David Stearns spent Monday doing something he can’t really afford to do often: sitting in the wreckage and saying it out loud.
The Mets’ president of baseball operations didn’t dodge the obvious after a season that went off the rails. He admitted the decisions he made last offseason helped create the disaster, and he made clear there won’t be any time machine coming to save him.
“We and I made a number of decisions that created the potential for almost an uncapped downside scenario,” he said at his Citi Field postmortem. “I think we try to learn from everything, and I think the entire offseason last year was a learning experience for me.”
Stearns has never come off like a man who wears his emotions on his sleeve. His delivery is calm, his answers are precise, and that can make it easy to mistake restraint for detachment. But Monday was different in one important way: he spent more than a half-hour owning the failures and sketching out what has to change.
“[What we] experienced this past weekend, what we just experienced in Washington, where you are literally playing out the string - it’s miserable,” he said. “That’s a miserable experience for players, for coaches, for executives. So I think we have an extraordinarily motivated organization from ownership on down to ensure that never happens again.”
The fixes he outlined were direct. The Mets need more from first and second base.
They plan to add to the top of the rotation. He wants more flexibility on the roster.
And while the organization still wants to build around a strong prospect pipeline, Stearns made it clear there will also be big swings.
“There are going to be selective, very aggressive pursuits [in free agency]. We have complete ownership support.”
One of the more interesting parts of his remarks was Stearns acknowledging something that has long been part of the Mets conversation: not every player is built to handle New York. He said his thinking has changed after seeing how players react when they arrive and when they leave.
“I think [my opinion has changed], yes,” he said. “When you live it and you see player reactions, both when they come here and when they leave here and you hear them talk about some of the differences that they experience here - I do think it’s important to have players here that lean into that and that enjoy it, because it’s unlike anywhere else.”
He followed that with the kind of blunt line that explains why the market can be so unforgiving here.
“When you win here, it’s the greatest thing in the world . . . It’s equally extreme when things aren’t going well, and I do think certain players struggle with that.”
That pressure lands on executives too, and no one on the Mets feels it more than Stearns. The decision not to re-sign Pete Alonso last offseason is the kind of move that can linger for the rest of his run. And even though he grew up a Mets fan, the same question now hangs over him that he’s asking about the players he wants to bring in: can he handle this place?
The answer is still being written. But Stearns does seem to understand the categories now: the people who can thrive in this chaos, the people who can’t, and the ones who figure it out.
This past offseason produced all three. Luke Weaver fit the first group.
Freddy Peralta landed in the second. Bo Bichette started getting buried by boos and still clawed his way out of it.
That third path is the hardest one. Once the failures pile up and the noise starts getting louder, it gets into your head. And then it can start feeding the next mistake.
That’s the road Stearns has to navigate now if he’s going to repair this thing.
The offseason he just went through was supposed to be difficult. The next one looks even worse.
The free-agent class is thin outside a few standouts. A looming lockout could cut into the 2027 season, and a new collective bargaining agreement is expected to reshape the way teams operate.
All of that is coming while the Mets sit in the aftermath of a season that left the organization, in Stearns’ own words, smelling like failure.
Still, Monday offered a reason to believe there’s at least some self-awareness here. Stearns was direct, and he sounded intent on correcting the blind spots that helped get the Mets into this mess. The club also has continuity with Andy Green in place as manager, and the younger players Stearns brought in give next year’s roster some real intrigue.
“The disappointment of our season is very true and real,” he said. “We, as an organization, feel that.
Our fan base feels that. There’s no denying any of that.
There is also the real foundation here for the level of success and competitiveness that we expect to have.”
He can’t undo what happened. He can only try to make sure the next round of decisions doesn’t send the Mets right back here. Whether he becomes the right person to pull that off will depend on what he does with the failure he’s already earned.
In Other News...
Islanders Were In On Kirill Marchenko But One Big Hurdle Loomed
Kirill Marchenkos name was one of the more intriguing ones floating around the trade market, and the Islanders were among the teams doing their homework. Columbus ultimately moved the winger to the Maple Leafs in a deal headlined by Matthew Knies and other pieces, but the wider field around Marchenko helps explain why the Blue Jackets had so many moving parts to consider before pulling the trigger.
New York was never alone in the chase, with Montreal reportedly involved right up to the end and interest also coming from Boston, Seattle and Tampa Bay. Blue Jackets GM Don Waddell said Marchenko preferred to play elsewhere, though he did not spell out why, leaving the sort of unfinished background story that often shapes whether a team keeps pushing or moves on to the next name on its list. [Read more 🡒]
Islanders Just Sent A Clear Message About Matthew Schaefer
The Islanders have signaled plenty of confidence in Matthew Schaefer before he has even settled into his NHL career, and now the organization is putting that belief into a visible leadership role. For the 2026-27 season, the club has named its alternate captains, a group that includes Ryan Pulock, Kyle Palmieri and Brayden Schenn, while Bo Horvat remains the captain at the top of the room.
Schaefer, the No. 1 pick in the 2025 NHL Draft, is the youngest name in that mix by a wide margin, which makes the assignment stand out even more. The Islanders are clearly looking beyond just his on-ice upside and treating him like part of their leadership core, a strong indication of how central they believe he can become as this roster continues to take shape. [Read more 🡒]
Islanders Face A Brutal Metro Reality Few Fans Wanted
The Islanders are heading into the 2026-27 season with a group that looks familiar in a lot of places, even after a summer that brought Anders Lees departure and Matias Maccelli in as a free-agent addition. Kyle Palmieri, Alexander Romanov and Ryan Pulock are back after injury, Victor Eklund has cracked the roster, and the hope is that a healthier lineup can give a steadier picture than the one they carried through much of last year.
Still, the outside view is not especially kind, and the concern around this team goes beyond simple continuity. With so little roster turnover and a few role questions still hanging over the group, the Islanders are already being treated like a team that has to prove it can keep pace in a division that leaves little margin for error, especially with the uncertainty surrounding Mathew Barzal adding another layer to an uneasy start. [Read more 🡒]