The Giants spent the offseason testing the market for Kayvon Thibodeaux, and the answer came back loud enough to settle the debate. New York wanted a third-round pick. Nobody stepped up with that kind of offer, and the former No. 5 overall pick stayed put.
That outcome leaves Thibodeaux in a strange but useful spot as the Giants head into the Dallas opener. He’s third on the edge depth chart, carrying fully guaranteed money, and the chances of a midseason trade are basically nonexistent.
But standing pat here wasn’t a sign of hesitation from Joe Schoen. It was the front office recognizing that selling him now would mean taking far less than the player is worth to this roster.
The key is the contract. Thibodeaux is set to play 2026 on a fully guaranteed $14.75 million fifth-year option, a number the Giants already locked in after drafting Abdul Carter.
That is starter-level money for someone who no longer opens games as a starter, which is exactly why the idea of moving him for a Day 2 pick had some logic earlier in the offseason. But logic changes fast when the market won’t cooperate.
A healthy, 25-year-old former top-five edge rusher is not the sort of player a contender hands over for a third-rounder and hopes to replace on the cheap. With John Harbaugh taking over, the Giants believe they can contend right away, and that makes Thibodeaux more valuable on the roster than he was in trade talks.
Spotrac pegs his open-market value at a four-year, $85 million deal, or about $21.3 million per year. Compared with the $14.75 million the Giants owe him in 2026, that gap is the whole story. New York is effectively getting a season of premium edge insurance at backup pricing, and the trade market never came close to matching that.
The 2025 season is what dragged his value down, not what defined him. Thibodeaux finished with 2.5 sacks in 10 games before a shoulder injury landed him on injured reserve.
His 58.0 PFF pass-rush grade ranked 93rd among 115 qualified edge defenders, the worst mark of his career and the number skeptics are quickest to cite. Even so, he still produced 32 total pressures on 494 snaps while playing through the injury, which is a much better reflection of his season than the sack total alone.
The bigger picture is why the Giants didn’t flinch. Over the previous two seasons, Thibodeaux racked up 17.0 sacks combined, including a career-best 11.5 in 2023.
He has 23.5 career sacks through four seasons. That’s the resume of a player whose down year came with a clear explanation, not a player whose ceiling has disappeared.
The Giants also have a rotation that makes him too useful to treat like a spare part. Brian Burns, Abdul Carter, and Thibodeaux accounted for 2,201 of the Giants’ 2,465 defensive snaps last season under new coordinator Dennard Wilson.
That kind of workload only works if all three are available. Burns posted 16.5 sacks in 2025, second in the NFL, after signing a five-year, $141 million deal.
Carter, meanwhile, flashed immediately with 66 pressures and an 84.5 PFF pass-rush grade as a rookie, and a bigger Year 2 jump would only increase the demand on the group.
That’s what makes Thibodeaux matter here. The Giants do not need him to be the centerpiece.
They need him to keep the edge room from falling apart when the inevitable bumps and bruises hit. A healthy third starter behind Burns and Carter is not excess.
It’s protection.
The numbers make that plain. Burns finished with 16.5 sacks, 53 pressures, and a 71.5 PFF pass-rush grade.
Carter had 4.0 sacks, 66 pressures, and an 84.5 grade. Thibodeaux’s 2.5 sacks and 32 pressures came in a shortened, injury-affected season, along with that 58.0 grade that does not tell the whole story.
So when the Giants found no team willing to meet their asking price, the right move was to hold. They kept a former top-five pick on guaranteed money instead of dumping him for pennies on the dollar. For a pass rush built around three edge players logging almost every meaningful snap, that was the smart non-move.
In Other News...
Giants Suddenly Have A Receiver Decision They Can't Play Safe
Calvin Austin IIIs season-ending ACL injury changed the Giants receiver picture in a hurry, creating a hole the staff can no longer cover by simply spreading snaps around and hoping for the best. With depth suddenly under pressure, the team now has to decide how to replace Austins work in a way that helps the offense in the short term while still giving it a real chance to learn something about the players behind him.
Malachi Fields has pushed his way into that conversation after a strong preseason, and the next step may be less about easing him in than about giving him a clearer lane to show what he can handle. The Giants have reason to be cautious with a young receiver group, but this is also the kind of opening that can force a more honest evaluation of who belongs in a larger role. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Need More Than Familiarity From Darnell Mooney Now
Darnell Mooneys path into the Giants offense comes with a built-in advantage, at least on paper. General manager Joe Schoen pointed to Mooneys productive years under Matt Nagy, noting that the receiver already knows the system and could be able to help after Calvin Austin IIIs injury opened the door for more competition at the position.
The Giants, though, still have to find out whether that familiarity turns into something useful on game day. Mooney is on the active roster and is expected to compete for playing time, but the real question is whether his past with Nagy can translate into meaningful contributions in this offense, where experience is only part of the equation. [Read more 🡒]
Darnell Mooney Suddenly Has A Giants Chance He Can't Waste
A season-ending injury to Calvin Austin III has suddenly opened the door for Darnell Mooney to step into a much larger role with the Giants, and the timing could hardly be more important. Mooney is now positioned to be the primary slot receiver, giving him a chance to become a real part of the offense rather than just another name on a crowded depth chart.
The fit is not entirely new for him, either. Mooney has played in the slot before under offensive coordinator Matt Nagy during their time together in Chicago, so the Giants are not asking him to learn everything from scratch. Even after a quiet preseason and some early uncertainty about his roster spot, the teams depleted wide receiver group should give him opportunities this season, which is why this chance feels so significant. [Read more 🡒]