J.J. McCarthy finally got a real look with the New York Giants on Sunday, and the conversation around his future didn’t stay on the field for long.
In Week 6 against the New Orleans Saints, the former Minnesota Vikings first-round pick attempted 21 passes and completed 11 of them. It wasn’t a sparkling line - 52.4% completion rate - but he still managed 243 yards and a touchdown, enough to at least make the case that he can be a usable option for New York. At 23 years old, there’s still room for that to grow into something more.
That’s where Dave Portnoy comes in. The Barstool founder, owner, and University of Michigan fan has been high on McCarthy for a while, and after watching him land with the Giants, he made it clear he thinks Minnesota never gave him a proper shot.
“I never thought he got a fair shake in Minnesota. He never got a fair shake.
He got hurt right away and then never got back in the flow. I’ve always been a JJ fan.
I saw what he did every single game at Michigan. I said when the Giants got him, they got a winner,” Portnoy said, H/T Heavy.
The argument isn’t hard to follow. McCarthy played only 10 games for the Vikings and went through multiple injuries during his stint there, so he never really had the runway to settle in. That much is plain.
What he showed at Michigan is still part of the appeal, and that’s why it’s not unreasonable to think he could become a quality player down the line. Whether he ends up being the right answer for the Giants this season is another question, and there are still questions about what happens next year with Jaxson Dart returning. But if McCarthy can get himself back on track, there’s at least a path toward becoming a solid NFL quarterback.
In Other News...
Giants Face A Defining Roster Decision As QB Change Begins
With J.J. McCarthy set to make his first start of the week against the Texans, the Giants are entering a stretch where every roster decision feels a little louder than usual. The quarterback switch gives the team a fresh look heading into Week 7, but it also keeps the focus on a group still trying to sort out its depth and identity after moving on from running back Najee Harris.
Paulson Adebos return from injured reserve adds another layer to that picture, especially with the cornerback practicing in a limited capacity after a knee injury. Even as the Giants work through the immediate demands of the new quarterback setup, there is still plenty of attention on how the roster may evolve around him, with the front office facing questions about whether more changes could be coming. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Trade Deadline Picture Suddenly Includes One Surprising Name
The Giants head into the trade deadline in a strange spot, sitting atop the division while still dealing with the kind of injury issues that can change a rosters direction in a hurry. That has opened the door to some unexpected names surfacing in the conversation, including Kayvon Thibodeaux and Cam Skattebo, as the front office weighs whether to hold steady or listen if the right offer comes along.
Jameis Winston is the one who really adds a jolt to the discussion, because his situation suggests a role that no longer looks as stable as it once did. Add in the fact that the Giants are trying to balance short-term competitiveness with longer-term roster value, and deadline chatter around a player like Winston feels like the sort of thing that could move quickly if the market develops the right way. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Suddenly Need Answers From Trace Ford
Trace Fords path to a bigger opportunity with the Giants has opened quickly, and it comes at a time when the team is trying to piece together its edge-rush rotation. New York brought Ford up from the practice squad to the active roster while moving on from Jihad Ward, a roster shuffle that signals the club wants a better look at what Ford can offer beyond spot duty.
Ford has appeared in three games, with seven tackles and no starts or sacks, so the next step is less about projecting production and more about finding out whether he can handle a more defined role on passing downs. With the Giants dealing with injuries around the edge, the evaluation matters now, and Ford suddenly has a chance to show whether he can be part of the answer rather than just an emergency add. [Read more 🡒]