The Giants may be running out of patience with Tyler Nubin.
What looked like a promising fit when New York brought in a new defensive coordinator has turned into a shaky situation at safety, and the second-year defender could be staring at a benching even if his neck injury from the Week 5 tie against the Commanders doesn’t keep him out.
The Athletic’s Dan Duggan reported that Nubin’s grip on the starting job is already slipping. That matters because Jason Pinnock, who missed time after suffering a concussion in the Week 4 win over the Cardinals, was running on the sideline at practice late last week and appears on track to clear concussion protocol in time for Week 6. If that happens, he could reclaim a starting role whether Nubin is available or not.
"Health aside, Nubin’s hold on his starting job is tenuous," Duggan wrote. "He was benched for Jason Pinnock in the first half of the Week 4 win over the Cardinals and was replaced by Ar’Darius Washington for two series in the first half against the Commanders.
Pinnock suffered a concussion during the Cardinals game, but he was running on the sideline at practice late last week, so he appears on track to clear the concussion protocol this week. He may take over as the starter regardless of Nubin’s status."
That’s a rough turn for a player the Giants took in the second round of the 2024 NFL Draft and expected to develop into a key piece of the defense. They’ve tried to give him every opportunity, but the results haven’t matched the draft investment. Nubin was once viewed as the answer after Xavier McKinney, yet the job he was supposed to own is now under real threat.
His college calling card was playmaking. At Minnesota, Nubin had five interceptions in his final season.
That hasn’t carried over to the NFL, where he still hasn’t picked off a pass. Missed tackles have also been part of the issue, making this stretch look more and more like a player losing ground fast.
Pinnock brings his own familiarity to the picture. He spent three seasons with the Giants from 2022-2024, starting 37 games, before signing with the San Francisco 49ers in 2025. His return to New York in free agency was enough of a surprise on its own, and now he may be the one stepping in as the cleaner option.
Washington is in the mix too. He arrived this offseason after being coached by John Harbaugh and Wilson in Baltimore, and he already has experience in this system. Between Pinnock and Washington, the Giants have alternatives who know the defense and have already seen the field when Nubin hasn’t been able to hold the spot.
Nubin is listed as day-to-day and still has a chance to play Sunday. But that may not be the same thing as keeping his job. With Jevon Holland set on one side, the Giants could decide the safer move is simply putting the most qualified safety next to him - and that might not be Nubin anymore.
In Other News...
Giants Offense May Have Found A New Identity With Winston
The Giants spent much of a recent game looking like a different offense once Jameis Winston started throwing more often, with Malik Nabers and Isaiah Likely becoming central pieces of the attack. The shift gave New York a more aggressive feel and hinted at a group that may be more comfortable when the game is in Winstons hands and the ball is moving through the air instead of being managed conservatively.
Isaiah Likelys role has been especially notable, because his work as a pass catcher has already stood out among NFL tight ends and given the Giants another reliable option in key spots. Even the late-game decision to play for overtime rather than chase a two-point conversion fit into the broader conversation around how this offense wants to operate, and whether the Giants are settling into a new identity or just revealing one for the first time. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Face A Tough Trade Deadline Call While Leading The NFC East
The Giants have spent the first part of the 2026 season doing the one thing few outside the building expected them to do this early: sit at 3-1-1 and lead the NFC East while managing a string of key injuries. That sort of start usually pushes a team toward addition mode at the trade deadline, but it can also force hard internal decisions about which veterans and depth pieces still fit the long-term picture, especially with Nov. 10 approaching.
Theo Johnson and John Michael Schmitz are among the names being discussed as possible trade candidates if the Giants decide to balance present success against future roster needs. Johnsons role has thinned enough to make him part of the conversation, while Schmitz has seen his standing change after opening the year as the center, and both situations speak to how complicated this deadline could be for a team trying to stay in first place without losing sight of what comes next. [Read more 🡒]
Giants May Have Found A Needed Answer On The Offensive Line
The Giants were forced to make a quick adjustment along the offensive line in Week 5 against Washington, and Marcus Mbow was the one who stepped in at right tackle after Jermaine Eleumunor went down. It was the kind of spot duty that can expose a young lineman in a hurry, especially against NFL edge pressure, but Mbow handled the sudden promotion with enough poise to give New York something to think about moving forward.
Over 45 snaps, Mbow allowed two pressures and largely got the job done in pass protection, showing the sort of baseline stability the Giants have been searching for up front. The tape also left room for growth in his technique and footwork, which is why this doesnt read like a finished answer so much as a promising start, but for a line that has needed help, it was the kind of outing that can earn a longer look. [Read more 🡒]