Jevon Holland’s second season with the Giants arrives with a spotlight attached to it.
New York handed the safety an $18.5 million cap hit for 2026, and after a first year that didn’t come close to matching the investment, the question is simple: was the Giants’ bet on him misplaced, or just delayed? That answer starts to take shape Sunday night against Dallas.
The Giants didn’t pay for a mystery. They paid for the player Holland already was in Miami - a versatile back-end defender with a strong coverage résumé and real ball skills.
Over four seasons with the Dolphins, he put together five interceptions, 25 passes defensed and five sacks, the kind of all-around production that made him one of the most attractive free-agent safeties on the 2025 market. His PFF numbers reflected that ceiling, too: an 84.7 overall grade in 2021 and a 90.4 mark in 2023, with a career 91.3 coverage grade that ranked fifth among safeties since he entered the league, per PFF.
That track record helped Holland land a three-year, $45.3 million deal with $30.3 million guaranteed and a $12 million signing bonus, according to Spotrac. It was a major commitment before he ever played a snap in blue.
Year 1, though, was rough. Holland finished with a 58.4 PFF overall grade in 2025, which ranked 73rd out of 98 qualified safeties.
Quarterbacks also posted a 93.9 passer rating when throwing into his coverage. For a player carrying that kind of cap number, the return was nowhere near what the Giants needed.
The slide wasn’t totally out of nowhere. Holland’s grades had already dipped to 67.2 in 2022 and 63.0 in 2024, so the inconsistency had shown up before he reached New York. But the Giants were banking on the higher end of the player, not the uneven version.
There is still a path for this to look different in Year 2. New defensive coordinator Dennard Wilson comes in from Tennessee, where he handled the same role for two seasons, and a clearer job in a new system can matter for a free safety who thrives when he can play instead of process. Holland also has Tyler Nubin beside him again, and the Giants will need that pairing to produce more takeaways after Nubin logged heavy snaps as a rookie without an interception in 2025.
If Wilson gives Holland room to roam, the Giants could finally get the version of him they thought they were buying. That’s the hope. Now comes the proof.
And the timing is sharp: Sunday night’s opener against Dallas at MetLife puts Holland on a stage built to test the deep part of the field. He has one year of guaranteed money left after this season, which makes the pressure even more immediate.
The talent has never been the issue. The tape in a Giants uniform has to catch up.
In Other News...
Giants Turn To Familiar Ravens Pipeline As Linebacker Need Grows
The Giants added a familiar face to their linebacker room by signing veteran Malik Harrison to the practice squad, a move that gives them another experienced option as they look to stabilize the position. Harrison arrives with five seasons of familiarity from his time under John Harbaugh in Baltimore, then spent a year with the Steelers before landing in New York, giving the Giants a veteran who knows the league and the kind of system demands that come with it.
New York will need to clear space on its 17-player practice squad to make the addition official, but Harrison is expected to be in the mix quickly. For a defense that can always use more depth in the middle of the field, the appeal is obvious, and the Giants are leaning once again on a Ravens-connected pipeline to patch a need before it becomes a bigger problem. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Still Have One Unsettled Roster Issue Before Week 1
The Giants have spent the late stages of the summer still surveying the market for help along the defensive front, with general manager Joe Schoen making it clear he wants to upgrade at defensive tackle. New York has also brought in several defensive linemen for workouts, a sign the team is keeping the door open to adding depth before Week 1.
Practice-squad options are already in place, but the search has not produced a confirmed trade or signing yet, leaving one roster spot on the interior line very much unsettled. For a team trying to get the defense ready for opening weekend, it is the kind of lingering issue that can still shape how the first few games look once the games start counting. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Have One Linebacker Decision Still Hanging Over Roster Cuts
The Giants trimmed their linebacker room as part of roster cuts, and most of the names that hit the wire have already landed somewhere else, either on active rosters or practice squads. One holdover remains in a more uncertain spot: Anfernee Orji, the late-July addition who arrived with some NFL experience from the Saints and Titans and was still working back after a torn ACL.
Orjis situation is a reminder that roster cutdowns are rarely the end of the story in late August, especially for players trying to re-establish themselves after injury. NFL rosters are still shifting, which leaves open the possibility that his next stop could come soon, but for now he is the lone Giants linebacker from that group still waiting for a new opportunity. [Read more 🡒]