The Giants did not bring in J.J. McCarthy to start a quarterback debate. They brought him in to give their offense another gear, and after five snaps against Washington, the plan is already getting bigger.
John Harbaugh said four days after that debut that he wants to see more of McCarthy’s package, not less. The rookie-turned-veteran of sorts got only five chances in the Oct. 11 game, but the design told the story: movement, quick decisions, and enough edge stress to make Washington react. The box score barely showed it because Giants penalties wiped out the only two completions McCarthy placed on tape.
McCarthy’s first series in a Giants uniform came in the second half against the Commanders. He opened with a short throw to Darnell Mooney that was erased by a Washington penalty, kept the ball on two option runs for a combined two yards, and handed off to Tyrone Tracy on another option look.
Then came a 14-yard completion to Malik Nabers that disappeared because of an illegal-shift flag. The staff clearly saw something it liked anyway.
“I just feel alive again,” McCarthy said afterward, per Yahoo Sports.
Harbaugh was just as direct about what comes next. When asked whether that package could grow, he said, “I do, and I think we’ll grow” via NBC Sports and ESPN’s Jordan Raanan. He also admitted the Giants have “got to clean some of that stuff up” after the pre-snap mistakes spoiled the two completions.
That patience makes sense because the Giants are in a strange but useful place. They’re 3-1-1, sitting alone atop the NFC East, with Jameis Winston driving the offense and Jaxson Dart out for the regular season after knee surgery. McCarthy, the former No. 10 overall pick Minnesota moved on from in September, has become the most intriguing piece on the board.
New York paid only a 2027 fifth-round pick for him on Sept. 28, a steep discount for a quarterback the Vikings drafted 10th overall in 2024. The price reflects the arc of his career to this point: a torn meniscus in his right knee after the 2024 preseason opener, then the distinction of becoming the first first-round quarterback to miss his entire rookie season because of injury.
McCarthy did get one extended run with Minnesota in 2025, and the numbers were uneven. In 10 starts, he went 6-4 with 57.6% completions, 1,632 yards, 11 touchdowns, 12 interceptions, and a 72.6 passer rating.
What the Giants bought, though, was not a finished answer. It was a former top-10 pick still on his rookie contract, a low-cost swing with enough pedigree to matter without threatening Winston’s role. The staff made that crystal clear when it named Winston QB1 on the day the trade was announced.
And Winston has given them no reason to hurry. He has 805 passing yards, six touchdowns, and three interceptions across his appearances, including an 18-of-29, 250-yard, three-touchdown game in the Week 4 win over Arizona and a 33-of-54, 326-yard, three-touchdown outing in the Week 5 tie at Washington.
Jameis Winston, 2026 Comp/Att Yards TD INT
Wk 2 at Rams (relief) 11/27 111 0 1
Wk 3 vs Titans 14/22 118 0 0
Wk 4 vs Cardinals 18/29 250 3 2
Wk 5 at Commanders 33/54 326 3 0
The risk with Winston has always been baked in. His aggressiveness has fueled the offense, but it has also come with turnovers, including a lost fumble in the Washington tie.
That is exactly why the McCarthy package matters. It gives Matt Nagy a changeup and an insurance policy without handing the whole operation over to the former No. 10 pick.
Behind Winston and McCarthy, the Giants have only Jake Haener. That makes McCarthy’s development a real part of the season, especially with Winston’s Week 6 reunion with the Saints looming.
The biggest takeaway from five snaps is simple: the Giants already like what they see. They traded for McCarthy as a reclamation project, and now, five weeks later, they’re building live offense around him while sitting in first place. If the penalties get cleaned up, that package stops being a one-game novelty and turns into something opponents have to study every week.
In Other News...
Cam Skattebo's Explanation Puts Giants Fans On Notice Again
Cam Skattebo spent part of his latest conversation answering for a moment that stood out in a wet, muddy game and reminded Giants fans why he has become such a talking point so quickly. The rookie running back explained why he went without gloves late, a decision he believed would help him handle the conditions better, and he tied it to the kind of aggressive, no-nonsense style that has made him intriguing early in his time in New York.
The result, though, is what hangs over the explanation now. Skattebo acknowledged the fumble and made clear that ball security has to be front and center as he moves forward, even as he pushed back on doubts about whether he can grow into a lead-back role. For the Giants, the appeal is obvious, but so is the margin for error, and how he responds next will say plenty about where this run-first plan can go from here. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Offseason Overhaul Is Already Changing Everything That Hurt Them
The Giants spent the offseason trying to undo what went wrong, and the early returns show just how much change they embraced. A new head coach, 10 new starters and a fresh mix of personnel have given the roster a different feel on all three phases, with several newcomers already helping shape the teams identity. Tremaine Edmunds, D.J. Reader and Jordan Stout have each found meaningful roles, while Isaiah Likely has quickly become part of the conversation in an offense that needed more reliable answers.
Likelys presence has been especially notable because the Giants were looking for someone who could help the passing game feel less one-dimensional around Malik Nabers. On special teams, Stout has also added value in a way that doesnt always show up in the spotlight, giving New York stability in a spot that can quietly swing field position. The broader question now is whether these early gains are the start of something sustainable, or simply the first signs of a roster still trying to catch up to the standard it wants to set. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Need Malachi Fields To Answer A Growing Passing Game Concern
The Giants spent the offseason trying to deepen their receiving room, but attrition has thinned that plan quickly. Several of the added pass catchers have already disappeared from the roster because of releases and injuries, leaving Darnell Mooney and rookie Malachi Fields as the main newcomers still standing. Fields flashed enough in the preseason to suggest he could help, and the passing game has otherwise leaned heavily on Malik Nabers and Isaiah Likely to carry the load.
Fields is now facing a different kind of test. His early regular-season role has been modest, and the Giants are approaching a stretch in which they may need more than the same familiar targets to keep the offense balanced. With tougher defenses ahead, including a pair of elite secondaries, the margin for a quiet stretch from Fields is getting smaller by the week. [Read more 🡒]