LANDOVER, Md. - The Giants got the kind of finish Sunday that somehow managed to be thrilling, ugly and hard to believe all at once.
After Cam Skattebo put the ball on the turf in overtime, Washington still found a way to waste the opening the Giants had handed them. Jayden Daniels and the Commanders then let the clock bleed all the way to zero on a final snap in field-goal range, and a 27-27 tie was the result at Northwest Stadium.
For the Giants, it was the latest twist in a game they had spent much of the afternoon chasing. For Washington, it was a staggering collapse in a moment that should have ended it.
The Giants nearly gave it away more than once, too. On the Skattebo fumble drive, they were saved when Washington defensive back Jeremy Reaves dropped what should have been a game-ending interception from Jameis Winston.
Winston was still sharp for much of the day, finishing 33 of 54 for 326 yards, three touchdowns and one turnover. He also powered the comeback after the Giants had fallen behind by 14, leading four straight scoring drives to close regulation.
His tying strike came with 1:43 left, a 17-yard touchdown to Malik Nabers up the middle that made it 27-27. Before that, Winston had hit tight end Isaiah Likely for touchdowns of 3 and 17 yards in the second half.
Those scores answered a pair of Daniels runs that cut through the Giants defense. In the third and fourth quarters, Daniels ripped off rushing touchdowns of 38 and 26 yards right up the gut.
The first half was a different story for the Giants, and it left them in a hole. They went to the break down 12-3 because the offense never found a rhythm on the ground or through the air. They had come in intent on controlling the game with the run, but the backfield managed just 11 carries for 21 yards, a miserable 1.9 yards per attempt.
That left Winston dealing with constant long-yardage situations, and Washington’s pass rush and blitz package kept pressing. One of the biggest swings came in the second quarter when K’Lavon Chaisson sacked Winston and Tim Settle recovered the fumble.
The Giants’ defense allowed Washington to strike quickly on the game’s opening possession. Jacory Croskey-Merritt finished a four-play drive with a 33-yard touchdown run straight into the end zone for a 6-0 lead just two minutes in, even with the missed extra point. After that, though, the defense mostly held Washington to field goals, including after Settle’s takeaway put the Commanders at the Giants’ 27-yard line with 1:58 left in the half.
New York had a few wasted chances before halftime, too. On the final possession of the half, Winston made enough throws to give his team life, but Skattebo dropped one pass and Nabers dropped two.
Then Dominic Zvada missed a 57-yard field goal attempt, his second miss of the half after pushing a 50-yarder wide in the first quarter. He did connect from 51 yards for the Giants’ only points before halftime.
Overtime opened badly for New York when Zvada missed a 46-yard field goal wide left. Washington then took over at its own 36 with 7:57 left and only needed a field goal. But on third down, Giants edge rusher Abdul Carter forced a Dyami Brown fumble, and Washington recovered on the Giants’ 46-yard line before eventually punting.
That gave the Giants the ball at their own 9, where Skattebo’s fumble seemed to hand the game back to Washington. Instead, the Commanders’ final possession dissolved into confusion, and the clock expired with no kick attempted.
The Giants also had to survive a bruising night of injuries. Right tackle Jermaine Eluemunor went down with a calf injury, safety Tyler Nubin left with a neck issue, and corner Colton Hood exited with a concussion.
In the end, the Giants walked away with a tie, and some breathing room in the division for now. Their 3-1-1 record leaves them ahead of the Eagles at 2-3, the Cowboys at 2-3 and the last-place Commanders at 1-3-1.
In Other News...
Giants Already Have A Debate Around Their Expensive New Punter
The Giants invested heavily in Jordan Stout this offseason, bringing in the veteran punter to help change field position and make a hidden part of the game more reliable. Through his first stretch, the early review has been less about raw leg strength and more about whether the operation is actually doing its job, because punting in this league is judged as much by placement and coverage as by hang time or distance.
Stout has gotten off to a solid enough start to keep the conversation going, with multiple punts pinned deep and only one touchback, but the fuller picture still depends on how the return game and coverage unit hold up around him. Coach John Harbaugh has been clear that a punter's value does not live in isolation, and for a Giants team that paid for an upgrade, the debate now is whether the return on that investment will be measured in booming kicks or in consistently better field position. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Suddenly Have A Pass Rush Problem They Couldnt Afford
The Giants defensive front took another hit this week when Chauncey Golston was placed on injured reserve, a move that only sharpens the concern around a unit already leaning thin. New York has been trying to piece together enough reliable depth up front, and losing another lineman forces the team to reshuffle again just as the schedule keeps asking more of the pass rush.
To help cover the immediate need, the Giants elevated outside linebacker Trace Ford and receiver Dalen Cambre from the practice squad for Sundays game. Fords call-up gives the defense another body on the edge for now, though it does not lock him into anything beyond this week, leaving New York still searching for a cleaner answer to its depth problem. [Read more 🡒]
Arvell Reese Has A Chance To Change This Giants Rivalry Fast
Arvell Reese has already given the Giants a useful early-season jolt on defense, and now the rookie linebacker is stepping into a game plan that could test him in a bigger way. Through the first four weeks, Reese has looked like a player the Giants can trust, and Week 5 brings a divisional setting that puts a premium on discipline, pursuit and making one of the leagues most dangerous young quarterbacks work for every yard.
Washingtons passing game is not at full strength, which only heightens the importance of keeping Jayden Daniels from turning broken plays into momentum-shifting gains. If the Giants can limit his ability to improvise, Reese could end up at the center of a fast-moving rivalry game where one rookie defender has a chance to shape how the whole afternoon feels. [Read more 🡒]