As the offseason starts to close out, the Islanders may be circling back to a familiar name.
Oliver Wahlstrom, the former New York first-round pick, is back in the conversation as teams sort through unsigned players ahead of training camp. The 26-year-old was taken 11th overall by the Isles in 2018, arrived with plenty of upside, and never fully turned that promise into a permanent role on Long Island. By the 2024-25 season, he had slipped out of the picture and landed on waivers.
Boston took a chance on him, but the fit never really took hold. Wahlstrom managed just two points in 16 games with the Bruins, and last season ended without an NHL contract.
Now, a reunion with the Islanders does not sound out of the question. Isles insider Stefen Rosner said there has at least been some conversation about a possible return.
“Now, I did mention Oliver Wahlstrom as someone who could potentially return, as his agent has had talks with the Islanders about some kind of move. I still don’t think a PTO is likely if that does come to fruition. I think it's more likely he gets an AHL deal.”
That path could mean a camp invite and, more likely, a minor-league arrangement in Hamilton.
If that happens, the Islanders’ AHL group would get a useful boost. Wahlstrom produced 24 goals and 42 points in 62 games for the San Jose Barracuda last season, enough to show he still has some finishing ability even if the NHL call never came.
The bigger question is whether there’s anything left for him at the top level.
If Wahlstrom comes into camp and turns heads, he’d still be fighting for a thin slice of roster real estate. Kyle MacLean is one name in the mix for a fourth-line job, and Ondrej Palat is another possible hurdle. The Islanders could also decide to keep Wahlstrom as the 13th forward.
Still, the bar would be high. He would need to stand out in a big way to make the NHL roster, and that does not look like the most likely outcome.
Even if he earns some notice, the safer bet is an AHL deal that puts him near the front of the line for call-ups when injuries hit.
Wahlstrom is still young enough that a late turnaround is not impossible. If he can finally put it together, it would give the Islanders a surprising comeback story this season.
If not, the club still would have given him another shot, and he would have a chance to prove he belongs as a quality AHL player. In that sense, it could still work out for both sides.
In Other News...
Islanders Are Bringing Back A Controversial Look At A Strange Time
The NHLs new Hometown Remix collection is set to give all 32 teams special edition uniforms, and for the Islanders it is bringing back one of the franchises most debated looks. The fisherman logo is expected to return on a jersey for the 2026-27 season, giving the club another turn with a design that has long stirred strong opinions among fans and observers alike.
What makes the timing especially interesting is that this will be a one-season uniform, separate from the fan-designed third jersey currently up for voting for 2027-28. The upcoming fisherman look is expected to resemble the version the Bridgeport Islanders wore last season more than the original 1990s sweater, which adds another layer to a throwback that is being revived in a very modern way. [Read more 🡒]