An opposing coach doesn’t hand out praise like this by accident, especially not when the Giants are about to see the Eagles across the line of scrimmage.
Vic Fangio, Philadelphia’s defensive coordinator, called J.J. McCarthy a “steal” while talking about New York’s changes this season, according to NBC Sports.
It’s a strong label, and it comes from someone who has a clear view of what the Giants just added. Still, it’s only one rival’s read on the move, not a verdict on where McCarthy’s career is headed.
What makes the comment stand out is the price New York paid. The Giants landed McCarthy from Minnesota for a 2027 fifth-round pick after Jaxson Dart suffered a season-ending knee injury. That kind of deal gives a team a shot at a former first-round quarterback without paying the kind of premium that usually comes with chasing a long-term answer.
Of course, the trade only opens the door. What happens next depends on how the Giants set him up.
John Harbaugh and his staff can make life easier by leaning on a credible running game, giving McCarthy clean reads, and finding ways to move the pocket. Against Philadelphia, New York should be willing to take the available throws instead of asking him to force the issue into tight windows.
That doesn’t mean the Giants can go into full survival mode. If they get too conservative, the Eagles can crowd the line and make everything harder.
New York still needs to pick its spots and take selective shots when the protection and coverage line up. The other path is a more pass-heavy plan that puts McCarthy in position to win from the pocket over and over, and that brings more risk against pressure.
Fangio’s “steal” comment says the acquisition has already made noise outside the Giants’ building. It does not tell us how McCarthy will hold up over four quarters against a division opponent, and it certainly doesn’t settle what the team does once Dart is healthy.
For now, the task is straightforward: build around what McCarthy does well, see how Philadelphia responds, and find out how much offense he can actually carry.
In Other News...
Isaiah Likely Has A Big Eagles Opportunity While Giants Weigh A Change
Isaiah Likelys first outing with J.J. McCarthy under center for the Giants was a quiet one, as he caught two of four targets for 12 yards and didnt get into the end zone. Still, the setup for the next game looks more favorable. New York is favored against the Eagles, and Philadelphias defense has had trouble with slot receivers, which could give Likely a cleaner path to a bigger role if the passing game finds a rhythm.
The wrinkle is that the Giants are also looking at ways to reshape the offense, and that could affect how much they lean on Likely going forward. If the roster changes they are considering come together, the attack could look different in a hurry, leaving his usage in a less certain place even as this matchup offers a chance to build on a slow start. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Could Still Add The One Upgrade This 6-2 Start Demands
The Giants 6-2 start has them sitting atop the NFC East, and it has also put them squarely in the middle of trade-season chatter. ESPNs Jeremy Fowler and Dan Graziano have both connected New York to possible upgrades, with the front office believed to be at least exploring help at defensive tackle and running back as the November 10 deadline approaches.
One name that has surfaced in that conversation is Jonathan Taylor, a reminder that the Giants are not just protecting a good record but trying to see how far it can carry them. They have already checked on other targets and come away empty in some cases, which suggests the search is real, even if the exact move is still unclear. [Read more 🡒]
Theo Johnson Has A Giants Problem He Cant Ignore
The Giants have a tight end setup that already feels a little unusual, with Isaiah Likely being used mostly as a slot receiver while Theo Johnson handles the more traditional in-line role. For now, Johnson remains the player most tied to that job, but his uneven production and blocking issues have left the team with a question it cannot really ignore as it looks ahead.
Ryan Wilson of CBS Sports recently pointed to LSU tight end Trey'Dez Green as a possible future answer if Johnson does not take a clear step forward. Green brings the kind of size, speed and contested-catch ability that can make a passing game more dangerous, though he would still need to sharpen his run-blocking to fit what the Giants want from the position. [Read more 🡒]