The Giants’ offensive line is drawing a wide range of opinions before the 2026 season even gets rolling, and the middle ground is where things land for now. In Football Insights’ preseason consensus rankings, New York checks in at No. 19, a spot that puts the group just below average and between the Patriots and the Ravens.
That number is interesting because there are reasons to believe the line should be better than that. Last season, the Giants were no longer one of the league’s punching bags up front.
Pro Football Focus had them 10th in pass blocking and 19th in run blocking, and both tackles are back. The interior, though, was only so-so, which is why the Giants used the No. 10 pick on Sisi Mauigoa, expected to step in at right guard.
Mauigoa has apparently held that job all through camp. According to Ed’s reporting from the Greenbriar:
Mauigoa has taken every snap of training camp as the starting right guard. It has certainly looked to the naked eye as though Mauigoa has been meeting or exceeding the bar Harbaugh has set.
He also looked fine in his first preseason game, which is why the No. 19 consensus slot feels a little conservative. But the individual rankings show just how split the view of this line really is.
FTN has the Giants all the way up at No. 10.
Dan Fornek’s assessment leans heavily on Andrew Thomas, who played 13 games in 2025 and gave up just one sack on a 2.9% pressure rate across 448 dropbacks. FTN also notes that New York returns four starters from a solid group and adds Mauigoa, whom the site views as one of the best offensive line prospects in the 2026 draft class.
Fornek also points to the rest of the room:
New York also has three experienced interior offensive linemen (Aaron Stinnie, Daniel Faalele and Lucas Patrick) with developmental tackle prospects (Marcus Mbow and J.C. Davis) waiting in the wings at tackle.
The Giants were a very good unit when Andrew Thomas was healthy in 2025. They enter 2026 as a top 10 group now that they addressed arguably their biggest hole with one of the best offensive line prospects in the 2026 draft class.
At the other end, Fantasy Points has the Giants at No. 29, a far gloomier read on the same roster. Their full rankings are behind a paywall, but the takeaway is obvious enough: some evaluators see a line that could hold up, while others are far less convinced.
The spread around the league is just as wild in other places. Carolina is the clearest example, with one analyst slotting the Panthers at No. 3 and another at No.
- Same team, wildly different conclusions.
For the Giants, the bigger question is how this all shapes the 2026 schedule. If the defense is going to make its mark through the pass rush, the quality of opposing offensive lines will matter a lot.
The good news is that New York won’t run into too many elite fronts. The bad news is that the schedule does include some tough ones.
Philadelphia, ranked No. 2, is the obvious headache, especially for an NFC East opponent. The Rams come next in Week 2 at No. 6, though the various analysts don’t all see Los Angeles the same way.
PFF and Brandon Thorn are less impressed than the others, but the Rams still present a serious challenge. Matthew Stafford posted a 95.8 PFF passing grade in 2025 when kept clean, but only a 68.4 mark when pressured.
That’s the split that defines that matchup.
The Giants will also see the three worst offensive lines in the consensus rankings, which could create some opportunities for the pass rush. Houston is first on that list, and while the Texans’ defense will make life hard on the Giants’ offense, C.J. Stroud’s numbers show how much pressure matters: he graded 81.4 when kept clean and 49.0 under pressure.
Tennessee in Week 3 is another favorable spot from that angle. Cam Ward posted a 70.0 grade when kept clean and a brutal 34.7 when pressured. Cleveland rounds out the trio, and while the starter there is still unclear between Deshaun Watson and Shedeur Sanders, both have shown a much bigger drop-off under pressure in their most recent season of play.
The two games against Washington are worth watching closely too. ESPN’s Mike Clay is the high man on the Commanders’ line, ranking it No. 17, but PFF has a much harsher view and puts it last in the league. That drop is tied to the injury to left tackle Laremy Tunsil:
Before the injury to left tackle Laremy Tunsil, this was a group set to rank just inside the top 20, but the loss of Tunsil for a significant amount of time is a huge blow to the group. There will be an expectation of some improvement from Josh Conerly Jr., and his 59.9 PFF grade in 2025 was fine for a rookie, but this is a unit that could really struggle if Tunsil misses the full season.
So the Giants’ line sits in an awkward but workable place: good enough to believe in, uncertain enough to debate, and important enough to shape the way their pass rush and offense are judged all season long.
In Other News...
Giants Move On From Veteran Starter As O-Line Youth Push Continues
The Giants youth movement along the offensive line has now sent another veteran out the door, with Greg Van Roten landing a one-year deal with the Patriots. Van Roten, 36, had been a starter in New York and has spent time with multiple NFL teams, making him a familiar kind of stopgap addition for a club looking for experienced help.
For the Giants, the move fits a broader push to get younger up front and keep building around players who can grow together. For Van Roten, it means another chance to carve out a role, and New England appears to see him as a versatile piece who can help at both guard and center while adding depth to a group that always seems to need it. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Backfield Just Got More Crowded For A Veteran Runner
The Giants have added another name to an already busy backfield, bringing in veteran running back Najee Harris to give the offense more depth at a position that already features Cam Skattebo, Tyrone Tracy Jr., Devin Singletary and Eric Gray. Harris arrives with plenty of NFL experience and a Pro Bowl nod from his time with the Steelers, giving New York another proven option as it sorts out how the carries will be distributed.
For a team looking to sort through a crowded running back room, the move adds both depth and a little more intrigue. Harris gives the Giants a different body type and rsum to mix into the rotation, and it also leaves the backfield picture looking a bit less settled than it was before the signing. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Just Sent A Clear Message About Their Receiver Battle
JuJu Smith-Schusters brief run with the Giants ended just as quickly as it began, a sign that the teams receiver competition is still very much in flux. Signed on June 1, Smith-Schuster never made much of an imprint during offseason work and was inactive in a recent game, while Braxton Berrios and Odell Beckham Jr. remain in the mix and are expected to be available for the next one.
The move also comes with a notable roster wrinkle, since the Giants filled the spot by adding running back Najee Harris. Even with Berrios and Beckham still on hand, the decision to move on from Smith-Schuster suggests the Giants are continuing to sort out which pass-catchers fit the plan best as they head into the upcoming game. [Read more 🡒]