Darius Alexander entered the summer with the kind of path that usually points straight to a breakout. Instead, two preseason games in, the Giants are staring at a much less comfortable possibility: their second-year defensive lineman may not be ready to fill the role they expected him to handle.
New York had already cleared the runway for Alexander after trading Dexter Lawrence to the Cincinnati Bengals earlier in the offseason, and the idea was simple enough. After finishing his rookie year on a strong note, the 26-year-old looked like the natural candidate to take the next step and become a bigger piece of the front.
That plan has hit a rough patch fast.
Alexander followed a poor preseason opener against the Minnesota Vikings with an even tougher showing against the Miami Dolphins in Preseason Game 2. With the regular season only 20 days away, the Giants no longer have the luxury of treating this as a minor blip. The concern now is whether they can afford to wait for him to settle in.
The Giants spent the 65th pick in the third round of the 2025 Draft on Alexander after a strong Senior Bowl and a reputation as the best defensive lineman in the MAC. At 6-foot-4 and 310 pounds, he came in with more buzz as a pass rusher than as a run defender, but the expectation was that his work against the run would come along as he adjusted to the speed and power of the NFL.
That part still hasn’t shown up.
As a rookie, Alexander had already struggled against the run, and the hope was that the offseason would help him clean that up and develop into a legitimate starter on John Harbaugh’s new-look defense. So far, he hasn’t delivered much reason for optimism.
Against Miami, Alexander posted a 39.7 overall grade from Pro Football Focus, including a 46.7 run-defense grade that ranked third-to-last on the team. His first preseason game wasn’t much better: he came away with a 43.8 run-defense grade against Minnesota, which finished fifth-to-last on the roster.
That kind of production makes the Giants’ internal conversation a lot harder.
It also comes at a time when New York has another asset it can use if it decides to chase help on the defensive front. The team recently sent offensive lineman Daniel Faalele to the Jacksonville Jaguars in exchange for a 2027 sixth-round pick, giving Joe Schoen and the front office a little more Day 3 capital to work with if they choose to make a move.
There’s still time for Alexander to change the story. Two preseason games don’t erase what he flashed as a rookie, and they don’t close the door on a second-year jump. But the version of the breakout that once looked inevitable now feels a lot less certain.
Alexander was supposed to make life after Dexter Lawrence easier. Right now, he’s giving the Giants reasons to wonder whether they need to find that help somewhere else.
In Other News...
Giants Suddenly Have A Darnell Mooney Problem They Can't Ignore
Darnell Mooneys absence for a recent game had a simple explanation, since he was on approved leave to serve as best man at his brothers wedding. Even so, the timing has only added to the uncertainty around a receiver who arrived with some optimism about his role but has not exactly forced the issue during a quiet training camp.
Around the Giants, every roster move now seems to carry a little extra weight because of what Mooneys situation might mean for the receiving corps heading into Week 1. If the team decides his future lies elsewhere, it would not just be a personnel change, but another shift in a room that still feels like it is sorting itself out. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Face Tough Final Roster Calls After Crowded Preseason Battles
Following the Giants preseason win over the Dolphins, the attention shifts from the final snap to the harder part of the job: trimming the roster to 53. There are still battles playing out across the depth chart, with questions at running back, wide receiver, offensive line and cornerback as the coaching staff and front office sort through a crowded group of players who have all flashed enough to make the conversation difficult.
John Harbaugh has already pointed to the way several players have performed, but the next step is where the real tension lies, because not every strong preseason showing can survive the numbers game. Joe Schoen now has to weigh upside, versatility and roster balance against limited spots, and with decisions still pending, a few players who looked safe only a week ago are suddenly waiting to see whether they are part of the opening-day plan. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Final Cut Battle Just Got Tougher After One Preseason Standout
The Giants final roster decisions are getting a little more complicated after their preseason showing against the Dolphins, because a few of the names fighting for fringe spots made a real case to stick around. The game film and Pro Football Focus grades pointed to one particularly encouraging offensive line performance from J.C. Davis, while wide receiver Dalen Cambre also turned in a strong outing that should have the staff paying closer attention as cutdown day approaches.
Elsewhere, the picture was less tidy, with some veterans and younger players not helping their chances as much as they needed to. Odell Beckham Jr. and Tyrone Tracy were among the players whose work in the game raised questions, and with final cuts looming, those uneven performances only sharpen the competition for the last available jobs. [Read more 🡒]