With the Giants set to see the Cardinals this week, the conversation starts in a familiar place for Arizona: which version shows up?
That was the first issue raised in the weekly “5 questions” exchange with Seth Cox of SB Nation’s Revenge of the Birds, and his answer was blunt. Arizona’s 31-7 loss to Seattle and its 36-30 defeat against San Francisco told very different stories, but Cox said the offense has been a little more revealing than the scoreboard.
The Cardinals threw it 52 times for 280 yards against the 49ers, and while the raw production looked solid, Cox said the passing game has functioned more like a run game than a true downfield threat. He pointed to Arizona being the second-worst team in explosive plays and said the offense often seems to play conservatively rather than attacking defenses and forcing mistakes.
That approach, he said, also fits the game script when the Cardinals fall behind. Opponents can let Arizona chip away because the drives eat clock, and they know their own offense is likely to answer quickly.
The discussion then shifted to one of the biggest decisions the Cardinals made: taking Jeremiyah Love third overall. Cox said the reaction from fans is mostly positive because Love was viewed as a blue-chip prospect and looks like he can become very good to great in the NFL. But he also said there’s still a split over whether that was the right place to spend such a high pick, especially with Arizona’s defense looking like maybe the worst in the NFL if it isn’t actively tanking like the Dolphins.
He mentioned Arvell Reese, Sonny Styles and even Caleb Downs as players who might have helped more right away, though he didn’t suggest anyone is panicking about the pick. The feeling, he said, is more that people are watching closely.
If Arizona could pluck one player from the Giants’ roster, Cox went straight to Jermaine Eluemunor, especially now that Brian Burns is gone. He called right tackle a major need for the Cardinals and said Eluemunor has a case not just as the best right tackle in the NFL, but maybe the best tackle overall.
That kind of addition, Cox said, would help address the same problems tied to Love’s selection and Arizona’s lack of explosive offensive plays.
As for Mike LaFleur, Cox’s read was that the coach is under pressure from day one. He noted that the average Cardinals head coach since the move to Arizona has lasted three years, and many haven’t come close to establishing long-term stability. Even so, he said LaFleur looks capable of being a really good NFL head coach, aside from the procedural and pre-snap penalties that need cleaning up.
Still, Cox said the Cardinals have to show they can handle the basics and compete inside their division before LaFleur can be seen as the long-term answer.
For the Giants, the path to an upset is pretty clear. Cox said Arizona’s defense has been mostly bad and at times downright atrocious, and he pointed to a staggering stat from the loss to San Francisco: the Cardinals ran 31 more plays and had the ball 17 more minutes than the 49ers, yet were still outgained by 72 yards.
That, he said, is hard to believe.
If Arizona can’t slow down what has been an impotent Giants offense since the injury to Jaxson Dart, Cox doesn’t see a reliable way for the Cardinals to stop anyone. He said the Giants were solid against the Chargers, and with the way they are coached and the way they can run the ball - something Arizona cannot stop - this should be a competitive game.
His blueprint for New York was straightforward: force Jacoby Brissett to stay in the pocket, take away the short passing game, and make him push the ball downfield.
On the other side, he said Arizona should lean on Cam Skattebo and Najee Harris and build from play action.
In Other News...
Odell Beckham Jr. Just Reopened An Ugly Giants Decision
Odell Beckham Jr.s brief return to the Giants has already become another awkward chapter in a relationship that once defined the franchises offense. After limited playing time and just one target in three games, New York moved on after Week 3, a decision that coach John Harbaugh framed as a matter of fit and timing, saying Beckham did not match what the team had planned.
Beckham made it clear on social media that the mid-season exit stung, especially after what was supposed to be a meaningful homecoming. For the Giants, the episode only adds more weight to a move that was supposed to help in the short term but instead reopened one of the more uncomfortable conversations around how this reunion was handled. [Read more 🡒]
Giants May Have Found An Unexpected Answer In A Chaotic Win
The Giants 36-24 win over the Cardinals in Week 4 was the kind of game that revealed as much about the roster as the score did. New York had already been forced to absorb the season-ending loss of pass rusher Brian Burns and the release of wide receiver Odell Beckham Jr., yet it still steadied itself after falling behind early and found a way to take control.
One of the biggest reasons was rookie linebacker Arvell Reese, who made multiple defensive plays and looked like he belonged in the middle of the chaos. For a team dealing with injuries and turnover, those kinds of contributions matter, and they helped push the Giants to 3-1 while also hinting that they may have stumbled onto an unexpected answer on defense. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Defense Faces A Rookie Test That Could Expose A Problem
The Giants are about to get a close look at the kind of rookie who can make a defense feel older than it is. After using the No. 5 pick on edge rusher Arvell Reese, New York now turns its attention to Arizona and the Cardinals No. 3 selection, Jeremiyah Love, a back who has already shown he can matter as both a runner and a receiver.
For a Giants defense dealing with injuries, the matchup comes at a tricky time. New York has done a decent job keeping opponents under control on the ground overall, but recent games have shown a weakness in the way yards are being given up, and Loves versatility creates the sort of test that can expose it if the front seven is a step slow. [Read more 🡒]