Giants Fans Still Cant Ignore What That Washington Loss Exposed

A roundup of the latest developments in the world of the NY Giants, from strategic missteps and personnel controversies to evaluations of key players and their future with the team.

Good morning, Giants fans. The week’s headlines around Big Blue are a mixed bag of debate, second-guessing and a little outside noise, with the Commanders loss still hanging over everything.

One of the louder storylines comes from a Pro Football Network report that lit up the J.J. McCarthy conversation.

In the piece, ex-NFL scout Daniel Jeremiah Middlekauff made a blunt claim about Vikings coach Kevin O’Connell’s feelings toward McCarthy, saying: “And if I wanted to speak for you in regard to J.J. McCarthy, you hated his guts as a player.

You couldn’t (expletive) stand him,” Middlekauff insisted. “Because you were clearly the driving force for making him the third quarterback and helping the GM: ‘We gotta get this guy out of here.

Fifth-round pick, I’ll drive him to the airport.’ Which is fine.

You’re not the first or the last coach to feel that way toward a QB.”

He continued, “It’s happened before and it will happen again. Then a couple of weeks later, when you’re starting Carson Wentz, who couldn’t hit water from the middle of the ocean and then J.J.’s making plays like that for (Matt) Nagy and Greg Roman you’re like, ‘Uh, no one is acting like this guy is Joe Montana, but this is way better than what we had.’”

Another piece of the Giants news cycle came from The Athletic, where the discussion centered on Colts personnel decisions and what they mean for Daniel Jones and Jonathan Taylor. The report said the Colts weren’t eager to move Jones, who played well before his torn Achilles last year, and noted that players are often better two years removed from Achilles tears.

Jones tore his 11 months ago, and while his recent play hasn’t been strong, the hope is that he’ll improve. The same report also said Jones needs a quality running back in Taylor, and that league sources aren’t sure a deal of a second and fifth would be on the table for Taylor in March.

It also framed the Colts’ approach as one that preserves flexibility, with the possibility that the next GM could be Dodds himself or an outsider.

The Giants’ own game management also stayed under the microscope after Thursday night. Giants on SI questioned why New York didn’t go with the tush push on 3rd-and-1, even though the numbers favored it. The piece framed it as a head-scratcher and said there’s a theory behind the decision.

The Daily News took the broader view of the loss to Washington, writing that the Commanders didn’t win Thursday’s game - the Giants lost it. The story pointed to John Harbaugh and his staff giving the franchise a coaching advantage this season, but said the decision-making came up short in the biggest game so far.

It also noted that the Giants still appear to be moving in the right direction, even after the 24-21 defeat, and that Harbaugh needs to learn from his mistakes if the first-place Giants (5-3-1) want to win the NFC East. The fourth-quarter conservative calls on offense stood out most.

Then there was the Jameis Winston chatter. Former Pro Bowler Donte Whitner went on ESPN’s “Get Up” and said he would move on from Winston after the “Who Let the Dogs Out” stunt.

“I’d cut Jameis Winston this morning,” Whitner said. “It was so unrealistic.

You have 10 other guys out there and guys on defense that are busting their butt every week, and it’s very hard and difficult to win a game in the National Football League. So, when you get up there - first and foremost, whoever says hut 1, hut 2, hut 3?

That’s 1950s football!

“And then when you go into ‘Who Let the Dogs Out’? Are you serious?

He’s clearly just trying to go viral on social media while they’re trying to win a football game. He’d get his pink slip this morning.”

The New York Post also published a piece arguing there are plenty of reasons to believe these Giants have what it takes, while still making clear the weekend off would have felt a lot better had they finished off the Commanders. Instead, the 24-21 loss landed as their most agonizing and wasteful of the season.

From Big Blue View, the site also asked readers to submit a question.

In Other News...

Giants Playoff Hopes Suddenly Ride On A Brutal Sunday Scoreboard

The Giants loss to Washington left their playoff path looking far less forgiving, and now the margin for error is shrinking fast. With the NFC East race still bunched behind the Commanders and Cowboys, New York is no longer just worrying about its own results. It is also watching the rest of the conference with unusual intensity, knowing that a handful of upcoming games could reshape the postseason picture around them.

Sundays scoreboard now matters almost as much as anything the Giants do themselves, with matchups involving the 49ers, Packers, Vikings, Lions, Patriots, Seahawks and Rams all carrying some weight for New Yorks hopes. For a team trying to stay in the hunt after a costly divisional loss, the next stretch is as much about scoreboard watching as it is about what happens on the field. [Read more 🡒]

Ex-Giants Keep Raising Questions About What New York Let Go

Several former Giants were in the spotlight during Week 10, and the list only added to the familiar feeling in New York that talent has a way of surfacing after it leaves. Tommy DeVito got a chance with the New England Patriots after their starter went down, finishing 12 of 24 with a touchdown and an interception, while Odell Beckham Jr. landed back on the Minnesota Vikings practice squad as his next stop came into focus.

Elsewhere, Daniel Jones had a rough outing for the Indianapolis Colts, Xavier McKinney picked off his league-best sixth pass for the Green Bay Packers, and Daniel Bellinger found the end zone for the Tennessee Titans. Joshua Ezeudu has also been contributing for the Kansas City Chiefs, another reminder that a number of ex-Giants are still finding roles elsewhere while New York keeps sorting through what it let go. [Read more 🡒]

Giants May Have Just Settled A Safety Debate For Good

Ar'Darius Washington made a strong case in Week 10, and he did it in a way the Giants could not ignore. He finished with seven tackles, two pass breakups and an interception, while also handling 78.2% of the defensive snaps, a clear sign the coaching staff leaned on him in a big spot.

Tyler Nubin, meanwhile, was on the field for only one defensive snap, which only sharpened the picture at safety for New York. Washington now looks like the favorite to start alongside Jevon Holland the rest of the season, giving the Giants a much clearer answer at a spot that had been worth watching closely. [Read more 🡒]