and Toronto, with the focus on finding more consistency and more offense before the trip is over. For New York, it is the kind of early-season opponent that can either be vulnerable or dangerous, depending on whether the Islanders let a struggling team settle in. [Read more 🡒]

Simon Holmstrom Is Making One Islanders Decision Look Risky

Simon Holmstroms first career hat trick did more than put a spotlight on his finishing touch. It also gave the Islanders another reminder that one of their quieter young forwards is starting to look like a real part of the clubs future, and maybe a more expensive one than the team might have preferred to address earlier. With his current two-year deal set to run out after this season, Holmstrom is moving toward restricted free agency at a time when his stock is rising and the market is expected to keep climbing with the NHL salary cap.

For the Islanders, the timing makes their decision to wait on a longer-term commitment look a little more precarious. Holmstrom has shown enough offensive growth to make a short bridge deal feel increasingly risky, especially if his production keeps trending up and his next contract has to be negotiated in a stronger cap environment. The club still has control, but the cost of keeping it may be heading in one direction, and it is not the cheaper one. [Read more 🡒]

Mathew Barzals Return Gives Islanders A Boost They Desperately Needed

Mathew Barzals season debut gave the Islanders a needed jolt, and it came with a familiar sight for fans at UBS Arena. After missing time with left knee inflammation, Barzal was back in the lineup against the Anaheim Ducks and picked up an assist, a reminder of how quickly he can change the feel of a game when he is on the ice.

Barzal said the recovery process was long and challenging, and the first night back came with the expected adjustment after six months away from game action. He also sounded energized by the chance to be back in front of the home crowd, with the Metropolitan Division still shaping up as a grind and every healthy body carrying extra weight for a team trying to keep pace. [Read more 🡒]