The Giants have a deadline problem sitting right on the edge of their defense, and it comes with Kayvon Thibodeaux’s name on it.
Through six games, Thibodeaux has played 277 defensive snaps and still hasn’t recorded a sack. He’s started four of those games, handled 73% of the defensive snaps, and is doing it on the final year of his rookie deal while carrying a $14.751 million fifth-year option. That’s starter money, and so far the production hasn’t matched it.
New York’s record softens the blow a bit. At 4-2-1, the Giants are alone in first place in the NFC East, which gives the front office some room to live with an awkward situation.
But the clock is ticking anyway, because the trade deadline hits Nov. 10.
That puts Joe Schoen and the Giants in a spot where they have to decide whether Thibodeaux is part of the future or a piece they should move before his value slips further.
The numbers tell the story plainly. Thibodeaux broke out with 11.5 sacks in 2023, but his production has gone backward every season since. The decline has been steep enough that this year - the one when he’s supposed to be positioning himself for his next contract - has become his worst stretch yet.
Kayvon Thibodeaux by season Games Sacks
2022 14 4.0
2023 17 11.5
2024 12 5.5
2025 10 2.5
2026 6 0.0
The larger problem is that the Giants’ pass rush has thinned out around him. Brian Burns was the engine until he tore his ACL in the Week 3 win over Tennessee, ending his season and removing the team’s most productive edge presence.
Then linebacker Tremaine Edmunds, one of the co-leaders in sacks, landed on injured reserve. That stripped another source of pressure from Dennard Wilson’s blitz-heavy defense.
As a result, the Giants have only nine sacks as a team, and the co-leaders are sitting at just 2.0 apiece. First-round rookie Abdul Carter helped against Houston with six pressures and a pile of holding penalties, while fellow rookie Arvell Reese chipped in a half-sack. The young players are carrying more of the load than the veterans were supposed to.
This is why Thibodeaux keeps coming up as a possible move. ESPN’s Dan Graziano said last spring he was “more likely to be traded during the season rather than over the summer,” and that possibility is now here. Schoen has already made his philosophy clear when it comes to the front four: “you can’t have enough pass rushers.”
Even so, there’s a real downside to shopping him now. Trading an edge rusher after a sackless start means dealing from a weak position, and a team trying to stay in the NFC East race may decide it needs another body on the edge more than it needs a draft pick. Thibodeaux built his market off that 11.5-sack season, but that was three years ago, and he has 11 games left to change the conversation.
The Giants can keep winning the division with this defense. The question is whether they can trust it when the stakes rise in January.
For Thibodeaux, the pressure is no longer theoretical. The clock is already running.
In Other News...
Giants In First Place But One Roster Decision Just Got Tougher
The Giants have spent enough time grinding through quarterback uncertainty and lineup shuffling that first place in the NFC East feels earned rather than accidental. J.J. McCarthy gave the offense a lift in his first start, Jaxson Dart is still working his way back in rehab, and the defense has continued to hold up its end, with Deonte Banks turning in effective coverage against the Texans as the team kept building momentum.
A few roster calls have helped shape that rise, too, including the decision to move on from running back Najee Harris before the recent win. But the next layer of roster management is where things get trickier now, especially with Tyrone Tracys situation putting added pressure on the backfield picture and forcing the Giants to weigh depth against the urgency of staying on top in a division race that suddenly looks very real. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Bye Week Lead Faces Its Biggest Test Yet
The Giants spent their Week 8 bye in a place they have not been in for a while: sitting atop the NFC East with a 4-2-1 record and a two-game cushion. It has not been a comfortable kind of lead, though. Their wins have come by narrow margins, and the defense has had to keep finding answers through takeaways even while dealing with injuries to key players.
Now the schedule tightens fast, with division games looming that could reshape the race in a hurry. For a team that has already lived on close calls, the next stretch is the real measure of whether this early advantage means something lasting or just a brief turn in the standings. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Face A Defining NFC East Stretch With Pressure Suddenly Rising
The Giants head into their bye week on the heels of a win over the Houston Texans, but the break only delays what looks like a pivotal stretch for their season. With the NFC East still within reach and John Harbaugh stressing how important the coming division games are for the teams place in the race, the next few weeks carry a different kind of weight for a club that has spent much of the fall trying to establish itself at the top of the standings.
The pressure only grows because the Cowboys have recently moved ahead of the Giants as the betting favorite in the division, even though New York still holds the lead in the standings. The schedule coming out of the bye leaves little room to settle in, and the Giants will also have to manage their backfield depth after placing Tyrone Tracy Jr. on injured reserve, a reminder that every edge matters as the division chase tightens. [Read more 🡒]