The Vikings are 3-0, but Kevin O’Connell’s last 24 hours have hardly been smooth.
Minnesota shipped former 2024 10th overall pick J.J. McCarthy to the Giants on Monday in exchange for a 2027 fifth-round pick, closing the book on a bizarre run that never found steady ground. McCarthy tore up his knee as a rookie, came back to win NFC Offensive Player of the Week in his first start, then dealt with a string of injuries and never settled in as an NFL quarterback.
Now the focus shifts to O’Connell, because the trade doesn’t just end a failed experiment at quarterback. It also puts a sharper spotlight on how the Vikings got here in the first place.
O’Connell and general manager Nolan Teasley spoke to reporters Monday afternoon and both said they were disappointed the partnership never clicked, even if a fresh start made sense for everyone involved. But the conversation keeps circling back to O’Connell’s own words, especially a line from a 2024 appearance on the "Rich Eisen Show" that has trailed him through McCarthy’s uneven time in Minnesota:
“I just think, as a whole, there's not enough emphasis put on the organization's role in the development of the position, meaning I believe that organizations fail young quarterbacks before young quarterbacks fail organizations."
He later added: "I do believe there's some times where things just don't work out, and then getting a chance to kinda wipe the slate clean and get a restart while still using your previous experiences to kinda shape how you're gonna work…”
That idea came up again in Monday’s press conference, and O’Connell kept the same basic message. Still, the question hanging over the Vikings is whether this was really just a case of things not working out - or whether O’Connell deserves a bigger share of the blame.
The offense hasn’t helped his case. Minnesota is sitting at the bottom of the league in yards per game, with 238.3 total yards per game and a league-low 137 passing yards per game. The Vikings have already lost their starting quarterback early in the opener, and they also had to navigate a muddy, rainy game in Week 2, but the production has been rough enough that it won’t be sustainable for long.
Neither Kyler Murray nor Carson Wentz looks like the kind of quarterback who can lift the passing game to the level it reached under Sam Darnold or Kirk Cousins. The next three games - against the Dolphins, Colts and Saints - look like Minnesota’s best shot to get things moving before the schedule turns tougher in November.
McCarthy probably wouldn’t have solved all of that, either. But with the quarterback room already carrying health concerns and uneven play, losing another option doesn’t make life any easier.
What makes this more complicated is that O’Connell didn’t draft McCarthy in a vacuum. Former GM Kwesi Adofo-Mensah took most of the heat for his late January firing, but he wasn’t making the pick alone.
The Vikings were heavily linked to Drake Maye, and sources confirmed the team was very aggressive in trying to trade up for the former Tar Heel. When that didn’t happen, Minnesota moved from No. 11 to No. 10 and took McCarthy.
Adofo-Mensah didn’t force O’Connell into developing a quarterback he wanted nothing to do with, either. The two had built the plan together, and when Maye was off the board they pivoted. O’Connell even called McCarthy a franchise QB after his first preseason game, another line that resurfaced Monday:
“Wouldn’t change anything I said in the moment” - Kevin O’Connell on referring to J.J. McCarthy as a franchise QB after his first preseason game in 2024. pic.twitter.com/uEH7QTcwDy
One thing does seem clear: O’Connell wanted McCarthy to sit behind a veteran in 2025 after the rookie missed all of 2024 with the knee injury. That appears to have been the main point of tension between O’Connell and his former general manager, and in that regard, O’Connell may have had the right instinct.
Teasley now has the job of working with O’Connell to get the Vikings ready for 2026 while also trying to solve the long-term quarterback problem. With Murray struggling on a one-year deal, Wentz playing like the backup he is and McCarthy now in New York, the room doesn’t look especially encouraging.
For O’Connell, the next stretch matters. His future in Minnesota looks tied to whether the Vikings can find their franchise quarterback between now and next offseason.
In Other News...
Giants QB Plans Just Got Clearer After Jaxson Dart Injury Update
Jaxson Darts next step is now clear after the rookie quarterback underwent surgery on his left knee to repair damage to his meniscus, MCL and PCL following the injury he suffered against the Los Angeles Rams. The procedure went as expected and doctors found no additional problems, but the recovery clock is long enough to force the Giants to settle their quarterback picture without him for a while.
Jameis Winston is now lined up as the starter, while J.J. McCarthy has been brought in as the backup, giving New York a much firmer short-term plan under center. For Dart, the focus shifts entirely to rehabilitation over the next four to six months, with the organization left to manage the position and monitor how the rookies recovery unfolds. [Read more 🡒]
Giants May Have Found More Than A Returner In Charlie Jones
Charlie Jones decision to stay with the Giants after being cut by the Bengals gave New York a player who wanted a fresh start and a bigger role. Known mostly for his return work, Jones made clear he did not want to be viewed as only a specialist, and the Giants were willing to give him a chance to broaden his contribution while adding depth to a roster still sorting through injuries.
The immediate path is obvious enough, with Jones expected to help on kickoff returns, but the more interesting part is what comes next on offense. If he can carve out a real place as a receiver, the Giants could end up with more than a temporary fix in the return game, which is exactly the sort of bonus value teams are always trying to uncover this time of year. [Read more 🡒]
Former Giants Are Already Fueling A Painful Roster Debate
Week 3 brought a familiar sort of discomfort for Giants observers, with a handful of former players turning up around the league and reminding everyone how many roster decisions are still under scrutiny. Wan'Dale Robinson made the biggest splash of the group, leading the ex-Giants contingent with seven catches and a touchdown for Tennessee, while other familiar names like Daniel Bellinger, Austin Schlottmann, Dane Belton and Greg Van Roten logged snaps in roles that ranged from useful to merely present.
Cor'Dale Flott, Bobby Okereke and Rakeem Nunez-Roches were also in the mix, adding to the sense that this was more than a collection of passing reunions. It was a quiet but pointed snapshot of how much of the Giants' recent talent pool is still spreading across the league, and why every week seems to invite another round of second-guessing about what stayed in New York and what got away. [Read more 🡒]