The Islanders’ offseason debate has a simple hinge point: can Cole Eiserman force his way into the picture?
New York looks split between two timelines. The veteran group gives the team a chance to chase the playoffs, while the younger wave, led by franchise defenseman Matthew Schaefer, points toward a future built on speed and upside. That push and pull is real, and the organization’s direction may come down to which side gains the upper hand.
Eiserman is the name that could tilt things.
The 2024 first-round pick showed plenty last season, putting up 28 points in 32 NCAA games at Boston University and adding nine points in 12 games with the Bridgeport Islanders. That production gives him a real case for a bigger role, especially with open space on the wing. Daily Faceoff’s projected lineup has the top-six wing spots filled by Emil Heineman, Kyle Palmieri, Calum Ritchie and Mathew Barzal, but that doesn’t close the door on Eiserman.
Barzal is a fixture, but Eiserman has the talent and the runway to fight his way into that mix. Even more interesting, his most direct competition may not be on the Islanders’ roster yet. 2025 first-round pick Victor Eklund is also pushing for a spot and could make the battle among the forwards even more competitive.
There’s a wrinkle, though. Eklund is a right winger and Eiserman plays left, but the Islanders could still decide that carrying two rookie wingers right away is too much risk and start one in Bridgeport. If that happens, it wouldn’t be a surprise if one or both are up with the Islanders at some point during the season.
That’s why Eiserman matters beyond his own stat line. If he earns a job and produces, it could strengthen the case for the organization to keep leaning into the youth movement. That kind of development can force harder choices on the veteran side, including moving on from long-time players, but those decisions are part of the transition eventually anyway.
For now, the Islanders have a clear window to sort it out. Training camp opens Thursday at 6 p.m., and Eiserman will have camp and the preseason to show he can be a go-to option moving forward. If he and Eklund both make noise, the argument for a younger core only gets louder.
Darche has already shown what he thinks of Eiserman’s best trait. Asked about him early last season, he said, "We know Cole," Darche began.
"He's a goal scorer. That's something you can't teach.
Like any player, there are things everybody needs to work on, but he's got a skill that's tough to teach, and that's scoring goals. So we're excited to have him.”
In a few weeks, the picture should be much clearer - both for the roster and for where Eiserman fits into it.
In Other News...
Islanders Are Bringing Back A Controversial Look Fans Never Forgot
A familiar flash of teal and orange is coming back to the Islanders uniforms this season, and it will be there in a form that fans of a certain era will recognize immediately. The club is planning to wear a shoulder patch tied to the 2027 NHL All-Star Weekend, a design that nods back to the mid-1990s Fisherman look with its waves and lighthouse imagery.
The patch is more than a nostalgia play, though, because it points ahead to a big moment for the franchise and UBS Arena. The Islanders are set to host the NHL All-Star Game in February 2027, their first time welcoming the leagues showcase event since 1983, so this seasons uniform detail is really the first public sign of whats coming. [Read more 🡒]
Islanders Camp Opens With One Big Health Concern Up Front
The Islanders opened 2026 training camp with the usual September sorting drill, splitting the roster into Blue, White and Orange groups for practice, but the first day of work quickly turned into a health check. Several familiar names were back on the ice after long rehabs, giving the group a more complete look than the club has had for stretches in recent seasons, and it was a welcome sight for a team trying to get its legs under it before the schedule tightens.
Mathew Barzal was the notable absence from the first skate, and his knee inflammation immediately became the biggest concern around camp. The Islanders are expecting him to be sidelined for two weeks, which puts an early wrinkle in the start of camp and leaves the club waiting to see how the rest of the opening stretch unfolds without one of its most important pieces. [Read more 🡒]
Varlamovs Comeback Gives Islanders One Huge Question In Net
Ilya Varlamovs return gives the Islanders a much different look in goal, and it also brings back the kind of depth they have been missing while he worked his way through a major knee overhaul. After double knee surgery and a long rehabilitation process, the veteran is back on the ice and back in the mix, which is the sort of development a team notices immediately when it comes to managing a seasons workload.
Pete DeBoer has stayed measured about where Varlamov is in the comeback process, but there is obvious value in simply having another proven option available behind Ilya Sorokin. Varlamov has made it clear he was not ready to walk away from the NHL, and his decision to take the risk of surgery rather than retire leaves the Islanders with a real goaltending decision that could shape how the net is handled moving forward. [Read more 🡒]