Jaxson Dart has been turning heads this season - and not just for his playmaking ability. The Giants’ rookie quarterback has shown a fearless, almost defiant approach to running the football, racking up 400 yards on the ground, good for fourth among all NFL quarterbacks. But while that kind of mobility can be a game-changer, it’s also raising serious questions about his long-term durability and decision-making - especially when it comes to protecting himself.
Dart was evaluated for a concussion during the Giants' recent loss to the Commanders - the fifth time he’s been checked for a head injury this season. While he’s only been officially diagnosed once, the frequency of these evaluations is enough to raise eyebrows.
Dart, for his part, has brushed off the concern, suggesting that there’s a certain “sensitivity” around how officials and teams react when he takes a hit. But that explanation isn’t easing the concerns of analysts or, potentially, future coaches.
On ESPN’s Get Up, Domonique Foxworth didn’t mince words about how Dart’s playing style could complicate the Giants' coaching search this offseason. “If I’m a head coach, I’m reluctant to have my career tied to the decision-making of that man,” Foxworth said.
“It’s the responses that are more concerning.” And you can see where he’s coming from.
It’s not just about the hits Dart is taking - it’s about how he’s responding to them. There’s a fine line between toughness and recklessness, and right now, Dart is toeing it.
Stephen A. Smith echoed the sentiment on First Take, praising Dart’s talent and toughness but emphasizing the need for maturity.
“You are a rookie and you have already been in concussion protocol five times,” Smith said. “Come on, man.
You have to have a heightened level of sensitivity.” Smith’s point wasn’t just about Dart’s health - it was about his responsibility to the team.
The Giants need their quarterback on the field, not in the blue tent.
Let’s be clear: Dart’s athleticism is one of the most exciting elements of the Giants’ offense right now. His ability to extend plays and create with his legs gives New York a dynamic edge that they haven’t had in years. But the refusal to slide, step out of bounds, or otherwise avoid contact is a dangerous habit - and one that could shorten his season, or worse, his career.
This isn’t about asking Dart to change who he is as a player. It’s about evolving - about learning when to take the hit and when to live to fight another down.
The best dual-threat quarterbacks - think Lamar Jackson, Jalen Hurts, even Josh Allen in his more recent seasons - have all had to learn that balance. Dart’s got the tools.
The question is whether he’ll adapt before the hits start to take a lasting toll.
The Giants believe they’ve found their quarterback of the future. Now it’s on Dart to protect that future - not just for himself, but for a franchise that’s banking on his growth.