Malik Nabers’ name shouldn’t be sliding down trade boards the way it has.
The Giants wideout looked like he was barreling toward superstardom after a rookie season that put him in the conversation with the league’s top receivers. Then came the sophomore year that never really got going, cut short by a torn ACL and meniscus in Week 4. Since then, plenty of people seem to be acting like that first season never happened.
That’s the part that’s hard to square. Nabers is showing up outside top-10 position lists, and ESPN’s Bill Barnwell left him off a group of players he believes “would land a first-round pick (or more) via trade.” Barnwell’s reasoning centered on health, writing, “The hope will be that Nabers recovers and lives up to the promise we saw before the injury, but it would be tough to justify trading a first-round pick for him before that happens.”
Sure, any team trying to pry him away from New York has to factor in the injury. He’s coming off a major knee issue and has already had two surgeries since.
Availability matters. No one is pretending otherwise.
But there’s a difference between caution and underrating the player. Nabers turns 23 on July 28, and he still comes with at least two more years of cost-friendly team control, plus a club option for 2028. That kind of age and contract situation matters a lot in trade conversations, especially when the talent is this obvious.
And the recent market for big-name players backs that up. The Giants sent Dexter Lawrence to the Cincinnati Bengals for the 2026 No. 10 overall pick, which became offensive lineman Francis Mauigoa.
The Philadelphia Eagles got a 2028 first-rounder and a 2027 fifth-round pick from the New England Patriots for A.J. Brown.
Lawrence and Brown were both entering their age-29 seasons, and both were considered distressed assets when they moved. Brown also reportedly has a degenerative knee condition that the Patriots knew about. Even with those concerns, teams still paid up.
Barnwell noted that front offices have gotten “really aggressive targeting proven pass-rushers and defensive disruptors,” but the same logic applies to established receivers. Brown is one example. Nabers, younger and under contract, and able to beat any coverage, belongs in that same tier of trade value at the very least.
The lesson is simple: the injury changed the conversation, but it shouldn’t have erased the value.
In Other News...
Giants May Have Found A Long Term Answer Up Front
The Giants defensive front still feels like a work in progress heading toward 2026, even after recent additions meant to help the linebackers behind it. There is talent in the mix, but there are also real questions about how much pressure this group can generate and whether the veteran pieces can hold up long enough for the next wave to arrive.
One reason the conversation keeps circling back to the draft is the appeal of a young interior defender who already flashes the kind of size, quickness and disruptive ability teams covet up front. He has shown enough pass-rush juice and run defense promise to look like a possible long-term answer, even if the next step is proving he can clean up the finer points and turn that upside into something more dependable. [Read more 🡒]
Shaun O'Hara Sparks Giants Hype Around Late Round Rookie
The Giants used a sixth-round pick on offensive tackle JC Davis, and the early buzz around him has already started to build thanks to a familiar voice. Former Giants center Shaun OHara dug into Daviss college tape and came away impressed by the rookies physical profile, pointing to traits like his arm length and overall demeanor while also noting there is still room for refinement as he makes the jump to the NFL.
For now, Davis is lined up to begin the season as a backup behind Andrew Thomas at left tackle, which is exactly the kind of spot where a late-round lineman can spend weeks waiting for a chance. But with tackle depth always a concern over the course of a season, the Giants will be watching closely to see whether Davis can turn that early optimism into real value if his number is called. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Suddenly Have Another Kicking Battle On Their Hands
The Giants kicking job has quietly turned into one of the more interesting camp battles on the roster, with incumbent Ben Sauls now sharing the runway with rookie Dominic Zvada. Zvada arrived with a decorated college rsum from Michigan, and he backed it up during minicamp by looking as clean and consistent as advertised, while Sauls brings the one thing no rookie can match right away: NFL game experience and a strong finish to last season.
Sauls late-season run gave the Giants reason to believe they already had a steady answer in place, but Zvadas early showing made this a lot less settled than it looked a few weeks ago. The real separator may not come until training camp and preseason games, when the Giants finally get a longer look at which leg holds up best under pressure. [Read more 🡒]