J.J. McCarthy turned a fourth-quarter blowout into a real decision for the Giants.
Down 34-10 to the New Orleans Saints in Week 6 at MetLife Stadium, New York made the switch from Jameis Winston to McCarthy, the quarterback acquired in a trade with the Minnesota Vikings late last month. What followed was enough to put the team’s Week 7 plans in play before the final whistle had even cooled off.
McCarthy’s first real run as the Giants’ quarterback came with the game hanging by a thread, and he made it count. He finished 11 of 21 for 243 yards and a touchdown, added 26 rushing yards, and helped spark three scoring drives that sliced the lead to one touchdown. He even got one more crack at it late, guiding New York all the way to the red zone with a chance to tie or win before the comeback fell short.
Afterward, head coach John Harbaugh didn’t shut the door on a change for next week’s matchup with the Houston Texans.
“Did a heck of a job, given the circumstances and the desperation,” Harbaugh said postgame. “It’s different than normal football, but he made some plays, got us back, and gave us a chance at the end to win the game. We were throwing the ball in the end zone at the end, so that was good.”
Harbaugh also said he “can’t answer” who will start next week and made it clear he wasn’t ready to settle the question 10 minutes after the game ended.
Winston, who had won his first two starts as QB1, had a rough outing against the team he used to play for. He went 14 of 26 for 152 yards, a touchdown and two interceptions, and both giveaways quickly turned into Saints scoring drives.
Asked about the possibility of being benched, Winston kept the focus on what he can control.
“That’s the decision [Coach John Harbaugh] will have to make. What I would love is to put myself in a better position to execute, and it starts with me: things I can control, going out there every single play, and doing my very best,” Winston said.
McCarthy said his approach won’t change no matter where he lands on the depth chart for Week 7. He plans to get ready for Houston the same way he has been preparing all along.
“Just making sure that each and every week, even when I got here when we were playing Arizona, I went into the game with the mindset that I could play the whole game. Just being able to really put myself in that position, Monday through Saturday, is something that helped me out today,” McCarthy said in the locker room.
He said the bigger point was simply proving he can be trusted.
“I hope I just showed them that I do my job at a high enough level that they can trust me out there,” McCarthy wasn’t biting on whether or not he deserved to be the starting quarterback. “At the end of the day, we didn’t win the game. We’ve got to do things better, and I’ve got to do better, and figure out ways that we can close this thing out.”
In Other News...
Giants Backfield Suddenly Has A Bigger Problem After Ugly Fallout
The Giants backfield was already searching for answers after a rough showing against the Saints, and the conversation around the running game only grew louder when Najee Harris voiced frustration with how the carries were being divided. Head coach John Harbaugh said the ground game had not yet found a rhythm and stressed the need to maximize whatever chances came along, a reminder that the issue was about more than one player or one off day.
Now the problem has become even more unsettled, with Harris short stint in New York coming to an abrupt end after the fallout. The Giants lose a veteran option in a backfield that was already under pressure, and the larger question is how they sort through the rotation from here without the player who had been part of the discussion just days ago. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Suddenly Have A Real Shot At Fixing Their Backfield
The Giants running back room has been one of the seasons softer spots, and as the trade deadline creeps closer, it is hard not to wonder whether help could be available. One of the more intriguing names in play is Jonathan Taylor, a productive runner whose situation in Indianapolis has suddenly become worth monitoring from a New York perspective.
The opening may be tied to the Colts direction, which is in flux as the deadline nears. Taylors contract situation only adds to the appeal for any team looking beyond a short-term fix, but for now there is still no confirmed trade and no clear sign of how far the Giants might be willing to go to stabilize a position that has been dragging them down. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Fans Already See An Evan Neal Debate Forming Up Front
The early returns on Francis Mauigoa have already sparked a familiar kind of Giants conversation up front. The rookie, taken 10th overall in 2026, has spent his first six weeks adjusting to right guard after lining up at right tackle in college, and the transition has come with the usual growing pains on an offensive line that has also been dealing with injuries and uneven play around him.
Even with those context points, the numbers have given critics plenty to point to, and the reaction online has been split between concern and caution. Some fans see a young lineman learning on the fly, while others are pushing back on the harsher takes and warning against turning Mauigoa into the next Evan Neal debate before his first NFL season has really had time to settle in. [Read more 🡒]