The Giants don’t need to decide whether Jordan Stout can punt. Thursday night already answered that. What they need is a better plan for what kind of punt they’re asking him to hit when the field gets tight.
That distinction matters because Stout showed both sides of the job in the same game. He blasted one from the Giants’ 7 that traveled 68 yards, and Washington still managed only 12 yards on the return.
Earlier, he punted from the Giants’ 25 and forced the Commanders to start at their 12. Those are the kinds of kicks that change a game without much drama attached to them.
The late one is the one that will stick in people’s heads, though. Up four with 1:54 left, New York punted on fourth-and-five from the Washington 41.
The NFL gamebook had the ball going out at the 29. Washington then picked up 33 yards on defensive pass interference on the next play and scored three snaps later.
That sequence gave the Commanders a better starting point than they should have had, but the penalty and touchdown weren’t the result of Stout missing his spot.
That’s why the bigger lesson isn’t about trust. It’s about target.
Stout came into Week 10 leading the league at 51.8 yards gross and 44.5 net, and his five punts Thursday averaged 44.8 gross with two downed inside the 20 and a 38.2 net. Those numbers tell part of the story, but not the whole thing.
A punt from the 41 is a different animal than one launched from deep in your own end. From that spot, a 35-yard ball that dies in the right area is far more useful than another booming kick that sails too far.
If the Giants want to get more out of that situation, the landing zone should be part of the conversation. A spot between the numbers and the sideline around the opponent’s 10 to 15 would keep coverage close enough to challenge a bounce and force the returner into a decision. It’s not risk-free, but it avoids asking the punter to do two jobs at once: pin the ball perfectly and still cover a huge chunk of field.
John Harbaugh put it this way Friday while talking about fourth-down decisions in windy conditions: “Sometimes it’s better to play a field position game,”
He was speaking about punts versus long field goals, not specifically about Stout’s final kick. Still, the point applies. If field position is the reason to punt, then the landing spot has to be part of the math.
None of that means the Giants should scrap the punt in that kind of situation. On fourth-and-five Thursday, the decision to kick was reasonable.
But if the coverage unit can’t get there or the conditions make a precise sideline punt unrealistic, that’s a separate question from whether the call itself was sound. On fourth-and-two across midfield with a play the offense likes, going for it might be the better answer.
On Thursday’s fourth-and-five, the punt was defensible.
The real takeaway is simpler: New York has a punter who can get the ball out of trouble. The next step is giving him a short-field target that doesn’t require perfection on the boundary and then judging the result by where the opponent starts.
In Other News...
Giants Playoff Hopes Suddenly Ride On A Brutal Sunday Scoreboard
The Giants loss to Washington left them in a tougher spot in the NFC East, and now their playoff path is tied as much to the scoreboard elsewhere as to anything they do themselves. They are still chasing both the Commanders and Cowboys in the division, which means every result around the NFC starts to matter a little more than it should in December.
Sundays slate is loaded with games that could reshape the picture, with the Giants needing help from matchups involving the 49ers, Packers, Vikings, Lions, Patriots, Seahawks and Rams. Its the kind of late-season setup that turns a rooting interest into a full-time job, and for New York, the margin for error has already gotten thin enough that one bad result can echo for the rest of the week. [Read more 🡒]
Ex-Giants Keep Raising Questions About What New York Let Go
Several former Giants were in the spotlight in Week 10, and the list was long enough to make New Yorks roster decisions feel worth revisiting. Tommy DeVito got a chance with the Patriots after an injury to their starting quarterback, finishing 12 of 24 with a touchdown and an interception, while Odell Beckham Jr. was back on the Vikings practice squad and Joshua Ezeudu continued contributing for the Chiefs.
Elsewhere, Daniel Jones had a rough outing for the Colts, Xavier McKinney kept making plays for the Packers with a league-best sixth interception, and Daniel Bellinger found the end zone for the Titans. It was the kind of Sunday that reminded Giants fans how much former pieces are still showing up around the league, and how some of the names New York moved on from are still leaving a mark in different uniforms. [Read more 🡒]
Giants May Have Just Settled A Safety Debate For Good
ArDarius Washington may have changed the conversation in a single Sunday. In Week 10, he was all over the field for the Giants, finishing with seven tackles, two pass breakups and an interception while handling 78.2% of the defensive snaps. For a secondary that has been searching for stability, that kind of workload says plenty about where the coaching staff is leaning.
Tyler Nubin, meanwhile, saw only one defensive snap, a sharp contrast that makes the picture at safety look a lot clearer heading into the stretch run. Washington now appears to be the favorite to start alongside Jevon Holland the rest of the way, and after a performance like that, it is easy to see why the Giants may be ready to settle the debate. [Read more 🡒]
