Mathieu Darche has asked for patience since taking over as general manager of the New York Islanders, but The Athletic’s latest contract efficiency rankings suggest the wait may be necessary for a different reason.
In the outlet’s annual look at every NHL contract, the Islanders landed 28th among 32 teams. That was a small step up from last year’s 29th-place finish, and with little roster turnover, the placement wasn’t exactly a shock. What was striking was the explanation behind it.
Dom Luszczyszyn’s analysis pointed directly at the Islanders’ cluster of low-end deals, and several of them trace back to Darche’s first offseason running the team.
"No team has more D-level deals than the Islanders," The Athletic wrote. "The worst part is that four of them came on Mathieu Darche's first year on the job. Extending Alexander Romanov immediately backfired, giving up value for both Brayden Schenn and Ondrej Palat was odd given their contracts, and extending Jean-Gabriel Pageau instead of moving him was a misstep."
That is a tough verdict for a front office that has barely had time to settle in.
The report also took aim at Darche’s move to bring in Schenn, his decision to absorb Ondrej Palat’s $6 million cap hit, the three-year extension for Pageau and Romanov’s new contract, which now makes him the highest-paid defenseman on the roster.
There were a couple of bright spots in the numbers, and both were tied to Lou Lamoriello and a bit of ping pong luck. The Athletic called Matthew Schaefer’s entry-level contract arguably the best value in the NHL, while Ilya Sorokin’s long-term deal was also viewed as one of the strongest contracts for a starting goaltender.
Even so, those bargains weren’t enough to lift the Islanders out of the lower tier. For now, the model leaves Darche’s first offseason looking rough. Whether that judgment holds will come down to what happens on the ice.
In Other News...
Islanders Fans Wont Love How This Patrik Laine Interest Looks
When NHL free agency opened, Patrik Laines name briefly surfaced in Islanders circles, but the interest never sounded especially aggressive. New York already has a surplus of forwards, and with roster spots and cap decisions still being sorted out around the league, the club does not appear to be pushing hard to add another scorer at this stage.
Laines market may not be settled yet, though, and that leaves the door cracked open if his search drags on. His agents could always circle back to the Islanders later if the winger remains unsigned, but for now this looks more like a team keeping tabs than one preparing to make a real run. [Read more 🡒]
Islanders Center Ranking Missed One Crucial Piece Of The Puzzle
The Athletics Harman Dayal took a swing at the Islanders center depth and came away unimpressed, slotting the clubs top-six group below average on the strength of Bo Horvat and Brayden Schenn. Horvats recent production was part of the case, and the broader concern was simple enough: if those are the names driving the middle of the lineup, it is hard to place the Islanders among the better teams down the middle.
But the evaluation may be missing the part that matters most to New York. Pete DeBoer has indicated Mathew Barzal is expected to shift back to center, and that changes the whole conversation about how the Islanders can line up. If Barzal is back where he belongs and paired with Horvat, the group starts to look a lot less ordinary and a lot more like a strength the rest of the league has to account for. [Read more 🡒]
Islanders Face A Franchise Defining Choice On Proven Scoring Help
Kirill Marchenkos name has started to surface in trade chatter, and that alone is enough to put the Islanders in an uncomfortable spot. The Blue Jackets forward is viewed as a proven scoring help option, which makes him appealing to a team that could use more offense, but the price tag is expected to be steep enough to force real soul-searching in New York.
The Islanders are still trying to rebuild their prospect pipeline, and that makes any aggressive pursuit a complicated fit for a front office that has stressed patience and a longer view. General manager Mathieu Darche has leaned hard into that approach, so even if Marchenko remains the kind of player who would draw interest, this looks like the sort of deal that would have to clear a very high bar before New York seriously bites. [Read more 🡒]