Tyrone Tracy Jr. has gone from a player the Giants leaned on to one who suddenly has to answer for every mistake.
The latest one came Saturday against Miami. On second-and-4 from the Dolphins 10, Tracy lost the ball after slipping on the wet grass, and a Miami defender fell on it in the red zone. For the Giants, it was the second straight preseason game in which their 2024 leading rusher gave the coaching staff something to worry about.
That is a rough spot for any back, let alone one who topped 1,000 scrimmage yards in each of his first two seasons. But that is where Tracy appears to be with two weeks left before the roster is cut to 53. The room around him has gotten crowded, and his room for error has nearly disappeared.
Najee Harris changed the equation when he signed a one-year deal worth roughly $1.2 million after the preseason opener. He brought in a former Pro Bowl runner with four 1,000-yard seasons, and he joined a backfield that already had a clear hierarchy forming.
Cam Skattebo got the first handoff last Saturday and looks like the presumed lead back. Devin Singletary has made his case with a 40-yard screen against Minnesota and a strong camp. Harris, meanwhile, did not play against Miami while working his way back from a torn Achilles, but his connection to Greg Roman from their time together with the Chargers matters here too.
Even the depth behind those names has started to tell a story. Eric Gray had eight carries for 20 yards against the Vikings and did not do much to separate himself.
So if the Giants keep four running backs, the math gets tight fast. Skattebo looks safe.
Harris seems safe too. Singletary has pushed himself into the mix.
That leaves one spot for the player who was once viewed as the Giants’ RB1.
The problem is that Tracy’s two preseason games have brought back the same issues the staff already knows about.
In the opener, he missed a pass-protection assignment that left a free rusher to hit Jaxson Dart. A week later, he put the ball on the ground in the red zone.
Ball security was already part of the scouting report: Tracy fumbled five times as a rookie in 2024, once every 46 touches, before cutting that down to just one fumble in 2025. The Miami turnover reopened that concern in front of a new coaching staff that did not draft him.
That matters because the Giants need trust as much as production. A back who cannot keep Dart clean is going to lose third-down work to Skattebo and Singletary.
A back who cannot be trusted with the football near the goal line is going to lose short-yardage chances to Harris. Per NorthJersey’s Art Stapleton, those two mistakes have made it an open question whether Tracy ends up on the bubble or on the trade market.
And that is what makes this so strange. The tape still says Tracy is a starter.
As a rookie, he ran for 839 yards on 192 carries, added 38 receptions, and posted a 69.6 PFF rushing grade while leading the team in rushing. In 2025, he followed with 740 rushing yards and 288 receiving yards, then finished with a career-high 159 scrimmage yards against Dallas in Week 18. He has posted back-to-back seasons with more than 1,000 scrimmage yards and has run for more than four yards per carry in each of his first two seasons.
Season Rush Att Rush Yds Yards/Carry Scrimmage Yds Fumbles
2024 192 839 4.4 1,123 5
2025 176 740 4.2 1,028 1
There is also the receiving side of his profile. Tracy posted a 40.9 PFF receiving grade as a rookie even though he entered the league as a converted wideout, and that is part of the tension now. A passing-down back who is shaky in protection and loose with the football becomes easier to replace once Harris is healthy and Singletary is in the picture.
The Giants did not expect to be having this kind of conversation about Tracy. They may still decide he is too valuable to move on from. If they do, and if four backs plus Harris’s recovery timeline make the room too crowded, he is the kind of player who could bring real value in a trade rather than disappearing onto the waiver wire.
What he cannot do is give the staff another red-zone fumble or another missed blitz pickup before Friday’s preseason finale against the Jets. The talent has never been the issue. The next 10 days are.
In Other News...
Giants Suddenly Have Real Roster Pressure At Two Key Positions
The Giants have made plenty of noise in the preseason, finishing 3-0 and drawing a top ranking from Pro Football Focus, but the more useful takeaway for Brian Dabolls staff is what those games revealed about the edges of the roster. Preseason wins always come with an asterisk, yet the performances did help clarify where New York has real depth and where the competition is suddenly a lot tighter than it looked a few weeks ago.
The running back group and the defensive front both stood out as spots where recent play has forced some hard conversations ahead of final cuts. Players on both units made cases in live action, which is exactly what a team wants this time of year, but it also means the Giants may have more tough decisions than expected when they sit down to set the roster. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Suddenly Have A Darnell Mooney Problem They Can't Ignore
Darnell Mooneys absence last week was excused for a good reason, since the Giants receiver was on approved leave to serve as best man at his brothers wedding. Even so, it arrived at a time when the veteran had already had a quiet training camp, and that combination has only sharpened the scrutiny around where he stands as the team moves toward the start of the season.
Mooney was supposed to be part of a receiver group the Giants hoped could settle in quickly, but the recent roster churn has kept his spot from feeling settled at all. If the front office decides to keep exploring other options, or if Mooney ends up moving on, it could reshape the depth chart and leave Week 1 looking different than expected. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Face Tough Final Roster Calls After Crowded Preseason Battles
After the preseason win over the Dolphins, the Giants are heading into the part of August that can be more revealing than the games themselves. John Harbaugh and Joe Schoen now have to sort through a crowded roster and turn a long list of encouraging preseason performances into the league-mandated 53-man group, with the most crowded debates shaping up at running back, wide receiver, offensive line and cornerback.
Some spots look fairly clear, but plenty of players are still living on the edge of the bubble as the front office weighs who fits best and who has done enough to stick. Harbaugh has already pointed to several strong individual showings, yet the final calls are still pending, which leaves the Giants with more good problems than bad ones and a handful of tough decisions still ahead. [Read more 🡒]