The Giants have only two games of tape to sort through, but that’s enough to start checking the draft-night “what if” file.
After New York’s 28-6 loss to the Los Angeles Rams on Monday night, there’s still plenty to like about rookies Arvell Reese and Francis “Sisi” Mauigoa, the two top-10 picks the Giants made in the 2026 Draft. Reese has looked solid at off-ball linebacker, while Mauigoa has flashed the kind of road-grading promise the Giants were after. Reese did leave Monday’s game for a stretch with an apparent injury, and Mauigoa ran into a Rams front seven that made life miserable all night.
That’s the backdrop for a running regret watch on the players New York could have taken instead - or the ones they were linked to - as the season opens. The list is still fluid, and with just two games to go on, there’s no rush to stamp anyone with a regret label.
For now, the closest thing to a verdict is simple: nobody has truly forced the Giants to flinch yet.
Jordyn Tyson, the Saints wide receiver, falls firmly into that bucket. He was the kind of player who made sense next to Malik Nabers during the draft process, but he’s on short-term injured reserve with a hamstring issue and will miss at least the first four games. Hard to regret not taking a player who hasn’t even been on the field.
Carnell Tate, now with the Titans, is in a different lane. He went fourth overall, so the Giants didn’t have much of a choice there, but he was still viewed as one of the top three players in their range if Reese hadn’t been there.
Tate’s start has been quiet: seven catches on 11 targets for 65 yards and no touchdowns. Tennessee’s offense has struggled under Brian Daboll, and he’ll get a shot at his former team next week when the Titans visit MetLife Stadium for a Week 3, 1:00 p.m.
ET kickoff.
Mansoor Delane, the Chiefs cornerback, was a favorite of the regret-watch train before the draft. He looked like an easy fit for a Giants secondary that was already unsettled, but right now there’s not much to second-guess.
Delane is dealing with a lingering shoulder injury from Week 1, dressed in Week 2 against the Indianapolis Colts, and did not play a snap. He went right after Reese at No. 6, after New York passed on him at five.
Jeremiyah Love, the Cardinals running back, was another player who would have made sense for a team that likes to lean on backs. Arizona took him third overall, and while the Cardinals have used a committee approach, Love’s first two games have been ordinary: 20 carries for 70 yards, a 3.5-yard average, and one touchdown, plus five catches for 25 yards on seven targets. There’s still time, but the early returns haven’t matched the hype.
Sonny Styles, now with the Commanders, is the one who makes you raise an eyebrow. The Giants chose Reese over Styles at five, and Styles has opened his career with seven tackles, one sack and two tackles for loss.
His 45.2 run-defense grade from Pro Football Focus ranks 64th out of 69, which is not exactly a number that calms anybody down. It’s still early, though, and the NFL game can take some getting used to.
Spencer Fano is the first player on the list who could eventually become a real sting. The Browns took the tackle ninth, just before the Giants were on the clock again, and he’s already coming off his best game as a pro.
His 79.1 pass-blocking grade from Pro Football Focus points to a player trending in the right direction. Still, with Andrew Thomas and Jermaine Eluemunor already locked in at tackle, this one may not hit as hard for New York as it would have if the need had been greater.
Then there’s Caleb Downs, the Cowboys safety and the only player New York passed on twice. That alone makes him the most obvious name to track.
He was widely seen as the best defensive prospect in the class, and he has made his presence felt early, forcing a fumble in each of his first two games. He’s already looking like a defensive cornerstone for Dallas, but there isn’t enough there yet to send Giants fans into full panic mode.
For the record, he’s 0-1 all time against New York.
As for the dreaded regret category? Empty for now.
One rough night against the Rams doesn’t change that. Check back next week.
In Other News...
Eli Manning's Reaction Said Everything About The Giants' Jaxson Dart Worry
A replay on ESPNs ManningCast drew a familiar face back into the conversation Monday night when Eli Manning reacted with clear concern to Jaxson Darts knee injury. The former Ole Miss quarterback, now with the Giants, was hurt in a moment that immediately shifted attention from the game itself to what comes next for a team already trying to sort out its quarterback plans.
Dart is expected to miss 2-4 weeks, and Jameis Winston stepped in after the injury, finishing 11 of 27 for 111 yards with one interception. For New York, the timing is the issue as much as the injury, with the Giants and head coach John Harbaugh now needing to map out the next stretch while waiting to see how Dart responds. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Fans Immediately Had One Big Fear After Jaxson Dart Went Down
Jaxson Darts night took an early turn at SoFi Stadium when the Giants quarterback went down with a knee injury on the opening offensive drive of Monday Night Football. Dart was hit as he let a pass go, then limped off the field before being listed as questionable to return, putting a quick jolt into a game that had barely started.
Jameis Winston stepped in at quarterback, but for Giants fans the larger concern was immediate: any setback to Dart carries obvious weight for a team trying to find stability under center. Even before the training staff had much time to sort out the injury, the attention around the sideline had already shifted from the drive itself to what comes next for a young quarterback the Giants can least afford to lose for long. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Suddenly Face A Bigger Jaxson Dart Concern Than This Game
Jaxson Darts early exit against the Rams quickly became the biggest storyline of the Giants Week 2 afternoon. The rookie quarterback went down with a knee injury in the first quarter, then was officially listed as questionable to return after leaving the field under his own power and heading to the medical tent.
Jameis Winston took over at quarterback, but the larger concern for New York is what Darts knee issue could mean beyond this one game. Anytime a young passer has to come off the field that early, the immediate result matters less than the next check on his health, and the Giants are left waiting for a clearer picture. [Read more 🡒]