The Giants came out of their Week 10 loss to the Washington Commanders with more than just a 5-3-1 record to sort through. They also got a fresh look at which impending free agents are helping shape this team’s future - and which ones are fading into the background.
Some of the answers are getting clearer by the week. Ar’Darius Washington is forcing his way into a bigger role.
Deonte Banks looks like a player who’s about to cash in. Micah McFadden has become indispensable.
And on the other end of the spectrum, Devin Singletary and John Michael Schmitz are trending toward the exit.
Washington’s rise has been one of the most notable developments on the roster. What started as a rotational role has turned into full-time work over the past month, and he’s earned it.
Against Washington, he made his biggest statement yet in prime time, coming through when the Giants needed him most in the fourth quarter. He helped force a turnover on downs with back-to-back standout plays, then picked off a pass with about two minutes left to give New York a shot to close things out.
Since Week 7, when he moved to the top of the depth chart, he’s been stingy in coverage. Among 73 defensive backs targeted at least 10 times in that span, he’s allowed the second-fewest receiving yards at 43 and owns the second-lowest passer rating allowed at 18.4, behind only Cleveland Browns Pro Bowl cornerback Denzel Ward.
After five seasons overlapping with head coach John Harbaugh in Baltimore, Washington looks like more than a fill-in. He’s pushing Tyler Nubin for the job next to Jevón Holland.
Banks is making a different kind of case. He’s not just holding his own - he’s looking like a legitimate shutdown corner again.
No pass-catcher has topped two catches or 36 receiving yards with Banks as the pre-snap matchup this season, and the numbers back up the eye test. Among 134 defensive backs with at least 20 targets, he ranks 115th in opponent completion percentage at 53.8 and 119th in expected points added per target.
The bigger picture is simple: he’s taking on top receivers and winning enough of those battles to set himself up for a payday in March, whether that comes from the Giants or someone else.
McFadden’s stock is climbing for a different reason. He re-signed last offseason after reportedly having “quite a few suitors,” and that decision has paid off for both sides.
With Tremaine Edmunds lost in mid-October to a season-ending torn chest muscle, McFadden stepped into the middle of the defense and took over the green dot responsibilities with little drop-off. Over the Giants’ last three games, he’s piled up 29 tackles, including four for loss, along with three quarterback hits, one sack and a fumble recovery.
He turns 27 in January, and it would not be a surprise if his price tag starts to outgrow what the front office wants to spend.
Singletary, meanwhile, is barely part of the conversation anymore. He was a healthy scratch earlier this season, and even with Tyrone Tracy Jr. out because of a hamstring injury, the Giants barely used him against the Commanders.
He played just five offensive snaps, ran two routes and finished with one three-yard carry. At this point, he’s mostly limited to special teams work.
The message is pretty plain: “Motor’s” best days are behind him, and the Giants don’t appear interested in leaning on him as the playoff race tightens.
Mooney hasn’t done enough to change that kind of outlook either. He has flashed on the occasional deep ball for Big Blue, but he hasn’t been a reliable option.
More than half of his routes have come from the slot, and while that usually suggests a steadier stream of touches, the Giants’ setup makes that harder to come by. Isaiah Likely is a major part of the passing game and lines up inside on more than 80 percent of his routes, while Malik Nabers commands a huge share of the offense on his own.
Through nine games, Nabers and Likely have accounted for more than half of the team’s receiving workload and production combined. Add in third-round rookie Malachi Fields, who continues to show big-play ability and has seen a small uptick in opportunities since the bye, and Mooney is left as the fourth option at best.
Against Washington, he caught two of five targets for eight yards and did not score.
Schmitz’s situation looks even more straightforward. He lost his job in September and has barely been involved since Bryan Hudson took over at center.
As a holdover from the previous regime, he hasn’t made much of an impression on the new staff. He entered the league with a reputation as one of the more pro-ready prospects in the 2023 draft class, but that hasn’t shown up in New York.
At this point, both sides may be better off moving on.
In Other News...
Giants Playoff Hopes Suddenly Ride On A Brutal Sunday Scoreboard
The Giants loss to Washington left their playoff path looking far less forgiving, and now the margin for error is shrinking fast. With the NFC East race still bunched behind the Commanders and Cowboys, New York is no longer just worrying about its own results. It is also watching the rest of the conference with unusual intensity, knowing that a handful of upcoming games could reshape the postseason picture around them.
Sundays scoreboard now matters almost as much as anything the Giants do themselves, with matchups involving the 49ers, Packers, Vikings, Lions, Patriots, Seahawks and Rams all carrying some weight for New Yorks hopes. For a team trying to stay in the hunt after a costly divisional loss, the next stretch is as much about scoreboard watching as it is about what happens on the field. [Read more 🡒]
Ex-Giants Keep Raising Questions About What New York Let Go
Several former Giants were in the spotlight during Week 10, and the list only added to the familiar feeling in New York that talent has a way of surfacing after it leaves. Tommy DeVito got a chance with the New England Patriots after their starter went down, finishing 12 of 24 with a touchdown and an interception, while Odell Beckham Jr. landed back on the Minnesota Vikings practice squad as his next stop came into focus.
Elsewhere, Daniel Jones had a rough outing for the Indianapolis Colts, Xavier McKinney picked off his league-best sixth pass for the Green Bay Packers, and Daniel Bellinger found the end zone for the Tennessee Titans. Joshua Ezeudu has also been contributing for the Kansas City Chiefs, another reminder that a number of ex-Giants are still finding roles elsewhere while New York keeps sorting through what it let go. [Read more 🡒]
Giants May Have Just Settled A Safety Debate For Good
Ar'Darius Washington made a strong case in Week 10, and he did it in a way the Giants could not ignore. He finished with seven tackles, two pass breakups and an interception, while also handling 78.2% of the defensive snaps, a clear sign the coaching staff leaned on him in a big spot.
Tyler Nubin, meanwhile, was on the field for only one defensive snap, which only sharpened the picture at safety for New York. Washington now looks like the favorite to start alongside Jevon Holland the rest of the season, giving the Giants a much clearer answer at a spot that had been worth watching closely. [Read more 🡒]
