WHITE SULPHUR SPRINGS, W.Va. - The Giants’ first padded practice brought the kind of mess that makes coaches sigh and defenders grin. Rain kept coming.
Flags kept flying. And Jaxson Dart and the offense looked every bit as rough as the wet ground at the Greenbrier Sports Performance Center.
If there was one player who turned the day into a defensive showcase, it was rookie linebacker Arvell Reese. He was all over the field, stacking up run stops, blowing up a throw to the left sideline meant for Tyrone Tracy Jr. and finishing the day with a third-down sack of Dart in the final period.
“He has a real chance to be special,” veteran defensive tackle DJ Reader said of Reese, the No. 5 overall pick in April’s NFL Draft. “You don’t really get a chance to see kids that size move around how he does at every different position, run around. He’s smart, stays quiet and really tries to learn.”
Reese’s range showed up in more than one way. He got involved in stopping the run, handled Tracy in man coverage on the outside and kept showing that burst that makes him look like more than a normal rookie linebacker. Tracy’s own description was simple: Reese is a “see ball, get ball” player.
John Harbaugh liked what he saw too.
“Very encouraged,” Harbaugh said of Reese. “I think he looked good today from what I could see.
I can’t wait to see the tape, but he’s playing really well. He’s been playing well the whole camp since he got here.”
The defense had plenty of other bright spots, especially against the run. That said, Cam Skattebo did break loose for one big gain off the left side inside Abdul Carter.
The bigger problem for the Giants was on the other side of the ball. Jermaine Eluemunor didn’t sugarcoat it.
“We need to do a better job on offense, truly starting quicker and then finishing better,” the right tackle said. “I think that would be the emphasis [Tuesday]: starting quicker.”
The sloppiness showed up in the penalty count, too. The Giants were flagged 14 times in a practice that included about 70 plays of 11-on-11, with nine penalties on offense and five on defense. Chris Manhertz and rookie corner Colton Hood each had two.
The opening stretch for the first-team offense told the story fast: two runs for negative total yards, a false start on Darius Slayton, a completion to Calvin Austin and then the breakup by Reese on the throw to Tracy.
Things didn’t get cleaner when the second units took over. Four straight plays brought four penalties - a false start by Dante Miller, a defensive offsides, a false start by Xavier Gipson and a delay of game on the offense.
Harbaugh tried to keep the reaction measured, pointing to the weather and the first day in pads.
“I think two things,” Harbaugh said. “I think you’ve got the elements a little bit and you’ve got the first day in pads. So it’s not really unexpected, but we’ll be working on it.”
Eluemunor said Harbaugh’s style makes the corrections impossible to miss.
“Obviously we’re going to see them all. He’s going to call everyone out in front of the team,” Eluemunor said. “But also you just got to know that you got to be better… You got to take your licks and then come back out tomorrow and be better.”
Even the defense had to pay for the day. Reader said coordinator Dennard Wilson has the unit do 10 push-ups for every penalty, and the defense wound up with 40 after practice.
“We had 40, so it was a tough first day on the push-ups,” he said.
There were still other notable moments sprinkled through the work. Jameis Winston was picked off by Micah McFadden in 11-on-11 after a tipped pass by Deonte Banks, and Dart was intercepted by safety Jevon Holland in 7-on-7. Banks almost had another takeaway on Winston in the final situational period, but the ball bounced off his hands near the goal line.
Dart also had a strange rep on a quarterback run to the right, lowering his shoulder and making contact with defenders. Paulson Adebo was one of the defenders who raised his hands, signaling the contact was unintentional or at least not something the defense had planned for.
In 7-on-7, rookie Malachi Fields hauled in a deep catch from Dart after getting behind Adebo, and Dalen Cambre snagged a bouncing pass after Korie Black got in the way. Hood left briefly after colliding with Miller on a screen pass, appeared to be dealing with a stinger and then returned later in practice.
Tuesday’s assignment is obvious: clean it up, cut the mistakes and get the offense moving forward. The defense has already shown it can create problems. Now the Giants need the other side of the ball to start answering back.
In Other News...
Darius Slaytons 2025 Suddenly Looks Different After New Giants Update
Darius Slaytons offseason took a sharp turn once the full scope of his nagging issue came into view. After dealing with a sports hernia through 2025, the veteran wideout tried to work his way back through rehab, but eventually needed surgery on both sides, a reminder of how much he was managing while trying to stay available for the Giants last season.
Now entering the second year of his three-year extension, Slayton is trying to reset in a receiver room that looks more crowded than it did a year ago. Giants coach John Harbaugh said Slayton is regaining strength and is expected to play a significant role, but the bigger question is how quickly he can get back to his usual level after an injury that clearly altered the path of his offseason. [Read more 🡒]
John Harbaugh Is Testing Giants Veterans And Jaxson Dart Early
Training camp has a way of exposing what a roster really is, and John Harbaugh is making sure the Giants feel that from the start. Around the building, the message has been about accountability, with players like Cam Skattebo and Darius Slayton acknowledging a coach who is quick to hold people responsible for their effort and their actions. It is the kind of early-camp tone that can sharpen a team fast, especially when the standard is being set publicly and without much wiggle room.
Harbaugh has not limited that approach to younger players either, which makes the situation even more interesting for a Giants group trying to sort out its hierarchy. Veterans have been in the mix, and so has Jaxson Dart, as the coach has reinforced expectations on and off the field. For a team still trying to define itself, the question is not whether Harbaugh is sending a message. It is how the veterans and the rookie quarterback respond once the real pressure starts to build. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Camp Buzz Is Raising One Early Concern And Two Big Hopes
Training camp is always where optimism gets sharpened by reality, and for the Giants, the early buzz has already started to sort out into a few familiar categories. Abdul Carter has looked like the kind of edge presence the defense can build around, winning reps and flashing the pass-rushing talent that made him such a key part of this summers hope. On the other side of the ball, rookie wide receiver Malachi Fields has also drawn attention in practice, earning meaningful first-team work and looking like someone who may not take long to matter.
The more delicate storyline, of course, is the quarterback room, where Jaxson Dart is still working through the demands of a new offense and the learning curve has been visible in camp. Early reports have pointed to issues with processing and timing, the kind of details that can look small in July but become much bigger once the games start counting. For a Giants team trying to find upward momentum, the first few weeks of camp are already offering both reassurance and one early reminder that development rarely moves in a straight line. [Read more 🡒]