Giants Have A Dominic Zvada Problem With No Easy Fix

While fans call for change, the New York Giants juggle limited options to replace struggling kicker Dominic Zvada.

The New York Giants are hearing the noise around Dominic Zvada, and it’s getting louder by the week.

That’s what happens when a rookie kicker starts 9-for-9, then follows it by making just 8 of his next 14 field-goal attempts over four games. Zvada’s trouble from the right hash mark has become the talking point, and plenty of fans are already ready to move on. But as easy as it is to say a kicker should be replaced, finding a clearly better answer is a different story.

“You can’t, as soon as a guy doesn’t make a play, start firing people left and right,” said head coach John Harbaugh.

So if the Giants were to seriously look elsewhere, what exactly would they be getting into?

Ben Sauls is the name that keeps coming up first. The left-footed kicker was a bright spot for the Giants late in the 2025 season, when he hit all 15 of his kicks over a three-game stretch, including eight field goals and seven extra points. That perfect run has made him an easy favorite for fans who want Zvada gone.

But there’s a catch. Sauls’ longest kick in that stretch was a 45-yard extra point, while Zvada has already been asked to try nine field goals from 50 yards or longer and has made six of them. Sauls may have the leg for those attempts, but he has not shown it in an NFL game.

There’s also the matter of how the two kickers got here in the first place. Sauls dealt with his own technique problems in the spring and summer while competing with Zvada.

He was rough in the spring, often pushing kicks left. He improved in the summer, but he still wasn’t as steady as Zvada.

That made the decision pretty straightforward at the time.

Sauls is not on a 53-man roster or a practice squad right now, and he may have only had one or two tryouts.

Then there’s Zane Gonzalez, who is 31 and has spent eight years in the league with plenty of ups and downs. He made 19 of 22 field goals for the Atlanta Falcons in 2025, good for 86.4%, but the Miami Dolphins waived him Monday after he missed two field goals and an extra point in a 24-22 loss to the Indianapolis Colts. Gonzalez had taken over for Riley Patterson earlier this season.

That makes it tough to argue Gonzalez would clearly be an upgrade over Zvada.

The veteran market doesn’t exactly offer a clean fix, either. Matt Prater, now 42, made 18 of 20 kicks for the Buffalo Bills last season, and he hasn’t finished below 80% in a season since 2020.

He also drilled a 57-yard kick for the Arizona Cardinals in 2024, so there’s still some leg left there. Still, the question hangs in the air: are the Giants really in a spot where swapping Zvada for a kicker nearly 20 years older makes sense?

Graham Gano is also available, and he misses football.

There are practice squad options too. Harrison Mevis is on the Baltimore Ravens’ practice squad after going 5 of 9 for the Los Angeles Rams earlier this year.

Justin Tucker is with the Kansas City Chiefs. Once the best kicker in the game for Harbaugh’s Baltimore Ravens, Tucker made just 22 of 30 field goals in 2024, was suspended in 2025 related to sexual misconduct allegations, and turns 37 in a few days.

For now, the conclusion is hard to avoid: there doesn’t appear to be a no-brainer replacement waiting out there. The Giants may be better off sticking with Zvada and trying to work through the right-hash issue rather than pretending the cure is obvious.

In Other News...

Giants Are Gambling On Another Return Game Fix

The Giants made another tweak to their return game on Tuesday, parting ways with wide receiver and return specialist Charlie Jones and defensive back Nikko Reed while bringing in defensive back Tavierre Thomas and signing Xavier Gipson off the Philadelphia Eagles practice squad. It is the kind of roster shuffle that usually says as much about urgency as it does about depth, and for New York it fits a familiar pattern of searching for a steadier answer in the kicking game.

Gipson is no stranger to the Giants, and that familiarity likely helped make him an appealing pickup as the team keeps trying to settle the back end of its roster and its return duties at the same time. The catch is that his track record has included ball security concerns, which means this move comes with obvious risk even as the Giants hope the upside is enough to justify another swing. [Read more 🡒]

Kayvon Thibodeaux Just Put One Giants Decision Under A Brighter Spotlight

Kayvon Thibodeauxs future has become one of the more interesting decisions facing the Giants as the season moves along, and NFL insider Jordan Schultz recently suggested there is at least a scenario in which the edge defender could be back in New York next year. Schultz pointed to what he sees as a noticeable emotional and maturity jump from Thibodeaux, a development that matters for a player whose talent has never really been in question.

The bigger issue for the Giants is less about whether Thibodeaux has helped and more about how they sort out a crowded, expensive position group. Even with underwhelming production by the numbers this season, he has still been part of a defense that has held up better than expected at times, which only makes the contract conversation more complicated as the team weighs what it can afford to keep together. [Read more 🡒]

Giants May Need An Uncomfortable Plan To Crack Jacksonville

Cam Wards Week 10 line against Jacksonville offered a useful blueprint for anyone trying to move the ball on the Jaguars. The Titans quarterback completed 20 of 21 passes for 122 yards and a touchdown, leaning heavily on short throws in a 40-23 loss, and the approach at least showed one way to keep the game manageable against a defense that has been strong against the run.

For the Giants, the uncomfortable part is that a similar plan may be their best path, even if it is not the kind of attack they usually want to feature. Jacksonville has since added defensive tackle Jordan Davis and safety Jessie Bates III, neither of whom played against Tennessee, which only raises the degree of difficulty for New York as it searches for answers in a matchup that could demand patience and precision more than big plays. [Read more 🡒]