Rainy conditions, a rebuilding opponent, and preseason caveats all make it easy to shrug off the Giants’ 26-3 win over the Dolphins. But even in a game that’s tough to read too deeply, the Pro Football Focus numbers still paint a pretty clear picture: the Giants controlled the line of scrimmage, got real production from a handful of roster battles, and saw a defense packed with defensive backs stack up some eye-catching grades.
Start with J.C. Davis, who was the day’s loudest winner.
The left tackle played 81 snaps against Miami and came away with an 89.3 overall grade, with his pass-blocking and run-blocking marks landing almost evenly in elite territory. That’s a sharp contrast from last week, when Davis posted an excellent 84.6 pass-blocking grade against Minnesota but a rough 41.7 in run blocking.
The rest of the offensive line held up well, too. Aaron Stinnie, Evan Neal, Joshua Ezeudu, Lucas Patrick, and Marcus Mbow all checked in in the 70s, and every one of them graded above average in pass protection except Neal, who landed right around average.
One sack sequence stood out, though. PFF charged Neal with responsibility for the sack, and the clip backed that up, but there was enough confusion on the play that Ezeudu looked like he should have been tagged for half of it as well.
At receiver, Dalen Cambre kept making a case for himself. He graded above 70 for a second straight week and caught all three of his targets after seeing just one ball thrown his way last week. With the receiver room crowded, his path to surviving cuts looks steep, though he’s also gotten some special teams work this summer and could still be in the mix for a roster spot there or as a practice squad option.
Darius Slayton also gave himself a needed boost, finishing with 4 catches on 6 targets for 58 yards. Whether that helps him lock down a roster spot or simply boosts his trade value as a potential chip for a 2027 draft pick, it was a good showing.
Calvin Austin, another receiver fighting for a spot, posted a 61.4 grade with 2 catches on 2 targets for 24 yards. Darnell Mooney did not play after Harbaugh excused him so he could serve as best man at his brother’s wedding.
Odell Beckham Jr. came in just under the 60 mark at 58.4. He caught 2 of his 4 targets for 17 yards and flashed on one catch after the reception, slipping tacklers in tight space for extra yardage.
He also had another downfield rep last week-style where he shook a defensive back free but never got the ball. The play everyone will remember, though, was the end-zone drop that should have been a touchdown.
PFF hit him with a 29.9 drop grade because of it.
In the backfield, Eric Gray led the running backs with a 70.4 grade, doing his best work late when the game had already drifted out of focus. Devin Singletary followed at 64.7 and appears to be firming up his spot. Tyrone Tracy was on the wrong end of the ledger with a 40.9 grade after an unforced fumble.
Defensively, Dru Phillips turned in the kind of PFF line that can split a room. He led all Giants defenders with a massive 96.3 grade, even though the most memorable snap for many fans will be the 30-yard completion he allowed while in position to break it up.
But Phillips also forced two fumbles on the day, and the Giants recovered both. That’s the tradeoff with him right now: big impact around the line of scrimmage, but clear vulnerability when he’s asked to defend downfield.
The rest of the secondary was loaded with strong numbers. Tyler Nubin followed up his first preseason game with another excellent performance, grading 90.3.
Deonte Banks bounced back from a rough coverage outing against Minnesota with an 85.3. Greg Newsome II, in his first action as a Giant, came in at 79.9.
Beau Brade scored 79.0 and Nic Jones 75.5, giving the Giants a rare run where the top six defensive grades all belonged to defensive backs.
The front seven had its share of good work, too. Arvell Reese graded 75.8, Caleb Murphy 75.4, and Micah McFadden 74.5.
Chauncey Golston posted a 73.0 for his second straight solid outing and looks like a name worth tracking this season as a possible beneficiary of the coordinator change. Among the 2026 draftees, Jack Kelly was quieter than he was in his debut but still finished with a solid 63.7, while Bobby Jamison-Travis posted a 58.9 and recorded a sack.
At the bottom of the defensive grades, Darius Alexander came in last at 39.7. He did get a QB hit and a hurry, but his tackling grade was a brutal 22.9 and he missed one tackle. That’s the part of his game that still has to catch up if he’s going to become more than a situational interior lineman.
In Other News...
Giants Suddenly Have Real Roster Pressure At Two Key Positions
The Giants have made plenty of noise in the preseason, finishing 3-0 and drawing a top ranking from Pro Football Focus, but the more useful takeaway for Brian Dabolls staff is what those games revealed about the edges of the roster. Preseason wins always come with an asterisk, yet the performances did help clarify where New York has real depth and where the competition is suddenly a lot tighter than it looked a few weeks ago.
The running back group and the defensive front both stood out as spots where recent play has forced some hard conversations ahead of final cuts. Players on both units made cases in live action, which is exactly what a team wants this time of year, but it also means the Giants may have more tough decisions than expected when they sit down to set the roster. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Suddenly Have A Darnell Mooney Problem They Can't Ignore
Darnell Mooneys absence last week was excused for a good reason, since the Giants receiver was on approved leave to serve as best man at his brothers wedding. Even so, it arrived at a time when the veteran had already had a quiet training camp, and that combination has only sharpened the scrutiny around where he stands as the team moves toward the start of the season.
Mooney was supposed to be part of a receiver group the Giants hoped could settle in quickly, but the recent roster churn has kept his spot from feeling settled at all. If the front office decides to keep exploring other options, or if Mooney ends up moving on, it could reshape the depth chart and leave Week 1 looking different than expected. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Face Tough Final Roster Calls After Crowded Preseason Battles
After the preseason win over the Dolphins, the Giants are heading into the part of August that can be more revealing than the games themselves. John Harbaugh and Joe Schoen now have to sort through a crowded roster and turn a long list of encouraging preseason performances into the league-mandated 53-man group, with the most crowded debates shaping up at running back, wide receiver, offensive line and cornerback.
Some spots look fairly clear, but plenty of players are still living on the edge of the bubble as the front office weighs who fits best and who has done enough to stick. Harbaugh has already pointed to several strong individual showings, yet the final calls are still pending, which leaves the Giants with more good problems than bad ones and a handful of tough decisions still ahead. [Read more 🡒]