Matthew Schaefer doesn’t have to be told the spotlight is getting brighter. He can feel it. After a rookie season that pushed him straight into the NHL’s elite conversation, the Islanders defenseman is heading into Year 2 with the kind of expectations that usually come with established stars, not a 19-year-old coming off his first full season.
That’s the backdrop around Schaefer as camp opens: huge outside pressure, a looming extension after July 1, and a team that needs his game to keep climbing if it wants to get back to the playoffs after missing the last two seasons. But the message from inside the room is simple.
Don’t turn the volume up on the noise. Just keep going.
“It was a great first year, but it’s in the past now,” Schaefer told Newsday. “I wouldn’t say I’m a different person, but I’ve learned a lot more from my first year.
I’m able to take everything I learned from my first year from all the older guys and put it into the second year. The second year is a big year.
We didn’t make the playoffs and I take that personally.”
What he did last season was remarkable by any standard. Schaefer played all 82 games, tied the NHL rookie record for defensemen with 23 goals and set the league record for an 18-year-old defenseman with 59 points. He logged top-pair minutes, ran the first power-play unit and led the Islanders in average ice time at 24:41.
That production immediately placed him in the same broad conversation as some of the league’s best defensemen, including the Avalanche’s Cale Makar, the Wild’s Quinn Hughes and the Blue Jackets’ Zach Werenski. The question now is how much higher he can climb.
“Just watching him last year, he proved he’s probably a very top-tier defenseman in this league and you just want him to take that next step to be in that echelon of the Cale Makar conversation,” an NHL scout said.
The scout pointed first to the obvious part of Schaefer’s game.
“His skating, obviously. But I think just his ability to read plays before things happen.
He can read the play so well both offensively and defensively. His mind works at the same speed that he skates at.”
And the scout doesn’t see some massive overhaul as the path forward.
“If he just keeps on repeating what he did last year and keeps improving, then he’ll be right there,” the scout said. “The season that he had last year is definitely hard to replicate, especially as a 19-year-old player. But he’s head and shoulders above his age level right now.”
For those around him, though, the most striking thing about Schaefer isn’t just the skill. It’s the way he’s handled everything around it.
His mother, Jennifer, died at age 56 in February 2024 after a two-year battle with breast cancer. Todd Schaefer said the emotional and mental support from the Islanders organization - including former coach Patrick Roy and current coach Pete DeBoer - has mattered a great deal.
So has the home he’s had with executive Matt Martin, his wife, Sydney, and their four young children. Schaefer moved in with them during last year’s training camp, and the arrangement has become a real family setup, not a temporary one.
“He’s always asking questions,” Martin, a special assistant to general manager Mathieu Darche, told Newsday. “He wants to be one of the best players in the world.
He has the talent to do that. The big thing is he’s going to put so much pressure on himself.
He has high expectations for himself and there’s so much outside pressure on him already.
“Being a player, there’s adversity that you go through. When that’s going to come and what that’s going to be, you don’t know. But he’s strong enough mentally and talented enough as a player to continue on the trajectory that he’s on.
“I don’t think I have expectations for him as much as I’m just excited to see him continue to grow as a player and take another step. Expectations are sky-high when you tie and break every record that there possibly could have been. Managing that a little bit is the important thing.”
The Islanders have already made clear how highly they think of him. DeBoer considered Schaefer among the candidates to replace Anders Lee as captain before choosing Bo Horvat, and he called Schaefer a “future captain” during the preseason.
Todd Schaefer said he was relieved his son didn’t get that burden added so early.
For now, the focus is on the next stage of development, and even physically, Schaefer looks ready for it. He’s listed at 6-3 and 193 pounds, up from 6-2 and 186 last season. He said he spent less time on the ice this summer and more time in the gym.
“I was on the ice less this summer because when you’re playing that much, I was taking care of my body more in the gym,” Matthew Schaefer said. “I definitely do feel a little stronger.”
Horvat noticed it too.
“He looks bigger physically, which is great for the longevity of the season,” Horvat said. “I think he knows what to expect now.
His maturity that way is going to take him even further to another level this year. I’m looking forward to seeing what he can do.”
That’s the feeling around Schaefer now: anticipation, not surprise. He already showed what he can do as a rookie. The question in Year 2 is how far he can push it.
In Other News...
Islanders Reveal Peter DeBoers First Opening Night Line Combos
The Islanders are set to open the 2026-27 season on the road against the Maple Leafs, and with Peter DeBoer taking over behind the bench, the first projected lineup gives an early look at how the new coach wants things to look. Ilya Sorokin is slated to start in goal, with Bo Horvat, Simon Holmstrom and Kyle Palmieri among the forwards penciled into the opener, while the defensive pairings and extra skaters were arranged after recent practices.
Palmieris place in the group is a notable one as the Islanders head into opening night with a few moving parts still worth watching. The lineup also suggests there may be more to sort out among the bottom six than first glance indicates, and Anthony Duclairs placement on the fourth line adds another layer to the early-season picture as DeBoer settles on his first combination choices. [Read more 🡒]
Mathew Barzals Setback Wont End The Season Islanders Fans Want
Mathew Barzals latest knee setback is a familiar and frustrating development for Islanders fans, especially with the season approaching and his role once again in doubt. After the same issue kept him out for most of the 2024-25 campaign, the expectation is that he will begin this year on the sideline, leaving New York to manage early-season plans without one of its most dynamic players.
Still, Barzals outlook is not as bleak as the injury news suggests. His past performance trends point to a player whose impact can swing the Islanders offense if he gets back to full health and into a heavier workload, and the conversation around him now is less about whether the talent is still there than whether the body will cooperate long enough to let it show. For a team that needs him at his best, that uncertainty hangs over everything. [Read more 🡒]
Islanders Face A Brutal Metro Reality Few Fans Wanted
The Islanders are heading into the 2026-27 season with a group that looks awfully familiar, even after a summer that saw Anders Lee leave and Matias Maccelli arrive in free agency. Kyle Palmieri, Alexander Romanov and Ryan Pulock are back after injury absences, and young Victor Eklund has cracked the roster, giving the team at least a few fresh faces around a core that still looks largely intact.
For all of that, the early outside view is hardly flattering. The changes were modest, the roles are still being sorted out, and there is enough uncertainty around the lineup to leave the Islanders projecting as a team with more questions than momentum. In a division that rarely offers much room to hide, that kind of lukewarm outlook is exactly the sort of reality fans were hoping to avoid. [Read more 🡒]