Jaxson Dart’s Week 1 breakout should have been the easy part for anyone ranking quarterbacks. Three touchdown passes.
A stunning upset of the Dallas Cowboys. A debut that forced everybody to pay attention.
Instead, Pro Football Focus doubled down and handed Dart the kind of ranking that had people wondering if the service watched the same game. Entering Week 2, Dart was slotted as the league’s eighth-worst quarterback, with Gordon McGuinness placing him at No. 25.
“He did produce a pair of turnover-worthy plays but also ranked in the top three in both completion percentage over expectation and accuracy over expectation,” McGuinness wrote of Dart.
That explanation didn’t do much to calm the backlash. PFF’s latest quarterback rankings have become a fresh lightning rod, and Dart is only part of the reason why.
The bigger issue is how the list handled the names around him. Sam Darnold and Kyler Murray, who combined for seven passes before leaving their games with hip and head injuries, were ranked No. 14 and No. 21, respectively.
Darnold completed a 13-yard pass, threw an incompletion and took a sack before heading to the locker room. Murray went 3-of-5 with an interception.
McGuinness said he was working from preseason rankings put together by Max Chadwick and Dalton Wasserman, and he argued there shouldn’t be huge swings yet because of the “small sample size.” But that only raises the obvious question: why publish the rankings if the sample is too small to matter?
The criticism around PFF has been building for days. The service already took heat for giving Bears quarterback Caleb Williams a 64.0 grade after he put up 334 yards, including 269 passing and 65 rushing, with four touchdowns - two through the air and two on the ground - and no turnovers in a win over the Panthers. PFF then followed up with an explanation of its process.
“What the grade measures is the part of the play the quarterback actually controls - the read, the decision, the throw,” PFF’s Mark Chichester wrote. “Not the result that lands in the box score.”
Chichester also said Williams, who went 21-of-29 and helped the Bears score 59 points, finished 6.8 percentage points “below expectation in accuracy.”
McGuinness’ latest list didn’t help the service’s case. Stafford checked in at No. 5 despite, as McGuinness wrote, “Among quarterbacks with at least 20 dropbacks, only two earned a lower PFF grade than Stafford’s 41.5,” and “He didn’t record a big-time throw and produced three turnover-worthy plays.”
And then there was Drake Maye. The Patriots quarterback landed at No. 9.
In Other News...
Giants Already Face Questions About Their Malachi Fields Decision
The Giants entered Week 1 already carrying a little draft-day intrigue with rookie wide receiver Malachi Fields, and his first NFL outing only sharpened it. New York traded up to take Fields ahead of Caleb Douglas, who went right after him, and the early comparison was hard to miss once the games started. Fields had a modest debut and was not a primary part of the Giants passing attack, which left his first showing feeling more like a starting point than a statement.
Douglas, meanwhile, stepped into a major role for Miami and immediately looked the part. The Dolphins made him a key receiver in their opener, and he answered with a franchise-record performance for receiving yards in his debut. For the Giants, that kind of contrast does not settle anything this early, but it does give the Fields decision a bit more weight after just one week. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Just Sent A Clear Message About Their Cornerback Situation
The Giants are adding another name to the cornerback mix, signing former Broncos defensive back Jaden Robinson to the practice squad and bringing him back together with defensive backs coach Addison Lynch. It is a small move on paper, but one that fits the larger picture around a secondary that has already drawn scrutiny for both health and performance coming out of Week 1.
Robinson has yet to play a regular-season NFL snap, so this is more about insurance and familiarity than an immediate fix. Still, the timing says plenty about where the Giants see the position group right now, and it suggests they are keeping the door open for added depth if the situation in the secondary keeps moving in the wrong direction. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Just Sent A Clear Message About Their Rams Game Plan
With the Rams on deck in Week 2, the Giants made a roster tweak that says plenty about how they expect to attack the matchup. New York promoted defensive lineman Josh Tupou from the practice squad and sent wide receiver Dalen Cambre back down, a move that adds another body up front as the team prepares for a Los Angeles rushing attack.
Tupou, signed earlier in the offseason, also brings a familiar connection to the coaching side after previously spending time with head coach John Harbaugh in Baltimore. For the Giants, the shuffle is less about offense and more about making sure the defensive line is ready for a game that figures to be fought in the trenches. [Read more 🡒]