Giants Kicking Problem Is Now Changing Games And Tough Decisions

Despite rookie kicker Dominic Zvada's struggles on the right hash mark, the Giants remain hopeful that a supportive approach from coach John Harbaugh will lead to a turnaround and strategic improvements.

The Giants are no longer guessing about Dominic Zvada’s problem. They know where it’s happening.

After another miss in Thursday night’s three-point loss to the Washington Commanders, the rookie kicker’s season has become less about raw talent and more about a very specific flaw: every one of his six misses has come from the right hash. Three have sailed wide right. Three have hooked wide left.

“There is an issue on the right hash, no question,” John Harbaugh said Friday.

Harbaugh has stayed with Zvada through the rough patches, and he doubled down again after the latest miss - a 33-yarder that came at extra-point distance and helped swing the game. The coach made it clear he isn’t ready to pull the plug on a rookie who had looked sharp for most of the spring and summer.

“You can’t, as soon as a guy doesn’t make a play, start firing people left and right. Especially your kicker who’s a rookie,” Harbaugh said.

“So, I’m confident he’s going to become a good kicker. I mean, at some point in time, if it doesn’t happen, it doesn’t happen.

But I’m not going to panic halfway through the season when a guy’s made a bunch of kicks, if that’s what you’re inferring we should be doing. We’re just not going to knee jerk it like that.

He’s going to make kicks. He’s going to make a lot of kicks.

I believe in him. I think he’s really good and really talented.

We’re going to give him an opportunity to do it, and it’s up to him to do it.“

Still, the mechanics are the issue now, not the mystery. Harbaugh said the Giants are looking at Zvada’s plant foot and trying to clean up the inconsistency.

“There’s a technique issue there with his plant foot that we’re kind of looking at,” Harbaugh said on Friday. “And he needs to clean that up from a consistency standpoint.

He knows that. Popped up again in that one kick there.”

That’s a sharp turn from where Zvada was earlier in the year. He won the kicking job over Ben Sauls after a strong spring and summer, then opened the season 9-for-9. Since then, though, he’s made only 8 of his last 14 attempts.

The misses have mattered. Zvada’s struggles were a major part of why the Giants tied one game with Washington and lost another instead of winning both. He missed three kicks in the Week 5 tie, then missed again Thursday in a game the Giants dropped by three.

And his recent struggles may have affected more than the scoreboard. The Giants punted three times inside Washington territory on Thursday night, from the 37-, 41- and 46-yard lines. Two of those situations would have meant kicks from inside 60 yards, a range the Giants have already asked Zvada to handle nine times this season.

Harbaugh said those decisions were tied to distance, weather and field position.

“Well, let’s look at the distances. Why don’t you go back and give me the distances.

I don’t have it in front of me. What were those field goals have been?

They were like high 50s, weren’t they? 55 plus,” Harbaugh said.

“It’s kind of a risk-reward. I’m not saying that he can’t make those kicks, but it’s a windy night and it’s a field position game in some ways.

It’s a big risk there, too. Sometimes it’s better to play a field position game.

“So those were toss up kind of calls probably at least, probably leaning toward punting, but I’m not saying we shouldn’t have gone for them or couldn’t have kicked them either way. The one question is, “should you have gone for it?”

The next question is, “should you have kicked the field goals?” That’s the follow-up question.

I don’t know. The other question could have been if we’d have missed the field goal, maybe you should have punted it down in there and played the field position game.

So they’re all kind of coin flip type of decisions.”

The analytics side of the story is straightforward, even if the choices aren’t. The three punts came in these spots: Giants 0, Commanders 0; fourth-and-7 at the Washington 37 with 11:28 left in the first quarter.

Commanders 17, Giants 14; fourth-and-3 at the Washington 46 with 14:15 left in the fourth quarter. Giants 21, Commanders 17; fourth-and-5 at the Washington 41 with 1:54 left in the fourth quarter.

That’s where the conversation lands now. Not on whether Harbaugh should have punted or kicked in each spot, but on the bigger problem underneath all of it: Zvada’s misses are forcing the Giants into tougher decisions and leaving points on the field.

In a division race that looks headed for the wire, that kind of margin matters. The question now is how much longer the Giants can keep giving Zvada room to sort it out.

In Other News...

Giants Loss To Washington Exposed A Hard Truth About This Roster

The NFL trade deadline came and went without the Giants making a move, despite plenty of fan chatter about possible swings for names like Jeffery Simmons, Jonathan Taylor and Bijan Robinson. After the loss to Washington, that quiet deadline looks a little less like missed opportunity and a little more like a reality check for a roster still trying to find its footing.

Around the NFC, other teams pushed chips in with aggressive trades, but the Giants are not in that same tier yet. Their defeat against the Commanders underscored a hard truth about where this rebuild stands: there is still a gap between being interesting and being ready to contend for a championship. [Read more 🡒]

Malik Nabers Sparks Giants Accountability Debate After Frustrating Loss

Malik Nabers comments after the Giants loss to Washington added another layer to an already frustrating finish, and not just because of the result. The rookie receiver pointed to the teams final-drive decisions, suggesting New York needed to be smarter about how it handled the moment instead of rushing to get into the end zone too quickly.

The reaction was immediate, with fans splitting over whether Nabers was speaking honestly about a bad sequence or stepping into territory that should have stayed in the huddle. Some took issue with him sounding like he was questioning J.J. McCarthys choices while not owning enough of his own missed chances, turning a postgame gripe into a broader accountability debate around a team still searching for answers. [Read more 🡒]

Giants May Have Found Their Lead Back But One Thing Is Missing

The Giants backfield took a clear turn in Week 10, with Devin Singletarys role shrinking while Cam Skattebo handled the bulk of the work. Skattebo responded with a productive day, piling up 21 touches, 122 scrimmage yards and two touchdowns, enough to reinforce the idea that the rookie may already be the teams lead runner.

Still, the picture is not fully settled. Skattebo has been effective, but the Giants have not yet seen the kind of explosive element that can change a game in a hurry, and Tyrone Tracy Jr. is expected back from injured reserve to add another layer to the rotation. If Tracy can return and complement Skattebo, New York may finally have a backfield that offers both steadiness and a little more juice. [Read more 🡒]