The Islanders still don’t have their blue line fully sorted, and Friday night’s preseason matchup against the Rangers at UBS Arena only reinforced that reality.
Pete DeBoer entered the night still weighing his top four, while the back end spots behind them remained up for grabs. The pairings offered a few hints, but not enough to suggest the picture is settled.
Alexander Romanov and Ryan Pulock skated together after both sat out the first two preseason games. Romanov, who missed the final 62 games last season after shoulder surgery, is expected to be part of the top six. DeBoer, though, stopped short of putting him in the top four and said Romanov has “upside” there.
The uncertainty stretches beyond the top pairings and into the bottom of the roster, where Isaiah George and Matt Kessel were together as they, along with Scott Mayfield, battled for the sixth and seventh defense spots. Mayfield did not dress.
For George, the stakes are obvious. If he can’t crack the top six, it would be a major setback in the organization’s eyes, especially with the season opener set for Wednesday night in Toronto.
General manager Mathieu Darche said in the offseason that the 22-year-old would have every opportunity to make the team. George, a fourth-round pick in 2022, has played 37 NHL games and is entering his third season in the organization, but he has yet to seize the job.
He’s also the only left-handed shot among the third-pair candidates, with the winner presumably lining up next to right-handed Tony DeAngelo.
Kessel, 26, brings a different resume, having played 99 NHL games for the Blues. Mayfield, meanwhile, has been a fixture in the Islanders’ lineup for more than eight seasons.
“You’re just looking for stability,” DeBoer said. “You want to gain the coach’s trust.
A coach wants to feel good about putting those guys out there. We’re starting on the road in Toronto.
We don’t control the matchups. You have to feel OK that [Auston] Matthews’ line is going to jump over the boards and those guys are going to be OK.”
There are still more moving parts. DeBoer’s choice to keep left-handed Matthew Schaefer on his off-side with fellow lefty Adam Pelech on the top pair will affect how the rest of the defense is arranged.
Romanov’s return is another important piece. He’s entering the second season of an eight-year, $50 million contract, and he’s listed at 6-1 and 207 pounds, 13 pounds lighter than he was at last year’s camp after changing his eating habits.
“I’m just excited to play my first game since I was injured,” Romanov said. “It doesn’t matter if it’s a preseason game because we’ve got to play our preseason games exactly how we’re going to play in the season.
I just want to come back and feel how it feels to be a hockey player. When you don’t play for almost a whole year, you miss the game.”
Pulock, who also dealt with shoulder surgery in the offseason, was glad to have him back.
“Missing him for a good portion of last year was a big blow,” Pulock said.
DeBoer said Romanov and Pulock will also play Saturday against the Devils at UBS Arena. The roster cutdown to 23 players comes Monday after that preseason finale.
So the answers are coming. Just not all at once. The defense remains in flux.
In Other News...
Scott Mayfields Islanders Role Suddenly Feels Open To Debate
Scott Mayfield has long been one of those Islanders players whose value has never been measured only by box score lines. Former beat writer Arthur Staple recently pointed out the defensemans willingness to drop the gloves, noting that Mayfield has fought 47 times in his NHL career. Staple also made clear that, whatever anyone thinks of the effectiveness of those fights, he respects Mayfields personality and the kind of presence he has brought to the team.
Now the bigger question is whether that presence still translates into a secure role. The Islanders are trying out other looks on the right side, and Mayfield finds himself in a position battle at a time when the roster is being shuffled around. For a player whose edge and identity have made him a fixture for so long, the debate is no longer just about what he brings in the rough stuff, but where he fits in the lineup going forward. [Read more 🡒]
Kashawn Aitcheson Is Giving Islanders Fans A Real Reason To Wonder
The preseason loss to the Rangers hardly told the whole story for the Islanders, who iced a lineup heavy on AHL players while New Yorks opponent dressed what looked like its likely Opening Night group. In that kind of mismatch, the bigger takeaway was not the score so much as the way Kashawn Aitcheson handled himself, with the 2025 draft pick continuing to look like a defenseman worth watching as the organization sorts out its next wave of talent.
Aitcheson has already shown the kind of offensive touch in junior hockey that makes him stand out from a lot of young blueliners, and thats why he keeps popping up in conversations about the Islanders future. He is not expected to crack the Opening Night roster, but performances like this keep the door from closing too quickly, and for a team searching for reasons to be hopeful beyond the present, that matters. [Read more 🡒]
Casey Cizikas Nears Rare Islanders Mark With Plenty Still To Prove
Casey Cizikas is closing in on one of the more unusual milestones in modern hockey, with his next stretch of games set to carry him toward 1,000 NHL appearances. What makes the number stand out even more is where he has spent every one of those games so far - with the Islanders, a rare run of longevity and loyalty in a league where careers often get broken up by trades and free-agent moves.
The milestone would arrive early in the season if he stays in the lineup, giving Cizikas a chance to hit it while still doing the kind of work the Islanders have always asked of him. For a player who has built his career on consistency and team-first responsibility, the personal marker is nice, but the bigger question is how much he can still help shape the Islanders' success once the puck drops for real. [Read more 🡒]