The Mets are already staring down a busy offseason, and a few familiar names may not make it to Opening Day 2027. After a year that fell well short of expectations, New York has a new core taking shape - but there are also several players whose grip on roster spots looks awfully shaky.
Marcus Semien sits near the top of that group after a brutal first year in New York. His production cratered on both sides of the ball, and the numbers tell the story.
In 139 games, he hit .215 with 15 home runs, posted a 74 wRC+, and finished with the second-worst OPS among qualified players at .619. The defense slipped just as badly.
One year after winning a Gold Glove at second base, Semien turned into one of the league’s worst defenders there, putting up -9 OAA. His -0.4 fWAR underscored how little he gave the Mets overall.
New York still owes him $56 million over the next two seasons, but moving that deal could be tough. If no trade materializes, the Mets may have to DFA him.
They could keep him around as a bench bat, but with his bat, defense and speed all trending down, that’s a hard sell when Brett Baty and top prospect Jefferson Rojas are options at second.
Mark Vientos is another name whose future feels murky. After breaking out in 2024 with 27 homers in 111 games, he hasn’t built on that momentum over the last two seasons.
This year, he hit .212/.258/.394 with 13 home runs and a 78 wRC+ in 87 games. Moving from third base to first didn’t fix the defensive problems either, as he finished at -10 OAA.
Vientos is under contract for two more seasons and is heading into his first year of arbitration eligibility. The Mets could keep him as a power bat off the bench, but a non-tender or trade looks more likely than that kind of role.
Bo Bichette’s situation is different because the decision may be his. He has the first of two opt-outs to weigh this winter, and reports have pointed in different directions on what he plans to do.
After a slow start through the first month-plus, Bichette settled in and looked much more like himself. He finished at .259/.311/.389 with 18 home runs and a 96 wRC+.
If he opts in, the Mets would owe him $42 million for 2027. That is a huge number for a player coming off a down year by his standards.
Still, he’ll turn 29 next year, so the window to land a long-term deal is narrowing, which could push him toward opting out.
Ronny Mauricio is in a tougher spot because the roster math may simply not work in his favor. He’s out of minor league options, and that alone puts his future in New York in doubt.
He managed just 13 hits in 59 major-league at-bats this season. His best chance came in 2023, when he finally reached the majors and flashed the talent that once made him the Mets’ top prospect.
But that progress was halted when he tore his ACL while playing in the Dominican Winter League that offseason. With no obvious role and no easy way to send him back down, the Mets may have to choose between a trade or a non-tender.
Kodai Senga might be the hardest player on the list to pin down. He’s entering the final year of his five-year, $75 million contract, and his future may depend on how the Mets want to use him.
His run as a starter this season went sideways fast: in eight starts, he went 0-7 with a 9.66 ERA. Since moving into the closer role, though, he’s looked far sharper, going 8-for-9 in save chances and showing better command.
The Mets would like to keep him in the bullpen, but Senga has made it clear he wants to return to the rotation. If that divide can’t be bridged, a trade could be the cleanest answer.
Huascar Myers is also in a tricky spot after an uneven season that never really settled into a clear role. Acquired from the Milwaukee Brewers along with Freddy Peralta before the season, he was expected to matter either as a starter or a reliever.
The Mets opened with him in the bullpen, where he pitched well early and kept his ERA under 3.00 through April while giving them length. But when the rotation needed help, they sent him to Triple-A Syracuse to stretch him out.
Instead of coming back quickly, he struggled badly and spent most of the second half in the minors. By season’s end, his ERA had climbed to 5.64.
He’s out of minor league options, and with the Mets needing bullpen help this winter, he may get passed by Austin Warren and Nate Lavender.
In Other News...
Islanders Were In On Kirill Marchenko But One Big Hurdle Loomed
Kirill Marchenkos name was one of the more intriguing ones floating around the trade market, and the Islanders were among the teams doing their homework. Columbus ultimately moved the winger to the Maple Leafs in a deal headlined by Matthew Knies and other pieces, but the wider field around Marchenko helps explain why the Blue Jackets had so many moving parts to consider before pulling the trigger.
New York was never alone in the chase, with Montreal reportedly involved right up to the end and interest also coming from Boston, Seattle and Tampa Bay. Blue Jackets GM Don Waddell said Marchenko preferred to play elsewhere, though he did not spell out why, leaving the sort of unfinished background story that often shapes whether a team keeps pushing or moves on to the next name on its list. [Read more 🡒]
Islanders Just Sent A Clear Message About Matthew Schaefer
The Islanders have signaled plenty of confidence in Matthew Schaefer before he has even settled into his NHL career, and now the organization is putting that belief into a visible leadership role. For the 2026-27 season, the club has named its alternate captains, a group that includes Ryan Pulock, Kyle Palmieri and Brayden Schenn, while Bo Horvat remains the captain at the top of the room.
Schaefer, the No. 1 pick in the 2025 NHL Draft, is the youngest name in that mix by a wide margin, which makes the assignment stand out even more. The Islanders are clearly looking beyond just his on-ice upside and treating him like part of their leadership core, a strong indication of how central they believe he can become as this roster continues to take shape. [Read more 🡒]
Islanders Face A Brutal Metro Reality Few Fans Wanted
The Islanders are heading into the 2026-27 season with a group that looks familiar in a lot of places, even after a summer that brought Anders Lees departure and Matias Maccelli in as a free-agent addition. Kyle Palmieri, Alexander Romanov and Ryan Pulock are back after injury, Victor Eklund has cracked the roster, and the hope is that a healthier lineup can give a steadier picture than the one they carried through much of last year.
Still, the outside view is not especially kind, and the concern around this team goes beyond simple continuity. With so little roster turnover and a few role questions still hanging over the group, the Islanders are already being treated like a team that has to prove it can keep pace in a division that leaves little margin for error, especially with the uncertainty surrounding Mathew Barzal adding another layer to an uneasy start. [Read more 🡒]