The Giants’ ground game has gone from a strength to a headache, and there isn’t one clean place to pin the blame.
New York was one of the NFL’s more efficient rushing teams in 2025. Now, in 2026, it sits among the least efficient. That drop-off is jarring, especially when the backfield looks mostly familiar outside of the few weeks with Najee Harris.
Cam Skattebo and Tyrone Tracy Jr., who is currently on IR, have been the top two backs, with Devin Singletary working in behind them. On paper, that’s enough to at least keep the run game afloat.
In reality, it has gone nowhere. The Giants are averaging just 3.9 yards per carry, and the lack of a true feature back has made life harder for J.J.
McCarthy and the offense as a whole.
That’s a rough fit for a team that brought in John Harbaugh with the idea of building a physical offense that could control the trenches and run the ball like his Baltimore teams did. That vision has not shown up on the field. The Giants even came up empty at the trade deadline when they failed to land a marquee running back, but the problems in the run game run deeper than one missed move.
The coaching setup hasn’t solved it either. Matt Nagy has never been known for his run-game design, so the Giants added Greg Roman, a longtime colleague and supposed run-game specialist, to help. Even that hasn’t changed much, and the offense has not made things easier on the backs since Jaxson Dart went down in Week 2.
The line has also been part of the problem. Pro Football Focus has the Giants’ run-blocking grade at 49.6, which ranks third-worst in the league at 30th. Only the Titans and Packers are worse, and that lines up with a unit that has Andrew Thomas as its only above-average starter up front.
Harbaugh also has to wear some of this. He didn’t get aggressive enough in the offseason or at the deadline to strengthen the room, and trying to power through with an injury-prone backfield was always a risky bet.
And while Skattebo and Tracy have had their own issues, neither one profiles as a true feature back. They fit better as committee pieces, not as the kind of runner who can carry the offense on his own. That’s why Jonathan Taylor would’ve been such a clean fit.
For now, the Giants’ run game is a mess, and the blame belongs to the whole operation.
In Other News...
Giants Regret Talk Is Growing Around A Pick They Couldnt Afford To Miss
The Giants went into the 2026 NFL Draft needing impact players, and their choice at No. 36 was supposed to help stabilize the back end of the defense. Instead, Colton Hoods rookie season has gotten off to a rough start, with limited defensive snaps and a string of completions and touchdowns allowed that have already put his early development under a microscope.
What makes the conversation sting even more is what happened right after New York made its pick. Cleveland grabbed wide receiver Denzel Boston shortly after Hood came off the board, and Boston has opened his rookie year with one of the better starts among first-year receivers in the league. For a Giants team that could not afford to miss in that spot, the comparison is hard to ignore, and it is only going to get louder if Hood does not turn things around soon. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Suddenly Need A Backup Plan For Isaiah Likely
Isaiah Likely was held out of practice because of a minor groin injury, a development that is not expected to keep him out of the upcoming game against Jacksonville. Even so, it has nudged the Giants into thinking through a backup plan at tight end, especially if Likely is available but not quite as mobile as usual. The immediate options on hand are Theo Johnson, Chris Manhertz and Thomas Fidone II, giving the staff some flexibility if it needs to redistribute the workload.
Head coach John Harbaugh did not confirm any changes to the depth chart or lineup, which leaves the situation in a holding pattern for now. Still, for a team that values what Likely brings to the offense, even a minor injury can force a closer look at how the position is managed from snap to snap. The Giants will keep monitoring him, but the real question is how much they can ask of him if he suits up. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Are Already Zeroing In On Three Positions For Next Spring
The Giants are already doing the kind of early draft homework that can shape a spring board long before the college season is over, and three names have started to stand out for different reasons. Carlos Hernandez at Wake Forest has drawn attention as a receiver, Wayne Knight at UCLA has been productive out of the backfield, and Vicari Swain at South Carolina has made his mark as a cornerback with special teams value, giving New York a look at three different ways to address future roster needs.
What makes the group interesting is how each player fits a different lane for the Giants. Hernandez brings the kind of receiving ability that can help a passing game, Knight offers a running back profile that could add another dimension to the offense, and Swains coverage work plus special teams contributions give him a broader appeal for a team that always has to squeeze value out of the bottom of the roster. The next step is seeing how each one holds up as the season goes on, because the Giants are clearly watching closely. [Read more 🡒]
