Micah McFadden's 2025 season was cut short after just 11 snaps due to a Lisfranc foot injury, sidelining him for the year and leaving the Giants' defense struggling against the run. His absence was felt more than anticipated, as the Giants rotated through a series of linebackers like Darius Muasau, Demetrius Flannigan-Fowles, Swayze Bozeman, Zaire Barnes, and Neville Hewitt alongside Bobby Okereke, none of whom were ideally suited for full-time roles.
The injury was particularly untimely for McFadden, who was in his free agent season, the final year of his rookie contract. Missing the chance to build on a strong 2024 season, he was deprived of a potential lucrative free agency opportunity. Reflecting on the season, McFadden expressed gratitude for his career despite the setback, remaining optimistic about his future in football.
With the Giants entering a new era under head coach John Harbaugh and defensive coordinator Dennard Wilson, the question arises: Should they bring McFadden back in 2026? Given the instability at linebacker last season and the possibility of Bobby Okereke becoming a cap casualty, McFadden could provide much-needed stability.
McFadden might have to consider a "prove-it" deal due to the missed opportunity to secure a big contract, with Spotrac estimating his market value at one-year, $2.4 million. However, his career tackle attempt miss rate of 15.6% raises questions about his ability to finish plays, potentially due to athletic limitations. This could lead Harbaugh and Wilson to seek faster, more athletic options at linebacker.
Ultimately, bringing McFadden back could be a wise move for the Giants, offering them a chance to stabilize their defense with a familiar face eager to prove himself.