When the Giants made the bold move to trade up for Deonte Banks in the 2023 NFL Draft, they envisioned a cornerstone cornerback. Fast forward to the present, and the narrative has shifted dramatically under the new leadership of John Harbaugh.
Banks has struggled to find his footing as a cornerback, finishing the 2025 season ranked 112th out of 114 qualifiers, according to PFF. With a coverage grade of 45.0 and allowing a passer rating of 136.3, his time as a starting corner seems to be dwindling.
However, in a season marked by defensive struggles, Banks has carved out a surprising new role. Despite his challenges in coverage, he emerged as a Second-Team All-Pro vote-getter on special teams, hinting at untapped potential.
Deonte Banks: A Rising Star in Special Teams
The unexpected twist of 2025 was Banks' evolution into a formidable kick-return specialist. After being benched for his defensive lapses, special teams coordinator Michael Ghobrial tapped into Banks' elite 9.99 RAS athleticism.
The outcome was impressive: Banks recorded 19 returns for 622 yards, averaging a remarkable 32.7 yards per return. His standout moment came in Week 17 against the Raiders with a thrilling 95-yard kickoff return touchdown.
For the Giants, who have long sought an explosive returner, Banks’ blazing speed offers a fresh opportunity to redefine his career and shed the “bust” label.
Banks’ Future with the Giants
The internal debate now centers on whether Banks can be revitalized under new defensive coordinator Dennard Wilson. Criticized for his effort and run defense, Banks didn’t thrive in Shane Bowen’s previous scheme, which hindered many defensive backs.
With a looming $11.9 million fifth-year option decision, the Giants face a pivotal choice. Although unlikely to have his option picked up, Banks has the chance to rebound defensively while excelling in his special teams role, potentially earning a contract extension heading into the 2027 offseason.
If Wilson can’t harness Banks’ athletic prowess in 2026, the former first-round pick may find himself focusing solely on special teams as his rookie deal winds down.
The 2026 Special Teams Strategy
Under Harbaugh’s guidance, known for his special teams expertise, the Giants are emphasizing roster versatility. By keeping Banks as a dedicated kick returner and dime package corner, they can justify his presence while scouting potential replacements in the 2026 NFL Draft.
If Banks maintains his impressive return stats, he offers a valuable field-position advantage, echoing the impact specialist roles Harbaugh valued with the Ravens. While he may never become the elite corner the Giants hoped for, his ability to electrify on returns could secure his place on the team.